Placebo controlled evaluation of Xilei San, a herbal preparation in patients with intractable ulcerative proctitis

被引:38
作者
Fukunaga, Ken [1 ]
Ohda, Yoshio [1 ]
Hida, Nobuyuki [1 ]
Iimuro, Masaki [1 ]
Yokoyama, Yoko [1 ]
Kamikozuru, Koji [1 ]
Nagase, Kazuko [1 ]
Nakamura, Shiro [1 ]
Miwa, Hiroto [2 ]
Matsumoto, Takayuki [2 ]
机构
[1] Hyogo Coll Med, Dept Internal Med, Div Lower Gastroenterol, Nishinomiya, Hyogo 6638501, Japan
[2] Hyogo Coll Med, Dept Internal Med, Div Upper Gastroenterol, Nishinomiya, Hyogo 6638501, Japan
关键词
Herbal medicine; placebo controlled trial; topical medication; ulcerative proctitis; Xilei San; CONTROLLED TRIAL; 5-AMINOSALICYLIC ACID; INDIGO NATURALIS; MESALAZINE SUPPOSITORIES; RANDOMIZED-TRIAL; DISTAL COLITIS; ENEMAS; EFFICACY; THERAPY; SULPHASALAZINE;
D O I
10.1111/j.1440-1746.2012.07215.x
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Background and Aim: Topical mesalamine or corticosteroid has shown efficacy in patients with ulcerative proctitis, but patients often become refractory to these interventions. Xilei San is a herbal preparation with evidence of anti-inflammatory effects. We evaluated the efficacy of topical Xilei San in ulcerative proctitis patients. Methods: In a double blind setting, 30 patients with intractable ulcerative proctitis despite >= 4 weeks of topical mesalamine or corticosteroid were randomly assigned to True (n = 15) and placebo (n = 15). Patients in True received suppository Xilei San (0.1 g/dose per day of Xilei San), the other 15 received placebo suppository. The initial efficacy was evaluated on day 14. Primary endpoint of the trial was avoiding relapse during 180 days, relapse meant recurrence of active disease. Riley's index was applied for endoscopic and histological evaluations, while patients' quality of life was evaluated by an inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire. Results: On day 14, the number of patients who achieved remission, clinical activity index <= 4 in True was significantly higher versus placebo (P < 0.04). Likewise, at day 180, an 81.8% of patients in True were without relapse versus 16.7% in placebo (P < 0.001). Further, significant endoscopic (P < 0.01), histological (P < 0.02) and inflammatory bowel disease questionnaire (P < 0.04) improvements were observed in True, but not in placebo. Conclusions: This is the first controlled investigation showing significant clinical and endoscopic efficacy for Xilei San in patients with intractable ulcerative proctitis. Topical Xilei San was well tolerated, and was without safety concerns.
引用
收藏
页码:1808 / 1815
页数:8
相关论文
共 29 条
[1]  
Amano K, 2000, ANN REPORT RES COMMI, P137
[2]   Short chain fatty acid rectal irrigation for left-sided ulcerative colitis: A randomised, placebo controlled trial [J].
Breuer, RI ;
Soergel, KH ;
Lashner, BA ;
Christ, ML ;
Hanauer, SB ;
Vanagunas, A ;
Harig, JM ;
Keshavarzian, A ;
Robinson, M ;
Sellin, JH ;
Weinberg, D ;
Vidican, DE ;
Flemal, KL ;
Rademaker, AW .
GUT, 1997, 40 (04) :485-491
[3]   5-AMINOSALICYLIC ACID SUPPOSITORIES IN THE MANAGEMENT OF ULCERATIVE-COLITIS [J].
CAMPIERI, M ;
GIONCHETTI, P ;
BELLUZZI, A ;
BRIGNOLA, C ;
TORRESAN, F ;
TAMPIERI, M ;
IANNONE, P ;
MIGLIOLI, M ;
BARBARA, L .
DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 1989, 32 (05) :398-399
[4]   Inhibitory Effect of Indigo Naturalis on Tumor Necrosis Factor-α-Induced Vascular Cell Adhesion Molecule-1 Expression in Human Umbilical Vein Endothelial Cells [J].
Chang, Hsin-Ning ;
Pang, Jong-Hwei Su ;
Yang, Sien-Hung ;
Hung, Chi-Feng ;
Chiang, Chi-Hsin ;
Lin, Tung-Yi ;
Lin, Yin-Ku .
MOLECULES, 2010, 15 (09) :6423-6435
[5]   Maintenance treatment of ulcerative proctitis with mesalazine suppositories: A double-blind placebo-controlled trial [J].
d'Albasio, G ;
Paoluzi, P ;
Campieri, M ;
Porro, GB ;
Pera, A ;
Prantera, C ;
Sturniolo, GC ;
Miglioli, M .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1998, 93 (05) :799-803
[6]   MESALAZINE SUPPOSITORIES VERSUS HYDROCORTISONE FOAM IN PATIENTS WITH DISTAL ULCERATIVE-COLITIS - A COMPARISON OF THE EFFICACY AND PRACTICALITY OF 2 TOPICAL TREATMENT REGIMENS [J].
FARUP, PG ;
HOVDE, O ;
HALVORSEN, FA ;
RAKNERUD, N ;
BRODIN, U .
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1995, 30 (02) :164-170
[7]  
FERBER KH, 1987, J ENVIRON PATHOL TOX, V7, P73
[8]   A suppository chinese medicine (Xilei-san) for refractory ulcerative proctitis: A pilot clinical trial [J].
Fukunaga, Ken ;
Hida, Nobuyuki ;
Ohnishi, Kunio ;
Ohda, Yoshio ;
Yoshida, Koji ;
Kusaka, Takeshi ;
Jinno, Yoshio ;
Nagase, Kazuko ;
Nakamura, Shiro ;
Kadobayashi, Muneo ;
Miwa, Hiroto ;
Matsumo, Takayuki .
DIGESTION, 2007, 75 (2-3) :146-147
[9]   A randomized trial of nicotine enemas for active ulcerative colitis [J].
Ingram, JR ;
Thomas, GAO ;
Rhodes, J ;
Green, JT ;
Hawkes, ND ;
Swift, JL ;
Srivastava, ED ;
Evans, BK ;
Williams, GT ;
Newcombe, RG ;
Courtney, E ;
Pillai, S .
CLINICAL GASTROENTEROLOGY AND HEPATOLOGY, 2005, 3 (11) :1107-1114
[10]   QUALITY-OF-LIFE - A VALID AND RELIABLE MEASURE OF THERAPEUTIC EFFICACY IN THE TREATMENT OF INFLAMMATORY DOWEL DISEASE [J].
IRVINE, EJ ;
FEAGAN, B ;
ROCHON, J ;
ARCHAMBAULT, A ;
FEDORAK, RN ;
GROLL, A ;
KINNEAR, D ;
SAIBIL, F ;
MCDONALD, JWD ;
VALBERG, B ;
LAUPACIS, A ;
RIDDELL, R ;
SEATON, T ;
SOMERS, S ;
DIRKS, J ;
FEUTREN, G ;
JEEJEEBHOY, K ;
SACKETT, D ;
DANDAVINO, R ;
GHENT, CN ;
GRYNOCH, JR ;
HOLBROOK, AM ;
KIBERD, BA ;
KNETEMAN, N ;
LEVINE, M ;
MANUEL, M ;
MUIRHEAD, NN ;
SAIPHOO, CS ;
SOMERVILLE, PJ ;
CAMERON, L ;
LOCKWOOD, T ;
SEGLENIEKS, E ;
TAYLORDOLMER, K ;
CHERRY, R ;
FISHER, D ;
KIRDEIKIS, P ;
MAHACHAI, V ;
SEDENS, T ;
SHERBANIUK, R ;
THOMSON, A ;
WENSEL, R ;
CASTELLI, M ;
COLLINS, S ;
CROITORU, K ;
CROWE, S ;
DONNELLY, M ;
GOODACRE, R ;
HUNT, R ;
LUMB, B ;
ROSSMAN, R .
GASTROENTEROLOGY, 1994, 106 (02) :287-296