THE NECESSITY, LOGIC, AND FORMS OF REPLICATION

被引:167
作者
Bettis, Richard A. [1 ]
Helfat, Constance E. [2 ]
Shaver, J. Myles [3 ]
机构
[1] Univ N Carolina, Kenan Flagler Business Sch, Chapel Hill, NC USA
[2] Tuck Sch Business Dartmouth, 100 Tuck Hall, Hanover, NH 03755 USA
[3] Univ Minnesota, Carlson Sch Management, Minneapolis, MN 55455 USA
关键词
replication; cumulative research; statistical evidence; guidelines; quasi-replication; STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT; DIVERSIFICATION; PERFORMANCE; KNOWLEDGE; ACQUISITION; ASYMMETRY; TESTS;
D O I
10.1002/smj.2580
中图分类号
F [经济];
学科分类号
02 ;
摘要
Research summary: A replication study assesses whether the results of a particular prior study can be reproduced, including in new contexts with different data. Replication studies are critical for building a cumulative body of research knowledge. This article discusses and provides a typology of different types of replications, compares replications with other approaches to cumulating knowledge, and provides guidelines toward producing high-quality replication studies. The articles in this Special Issue provide examples of replication studies in strategic management. Managerial summary: Research studies sometimes draw implications for managerial practice. A single empirical study, however, is specific to a particular context, relies on a particular set of data, and uses a particular research design. As a consequence, a single study cannot establish whether the findings generalize to a different context and whether the research design is robust to alternative approaches. Replication studies can help to establish the range of applicability of prior studies and better support what implications can be drawn for managerial practice. Copyright (C) 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
引用
收藏
页码:2193 / 2203
页数:11
相关论文
共 28 条
  • [1] Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science
    Aarts, Alexander A.
    Anderson, Joanna E.
    Anderson, Christopher J.
    Attridge, Peter R.
    Attwood, Angela
    Axt, Jordan
    Babel, Molly
    Bahnik, Stepan
    Baranski, Erica
    Barnett-Cowan, Michael
    Bartmess, Elizabeth
    Beer, Jennifer
    Bell, Raoul
    Bentley, Heather
    Beyan, Leah
    Binion, Grace
    Borsboom, Denny
    Bosch, Annick
    Bosco, Frank A.
    Bowman, Sara D.
    Brandt, Mark J.
    Braswell, Erin
    Brohmer, Hilmar
    Brown, Benjamin T.
    Brown, Kristina
    Bruening, Jovita
    Calhoun-Sauls, Ann
    Callahan, Shannon P.
    Chagnon, Elizabeth
    Chandler, Jesse
    Chartier, Christopher R.
    Cheung, Felix
    Christopherson, Cody D.
    Cillessen, Linda
    Clay, Russ
    Cleary, Hayley
    Cloud, Mark D.
    Cohn, Michael
    Cohoon, Johanna
    Columbus, Simon
    Cordes, Andreas
    Costantini, Giulio
    Alvarez, Leslie D. Cramblet
    Cremata, Ed
    Crusius, Jan
    DeCoster, Jamie
    DeGaetano, Michelle A.
    Della Penna, Nicolas
    den Bezemer, Bobby
    Deserno, Marie K.
    [J]. SCIENCE, 2015, 349 (6251)
  • [2] STRUCTURAL HOMOPHILY OR SOCIAL ASYMMETRY? THE FORMATION OF ALLIANCES BY POORLY EMBEDDED FIRMS
    Ahuja, Gautam
    Polidoro, Francisco, Jr.
    Mitchell, Will
    [J]. STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2009, 30 (09) : 941 - 958
  • [3] International expansion through start-up or acquisition: A learning perspective
    Barkema, HG
    Vermeulen, F
    [J]. ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 1998, 41 (01) : 7 - 26
  • [4] LOCALIZED COMPETITION AND ORGANIZATIONAL FAILURE IN THE MANHATTAN HOTEL INDUSTRY, 1898-1990
    BAUM, JAC
    MEZIAS, SJ
    [J]. ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCE QUARTERLY, 1992, 37 (04) : 580 - 604
  • [5] Friends or strangers? Firm-specific uncertainty, market uncertainty, and network partner selection
    Beckman, CM
    Haunschild, PR
    Phillips, DJ
    [J]. ORGANIZATION SCIENCE, 2004, 15 (03) : 259 - 275
  • [6] CREATING REPEATABLE CUMULATIVE KNOWLEDGE IN STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT: A CALL FOR A BROAD AND DEEP CONVERSATION AMONG AUTHORS, REFEREES, AND EDITORS
    Bettis, Richard A.
    Ethiraj, Sendil
    Gambardella, Alfonso
    Helfat, Constance
    Mitchell, Will
    [J]. STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2016, 37 (02) : 257 - 261
  • [7] QUALITATIVE EMPIRICAL RESEARCH IN STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
    Bettis, Richard A.
    Gambardella, Alfonso
    Helfat, Constance
    Mitchell, Will
    [J]. STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2015, 36 (05) : 637 - 639
  • [8] Theory in strategic management
    Bettis, Richard A.
    Gambardella, Alfonso
    Helfat, Constance
    Mitchell, Will
    [J]. STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2014, 35 (10) : 1411 - 1413
  • [9] THE SEARCH FOR ASTERISKS: COMPROMISED STATISTICAL TESTS AND FLAWED THEORIES
    Bettis, Richard A.
    [J]. STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2012, 33 (01) : 108 - 113
  • [10] Wealth and the effects of founder management among IPO-stage new ventures
    Certo, ST
    Covin, JG
    Daily, CM
    Dalton, DR
    [J]. STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2001, 22 (6-7) : 641 - 658