Comparison of necessary conditions for typical Takagi-Sugeno and Mamdani fuzzy systems as universal approximators

Both Takagi-Sugeno (TS) and Mamdani fuzzy systems are known to be universal approximators. In this paper, we investigate whether one type of the fuzzy approximators is more economical than the other type. The TS fuzzy systems in this study are the typical two-input single-output TS fuzzy systems: they employ trapezoidal or triangular input fuzzy sets, arbitrary fuzzy rules with linear rule consequent, product fuzzy logic AND, and the centroid defuzzifier. We first establish necessary conditions on minimal system configuration of the TS fuzzy systems as function approximators. We show that the number of the input fuzzy sets and fuzzy rules needed by the TS fuzzy systems depend on the number and locations of the extrema of the function to be approximated. The resulting conditions reveal the strength of the TS fuzzy approximators: only a handful of fuzzy rules may be needed to approximate functions that have complicated formulation hut a few extrema. The drawback, though, is that a large number of fuzzy rules must be employed to approximate periodic or highly oscillatory functions. We then compare these necessary conditions with the ones that we established for the general Mamdani fuzzy systems in our previous papers. Results of the comparison unveil that the minimal system configurations of the TS and Mamdani fuzzy systems are comparable. Finally, we prove that the minimal configuration of the TS fuzzy systems can be reduced and becomes smaller than that of the Mamdani fuzzy systems if nontrapezoidal or nontriangular input fuzzy sets are used. We believe that all the results in present paper hold for the TS fuzzy systems with more than two input variables but the proof seems to be mathematically difficult. Our new findings are valuable in designing more compact Fuzzy systems, especially fuzzy controllers and models which are two most popular and successful applications of the fuzzy approximators.