Vascular Catheter Tip Cultures for Suspected Catheter-Related Blood Stream Infection in the Intensive Care Unit: A Tradition Whose Time Has Passed?

Background: Catheter-related blood stream infections (CR-BSIs) are estimated to occur in 80,000 patients in intensive care units (ICUs) each year in the United States. We sought to determine the clinical utility of vascular catheter cultures in critically ill patients with suspected CR-BSI. Methods: We reviewed retrospectively all positive (>= 15 colony forming units/roll) vascular catheter tip cultures (CTCs) documented over a four-year period in the ICUs of two hospitals. A CR-BSI was defined as matching positive blood and catheter cultures. The time interval between catheter removal and blood culture was recorded. Results: A total of 1,391 CTCs were obtained, of which 468 (34%) were positive and 143 (31% of the positive cultures) were associated with a diagnosis of CR-BSI. In 133 of these 143 cases (93%), the positive blood culture was obtained before or within 24 h after catheter removal and dictated antibiotic therapy. In only 10 of 143 cases (7%) did catheter removal and culture significantly (>1 day) precede the positive blood culture. In 55% of the CR-BSI cases, the catheter was removed empirically and close to the time of blood culture (-1.3 +/- 19.0 h). In the remaining 45%, the catheter was removed clinically (after a blood culture was positive), and this action was more remote in time (23.6 +/- 19.4 h; p < 0.001 vs. empiric removal). Total microbiology laboratory costs for the CTCs were $75,300, and 600 microbiology technician hours were required. Conclusion: In an ICU patient population, only about one-third of vascular catheter cultures were positive, and only about one-third of the positive CTCs were associated with CR-BSI. Ninety-three percent of all CR-BSIs were identified by bacteremia either before or coinciding with catheter removal, and the results of the blood culture dictated antimicrobial therapy. Because CTCs rarely changed therapy, they may not be appropriate in the management of suspected CR-BSI in the ICU setting.