Using deliberate practice framework to assess the quality of feedback in undergraduate clinical skills training

被引:14
作者
Abraham, Reina M. [1 ]
Singaram, Veena S. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ KwaZulu Natal, Sch Clin Med, Coll Hlth Sci, Clin & Profess Practice, ZA-4000 Durban, South Africa
关键词
Medical education; Feedback; Evaluation; Deliberate practice; Feed-forward; Clinical skills; WRITTEN FEEDBACK; EXPERT PERFORMANCE; INTERNAL-MEDICINE; PERCEPTIONS; EDUCATION; STUDENTS; ACQUISITION;
D O I
10.1186/s12909-019-1547-5
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Background: In this research paper we report on the quality of feedback provided in the logbooks of pre-clinical undergraduate students based on a model of 'actionable feedback'. Feedback to clinical learners about their performance is crucial to their learning, which ultimately impacts on their development into competent clinicians. Due to students' concerns regarding the inconsistency and quality of feedback provided by clinicians, a structured feedback improvement strategy to move feedback forward was added to the clinical skills logbook. The instrument was also extended for peer assessment. This study aims to assess the quality of feedback using the deliberate practice framework. Methods: A feedback scoring system was used to retrospectively assess the quality of tutor and peer logbook feedback provided to second and third year medical students to identify deliberate practice components i.e. task, performance gap and action plan. The sample consisted of 425 second year and 600 third year feedback responses over a year. Results: All three deliberate practice components were observed in the majority of the written feedback for both classes. The frequency was higher in peer (83%, 89%) than tutor logbook assessments (51%, 67%) in both classes respectively. Average tutor and peer task, gap and action feedback scores ranged from 1.84-2.07 and 1.93-2.21 respectively. The overall quality of feedback provided by the tutor and peer was moderate and less specific (average score < or = 2). The absence of the three components was noted in only 1% of the feedback responses in both 2nd and 3rd year. Conclusion: This study found that adding in a feed-forward strategy to the logbooks increased the overall quality of tutor and peer feedback as the task, gap and action plans were described. Deliberate practice framework provides an objective assessment of tutor and peer feedback quality and can be used for faculty development and training. The findings from our study suggest that the ratings from the tool can also be used as guidelines to provide feedback providers with feedback on the quality of feedback they provided. This includes specifically describing a task, performance gap and providing a learning plan as feed-forward to enhance feedback given.
引用
收藏
页数:11
相关论文
共 50 条
[21]   Training verfahrensübergreifender KompetenzenSubjektive Zufriedenheit mit Deliberate Practice und Strukturiertem FeedbackTraining of transtheoretical competenciesSubjective satisfaction with deliberate practice and structured feedback [J].
S. Sell ;
W. Andersen ;
A. Berning ;
B. Strauß ;
S. Taubner .
Die Psychotherapie, 2025, 70 (2) :104-111
[22]   Effectiveness of IV Cannulation Skills Laboratory Training and Its Transfer into Clinical Practice: A Randomized, Controlled Trial [J].
Lund, Frederike ;
Schultz, Jobst-Hendrik ;
Maatouk, Imad ;
Krautter, Markus ;
Moeltner, Andreas ;
Werner, Anne ;
Weyrich, Peter ;
Juenger, Jana ;
Nikendei, Christoph .
PLOS ONE, 2012, 7 (03)
[23]   Child Abuse Recognition Training for Prehospital Providers Using Deliberate Practice [J].
Adelgais, Kathleen ;
Pusic, Martin ;
Abdoo, Denise ;
Caffrey, Sean ;
Snyder, Katherine ;
Alletag, Michelle ;
Balakas, Ashley ;
Givens, Timothy ;
Kane, Ian ;
Mandt, Maria ;
Roswell, Kelley ;
Saunders, Mary ;
Boutis, Kathy .
PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE, 2021, 25 (06) :822-831
[24]   Clinical assessors' working conceptualisations of undergraduate consultation skills: a framework analysis of how assessors make expert judgements in practice [J].
Hyde, Catherine ;
Yardley, Sarah ;
Lefroy, Janet ;
Gay, Simon ;
McKinley, Robert K. .
ADVANCES IN HEALTH SCIENCES EDUCATION, 2020, 25 (04) :845-875
[25]   Doctor Coach: A Deliberate Practice Approach to Teaching and Learning Clinical Skills [J].
Gifford, Kimberly A. ;
Fall, Leslie H. .
ACADEMIC MEDICINE, 2014, 89 (02) :272-276
[26]   Effective and Feasible Simulation-Based Procedural Training for Medical Students: Instructional Video-Guided Deliberate Practice Versus Training with Expert Feedback [J].
Toy, Serkan ;
McKay, Robert ;
Eilert, Randy ;
Sandall, Justin .
MEDICAL SCIENCE EDUCATOR, 2019, 29 (01) :35-39
[27]   Mastering Clinical Skills: Rapid Cycle Deliberate Practice Skills Validation with Nurse Practitioner Students [J].
Suttle, Rebecca D. ;
Kopf, Sabrina D. ;
Nguyen, Somali H. ;
Haamankuli, Hiboombe M. ;
White, Tracie L. .
JNP- THE JOURNAL FOR NURSE PRACTITIONERS, 2025, 21 (03)
[28]   FACILITATING THE NOVICE TO EXPERT TRANSITION IN INTERPRETER TRAINING: A 'DELIBERATE PRACTICE' FRAMEWORK PROPOSAL [J].
Motta, Manuela .
STUDIA UNIVERSITATIS BABES-BOLYAI PHILOLOGIA, 2011, 56 (01) :27-42
[29]   Confounding factors in using upward feedback to assess the quality of medical training: a systematic review [J].
Zhou, Anli Yue ;
Baker, Paul .
JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL EVALUATION FOR HEALTH PROFESSIONS, 2014, 11
[30]   Direct observation and focused feedback for clinical skills training [J].
Singh, Tejinder ;
Kundra, Shaveta ;
Gupta, Piyush .
INDIAN PEDIATRICS, 2014, 51 (09) :713-717