The temporal development and additivity of plant-soil feedback in perennial grasses

Current knowledge of plant-soil feedback is based largely on single end point studies with soils conditioned by monocultures, but accounting for variability in the ecological impacts of feedback effects may require understanding how feedback develops over time and in multi-species plant communities. To examine temporal development and additivity of feedback, two pairs of native and non-native congeneric grasses were grown alone or in mixtures to create six soil conditioning treatments. We measured plant growth and feedback on the soils over 19 months and addressed whether plant biomass was additive or non-additive between soils treated by mixtures and their constituent monocultures. For native grasses, plant-soil feedback either became progressively more negative through time or switched from neutral to negative. Feedback to non-native grasses was variably neutral to positive. Final biomass of the grasses growing on soils conditioned by mixtures was generally an additive function of growth on soils conditioned by the component monocultures, except native grasses growing in soils conditioned by their own congener mixtures, which were non-additive. Temporal variation and non-additivity in feedback suggest that extrapolation to communities may be complex. More work is needed to assess the generality of temporal and scaling effects.