Comment on 'Molecular arrangement in water: random but not quite'

被引：17

作者：

Skinner, Lawrie B. ^{[1
]}

Benmore, Chris J. ^{[2
]}

Parise, John B. ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] SUNY Stony Brook, Inst Mineral Phys, New York, NY 11794 USA

[2] Argonne Natl Lab, Adv Photon Source, Xray Sci Div, Argonne, IL 60439 USA

来源：

JOURNAL OF PHYSICS-CONDENSED MATTER | 2012年 / 24卷 / 33期

关键词：

RAY-STRUCTURE FACTOR; LIQUID; SCATTERING;

D O I：

10.1088/0953-8984/24/33/338001

中图分类号：

O469 [凝聚态物理学];

学科分类号：

070205 ;

摘要：

Accurate high energy x-ray diffraction data are presented on liquid water measured at room temperature. Sources of both systematic and statistical errors within the experiment are considered and data consistency checks are discussed. It is found that the resulting x-ray pair distribution function is smoothly varying in real space and shows no evidence of small peaks in the 3-5 angstrom region. Our results are in contrast to the recent findings reported in Petkov et al 2012 J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 24 155102.

引用

页数：3

共 14 条

[1] ISOCHORIC TEMPERATURE DIFFERENTIAL OF THE X-RAY STRUCTURE FACTOR AND STRUCTURAL REARRANGEMENTS IN LOW-TEMPERATURE HEAVY-WATER [J].

BOSIO, L ;

CHEN, SH ;

TEIXEIRA, J .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1983, 27 (03) :1468-1475

[2] Small-angle scattering and the structure of ambient liquid water [J].

Clark, Gary N. I. ;

Hura, Greg L. ;

Teixeira, Jose ;

Soper, Alan K. ;

Head-Gordon, Teresa .

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 2010, 107 (32) :14003-14007

[3] X-ray study of the structure of liquid water [J].

Fu, Ling ;

Bienenstock, Arthur ;

Brennan, Sean .

JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS, 2009, 131 (23)

[4]

Haung C, 2012, J CHEM PHYS IN PRESS

[5] The inhomogeneous structure of water at ambient conditions [J].

Huang, C. ;

Wikfeldt, K. T. ;

Tokushima, T. ;

Nordlund, D. ;

Harada, Y. ;

Bergmann, U. ;

Niebuhr, M. ;

Weiss, T. M. ;

Horikawa, Y. ;

Leetmaa, M. ;

Ljungberg, M. P. ;

Takahashi, O. ;

Lenz, A. ;

Ojamae, L. ;

Lyubartsev, A. P. ;

Shin, S. ;

Pettersson, L. G. M. ;

Nilsson, A. .

PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 2009, 106 (36) :15214-15218

[6] Wide-angle X-ray diffraction and molecular dynamics study of medium-range order in ambient and hot water [J].

Huang, Congcong ;

Wikfeldt, K. T. ;

Nordlund, D. ;

Bergmann, U. ;

McQueen, T. ;

Sellberg, J. ;

Pettersson, L. G. M. ;

Nilsson, A. .

PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY CHEMICAL PHYSICS, 2011, 13 (44) :19997-20007

[7] LIQUID WATER - MOLECULAR CORRELATION FUNCTIONS FROM X-RAY DIFFRACTION [J].

NARTEN, AH ;

LEVY, HA .

JOURNAL OF CHEMICAL PHYSICS, 1971, 55 (05) :2263-+

[8] More accurate X-ray scattering data of deeply supercooled bulk liquid water [J].

Neuefeind, J. ;

Benmore, C. J. ;

Weber, J. K. R. ;

Paschek, D. .

MOLECULAR PHYSICS, 2011, 109 (02) :279-288

[9] Experimental determination of the electron density of liquid H2O and D2O [J].

Neuefeind, J ;

Benmore, CJ ;

Tomberli, B ;

Egelstaff, PA .

JOURNAL OF PHYSICS-CONDENSED MATTER, 2002, 14 (23) :L429-L433

[10] Molecular arrangement in water: random but not quite [J].

Petkov, V. ;

Ren, Y. ;

Suchomel, M. .

JOURNAL OF PHYSICS-CONDENSED MATTER, 2012, 24 (15)

← 1 2 →