Comparative evaluation of 14 immunoassays for detection of antibodies to the human T-lymphotropic virus types I and II using panels of sera from Sweden and West Africa

BACKGROUND: A new generation of assays for the detection of human T-lymphotropic virus types I and II (HTLV-I/II) antibodies has been released. These assays incorporate HTLV-I- and HTLV-II-specific antigens, and some are based on new assay principles. Comparative evaluation data that include these new as well as previous assays are limited. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Fourteen HTLV antibody assays were evaluated by using well-characterized panels of sera from Guinea-Bissau, West Africa, and Sweden. The sera included 127 HTLV-I-positive and 62 HTLV-II-positive specimens, as well as 919 consecutive negative samples. RESULTS: The sensitivity for HTLV-I was 100 percent for all assays, except one, which repeatedly missed one sample. The sensitivity for HTLV-II varied between 86 percent and 100 percent. In general, new-generation assays incorporating HTLV-II-specific antigens, and some of which are based on new assay principles, had a higher sensitivity for HTLV-II than previous assays, which mainly are based on HTLV-I antigens. The specificity was generally higher for new assays than for the previous versions. Testing of Swedish blood donor sera gave higher specificities (94-1.00%) than did that of African specimens (90-99.7%). Most assays had low delta values (DVs), although there was a tendency toward increased DVs for the new generation of assays. Only two of the new generation of assays came close to a combination of high sensitivity for both HTLV-I and HTLV-II, high specificity, positive and negative predictive values, and high DVs. CONCLUSION: The sensitivity for HTLV-I was generally high and appears to have improved for HTLV-II with the introduction of a new generation of assays incorporating HTLV-II-specific antigens. However, some assays still give false-negative results on HTLV-II-positive specimens. The specificities and the DVs were generally higher for the new assays than for the previous versions.