Why are we weighting? The role of importance ratings in quality of life measurement

被引:103
作者
Trauer, T [1 ]
Mackinnon, A [1 ]
机构
[1] Mental Hlth Res Inst, Parkville, Vic, Australia
关键词
importance ratings; multiplicative composites; quality of life; satisfaction;
D O I
10.1023/A:1013159414364
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
Many Quality of Life (QoL) instruments ask respondents to rate a number of life domains in terms of satisfaction and personal importance, and derive weighted satisfaction scores by multiplying the two ratings. This paper demonstrates that this practice is both undesirable and unnecessary. QoL domains are selected on the basis of their inherent importance, rendering separate importance rating partially redundant. Weighted scores present difficulties in interpretation. Further, we show that multiplicative composites have undesirable psychometric properties. There is evidence that multiplicative composites have little or no advantage over unweighted ratings in correlational or predictive studies. Apart from the face validity and the intuitive appeal of multiplying satisfaction ratings by importance ratings, there appear to be no sound reasons for doing so, and several good reasons not to do so.
引用
收藏
页码:579 / 585
页数:7
相关论文
共 31 条
[1]  
Andrew F., 1976, SOCIAL INDICATORS WE
[2]  
[Anonymous], BEHAV THERAPIST
[3]   A NEW PATIENT FOCUSED INDEX FOR MEASURING QUALITY-OF-LIFE IN PERSONS WITH SEVERE AND PERSISTENT MENTAL-ILLNESS [J].
BECKER, M ;
DIAMOND, R ;
SAINFORT, F .
QUALITY OF LIFE RESEARCH, 1993, 2 (04) :239-251
[4]   INTEGRATING BOTTOM-UP AND TOP-DOWN THEORIES OF SUBJECTIVE WELL-BEING - THE CASE OF HEALTH [J].
BRIEF, AP ;
BUTCHER, AH ;
GEORGE, JM ;
LINK, KE .
JOURNAL OF PERSONALITY AND SOCIAL PSYCHOLOGY, 1993, 64 (04) :646-653
[5]  
CAMPBELL A, 1976, QUALITY AM LIFE
[6]   THINGS I HAVE LEARNED (SO FAR) [J].
COHEN, J .
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGIST, 1990, 45 (12) :1304-1312
[7]   THE COMPREHENSIVE QUALITY-OF-LIFE SCALE (COMQOL) - INSTRUMENT DEVELOPMENT AND PSYCHOMETRIC EVALUATION ON COLLEGE STAFF AND STUDENTS [J].
CUMMINS, RA ;
MCCABE, MP ;
ROMEO, Y ;
GULLONE, E .
EDUCATIONAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL MEASUREMENT, 1994, 54 (02) :372-382
[8]  
CUMMINS RA, 1995, QUALITY LIFE HANDICA
[9]   SUBJECTIVE WELL-BEING [J].
DIENER, E .
PSYCHOLOGICAL BULLETIN, 1984, 95 (03) :542-575
[10]   UNIT WEIGHTING SCHEMES FOR DECISION MAKING [J].
EINHORN, HJ .
ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR AND HUMAN PERFORMANCE, 1975, 13 (02) :171-192