A comparative study of fluorescent singlet oxygen probes in plant leaves

Four fluorescent singlet oxygen sensors: DanePy, its oxalate salt, Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green and MVP, were infiltrated into tobacco leaves and tested for toxicity, subcellular localization, light sensitivity and capacity to trap the singlet oxygen produced in photoinhibition. For reference, a broad sensitivity free radical probe, TEMPO-9-AC, was also included. Photochemical yield was approximately 15% and 10% inhibited by Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green and MVP, respectively, but was not significantly affected by the other probes. Under photoinhibitory conditions, brought about by irradiating lincomycin-treated leaves with strong photosynthetically active radiation, DanePy and Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green were responsive. Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green was also reactive to low, non-photoinhibitory light exposure of the leaf, which was not characteristic to the other probes. MVP did not respond to singlet oxygen which can partly be explained by a possible attenuation of its blue emission in the leaf, as shown by the example TEMPO-9-AC. DanePy-oxalate did not respond to photosynthetic singlet oxygen due to lack of its penetration into photosynthetic tissue and hence could be useful in detecting any singlet oxygen which escapes from a chloroplast initiation site. DanePy was localized in the chloroplasts, while Singlet Oxygen Sensor Green was mainly found in the epidermal cells preferentially associated with the nucleus.