Comparison of four staining methods for detection of mast cells in equine bronchoalveolar lavage fluid

Mast cells normally are present in equine bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), but usually represent < 2% of all cells in healthy horses. An increased percentage of mast cells has been associated with airway hyperactivity and inflammatory airway diseases, but marked differences are reported between studies in normal and diseased horses. Because an abnormal mast cell count may be of clinical relevance, we compared the ability of a fast Romanowsky method to stain mast cell granules With that of 3 metachromatic stains: automated Romanowsky, May-Grunwald Giemsa, and toluidine blue stains. The BALF cells from 24 horses were studied. A differential cell count was performed blindly on 400 cells. The percentages of mast cells obtained were analyzed by means of repeated-measures analysis of Variance and Fischer's PLSD test. The Bland and Altman method Was Used to assess agreement among stains. The mean percentage of mast cells in BALF was significantly lower with the fast Romanowsky than with the automated Romanowsky, May-Grunwald Giemsa, and toluidine blue stains. With the fast Romanowsky stain, the metachromatic granules of mast cell, were not stained. and their identification was based oil morphologic criteria. Toluidine blue staining allowed detection of the highest mean percentage of mast cells. but Was inadequate for performing a differential cell count on other cell types. In conclusion, fast Romanosky stain may be inadequate for detection of Mast Cells in equine BALF, whereas automated Romanowsky, May-Grunwald Giemsa, and toluidine blue stains provide metachromatic staining of mast cell granules.