Overlapping confidence intervals or standard error intervals: What do they mean in terms of statistical significance?

被引:839
作者
Payton, Mark E. [1 ]
Greenstone, Matthew H. [2 ]
Schenker, Nathaniel [3 ]
机构
[1] Oklahoma State Univ, Dept Stat, 301 MSCS Bldg, Stillwater, OK 74078 USA
[2] ARS, USDA, Insect Biocontrol Lab, Beltsville, MD 20705 USA
[3] Natl Ctr Hlth Stat, Off Res & Methodol, Hyattsville, MD 20782 USA
关键词
Confidence intervals; detectability half-life; effective dose; LD50; lethal dose; predator gut analysis; probit analysis; standard error intervals;
D O I
10.1093/jis/3.1.34
中图分类号
Q96 [昆虫学];
学科分类号
摘要
We investigate the procedure of checking for overlap between confidence intervals or standard error intervals to draw conclusions regarding hypotheses about differences between population parameters. Mathematical expressions and algebraic manipulations are given, and computer simulations are performed to assess the usefulness of confidence and standard error intervals in this manner. We make recommendations for their use in situations in which standard tests of hypotheses do not exist. An example is given that tests this methodology for comparing effective dose levels in independent probit regressions, an application that is also pertinent to derivations of LC(50)s for insect pathogens and of detectability half-lives for prey proteins or DNA sequences in predator gut analysis.
引用
收藏
页数:6
相关论文
共 22 条
[1]  
Ahmad M, 2003, J ECON ENTOMOL, V96, P875, DOI 10.1603/0022-0493-96.3.875
[2]   STUDIES ON THE EFFECT OF DELTAMETHRIN SPRAYS ON THE NUMBERS OF EPIGEAL PREDATORY ARTHROPODS OCCURRING IN ARABLE FIELDS [J].
BASEDOW, T ;
RZEHAK, H ;
VOSS, K .
PESTICIDE SCIENCE, 1985, 16 (04) :325-331
[3]   VISUAL ASSESSMENT OF THE SIGNIFICANCE OF A MEAN DIFFERENCE [J].
BROWNE, RH .
BIOMETRICS, 1979, 35 (03) :657-665
[4]   Identifying key cereal aphid predators by molecular gut analysis [J].
Chen, Y ;
Giles, KL ;
Payton, ME ;
Greenstone, MH .
MOLECULAR ECOLOGY, 2000, 9 (11) :1887-1898
[5]  
Croft BA, 1990, ARTHROPOD BIOL CONTR
[6]   Policy forum:: Global food supply -: Food production, population growth, and the environment [J].
Daily, G ;
Dasgupta, P ;
Bolin, B ;
Crosson, P ;
du Guerny, J ;
Ehrlich, P ;
Folke, C ;
Jansson, AM ;
Jansson, BO ;
Kautsky, N ;
Kinzig, A ;
Levin, S ;
Mäler, KG ;
Pinstrup-Andersen, P ;
Siniscalco, D ;
Walker, B .
SCIENCE, 1998, 281 (5381) :1291-1292
[7]   POISONING OF CANADA GEESE IN TEXAS BY PARATHION SPRAYED FOR CONTROL OF RUSSIAN WHEAT APHID [J].
FLICKINGER, EL ;
JUENGER, G ;
ROFFE, TJ ;
SMITH, MR ;
IRWIN, RJ .
JOURNAL OF WILDLIFE DISEASES, 1991, 27 (02) :265-268
[8]   THE GRAPHICAL PRESENTATION OF A COLLECTION OF MEANS [J].
GOLDSTEIN, H ;
HEALY, MJR .
JOURNAL OF THE ROYAL STATISTICAL SOCIETY SERIES A-STATISTICS IN SOCIETY, 1995, 158 :175-177
[9]  
GREENSTONE MH, 1993, ENTOMOL EXP APPL, V68, P1, DOI 10.1007/BF02380575
[10]   Testing the equality of coefficients of variation in K normal populations [J].
Gupta, RC ;
Ma, SC .
COMMUNICATIONS IN STATISTICS-THEORY AND METHODS, 1996, 25 (01) :115-132