Additional diagnostic value of new CT imaging techniques for the functional assessment of coronary artery disease: a meta-analysis

被引:26
作者
Hamon, Michele [1 ,2 ]
Geindreau, Damien [1 ,2 ]
Guittet, Lydia [2 ,3 ]
Bauters, Christophe [4 ,5 ]
Hamon, Martial [2 ]
机构
[1] CHU Caen, Dept Radiol, Ave Cote Nacre, F-14033 Caen, Normandie, France
[2] Univ Caen, UFR Med, Caen, Normandie, France
[3] CHU Caen, Dept Informat Med, Caen, Normandie, France
[4] Ctr Hosp Univ Reg Lille, Dept Cardiol, Lille, Hauts De France, France
[5] Univ Lille, UFR Med, INSERM, U1167, Lille, Hauts De France, France
关键词
Coronary angiography; Myocardial perfusion imaging; Computed tomography angiography; Myocardial fractional flow reserve; Coronary artery disease; FRACTIONAL FLOW RESERVE; COMPUTED-TOMOGRAPHY ANGIOGRAPHY; TRANSLUMINAL ATTENUATION GRADIENT; MYOCARDIAL BLOOD-FLOW; HEMODYNAMICALLY SIGNIFICANT STENOSES; REFERENCE-STANDARD; MEDICAL THERAPY; PERFORMANCE; PERFUSION; INTERMEDIATE;
D O I
10.1007/s00330-018-5919-8
中图分类号
R8 [特种医学]; R445 [影像诊断学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100207 ; 1009 ;
摘要
ObjectivesTo determine the diagnostic performance of cardiac computed tomography (CT)-based modalities including coronary CT angiography (CTA), stress myocardial CT perfusion (stress CTP), computer simulation of fractional flow reserve by CT (FFRCT), and transluminal attenuation gradients (TAG), for the diagnosis of hemodynamic significant coronary artery disease (CAD), using invasive fractional flow reserve as the reference standard.MethodsPubMed and Cochrane databases were searched for original articles until July 2018. Diagnostic accuracy results were pooled at per-patient and per-vessel level using random effect models.ResultsFifty articles were included in the meta-analysis (3024 subjects). The per-patient analysis per imaging modality demonstrated a pooled positive likelihood ratio (PLR) of 1.78 (95% confidence interval CI 1.49-2.11), 4.58 (95% CI 3.54-5.91), and 3.45 (95% CI 2.38-5.00) for CTA, stress CTP, and FFRCT respectively. Per-patient specificity of stress CTP (82%, 95% CI 76-86) and FFRCT (72%, 95% CI 68-76) were higher than for CTA (48%, 95% CI 44-51). At the vessel level, PLR was 2.42 (95% CI 1.93-3.02), 7.72 (95% CI 5.50-10.83), 3.50 (95% CI 2.73-4.78), 1.97 (95% CI 1.32-2.93) for CTA, stress CTP, FFRCT, and TAG respectively.ConclusionWith improved PLR and specificity, stress CTP and FFRCT have incremental value over CTA for the detection of functionally significant CAD.Key Points center dot New functional CT imaging techniques, such as stress CTP and FFRCT, improve diagnostic accuracy of coronary CTA to predict hemodynamically relevant stenosis.center dot TAG yields poor diagnostic performance.center dot Combination of CTA and some functional CT techniques (stress CTP and FFRCT) might become a must to improve diagnostic accuracy of CAD and to reduce unnecessary invasive coronary angiography.
引用
收藏
页码:3044 / 3061
页数:18
相关论文
共 76 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], CIRC CARDIOVASC IMAG
[2]   Detection of Hemodynamically Significant Coronary Artery Stenosis: Incremental Diagnostic Value of Dynamic CT-based Myocardial Perfusion Imaging [J].
Bamberg, Fabian ;
Becker, Alexander ;
Schwarz, Florian ;
Marcus, Roy P. ;
Greif, Martin ;
von Ziegler, Franz ;
Blankstein, Ron ;
Hoffmann, Udo ;
Sommer, Wieland H. ;
Hoffmann, Verena S. ;
Johnson, Thorsten R. C. ;
Becker, Hans-Christoph R. ;
Wintersperger, Bernd J. ;
Reiser, Maximilian F. ;
Nikolaou, Konstantin .
RADIOLOGY, 2011, 260 (03) :689-698
[3]   Comparison of Coronary Computed Tomography Angiography-Derived vs Invasive Fractional Flow Reserve Assessment: Meta-Analysis with Subgroup Evaluation of Intermediate Stenosis [J].
Baumann, Stefan ;
Renker, Matthias ;
Hetjens, Svetlana ;
Fuller, Stephen R. ;
Becher, Tobias ;
Lossnitzer, Dirk ;
Lehmann, Ralf ;
Akin, Ibrahim ;
Borggrefe, Martin ;
Lang, Siegfried ;
Wichmann, Julian L. ;
Schoepf, U. Joseph .
ACADEMIC RADIOLOGY, 2016, 23 (11) :1402-1411
[4]   Direct Comparison of Cardiac Magnetic Resonance and Multidetector Computed Tomography Stress-Rest Perfusion Imaging for Detection of Coronary Artery Disease [J].
Bettencourt, Nuno ;
Chiribiri, Amedeo ;
Schuster, Andreas ;
Ferreira, Nuno ;
Sampaio, Francisco ;
Pires-Morais, Gustavo ;
Santos, Lino ;
Melica, Bruno ;
Rodrigues, Alberto ;
Braga, Pedro ;
Azevedo, Luis ;
Teixeira, Madalena ;
Leite-Moreira, Adelino ;
Silva-Cardoso, Jose ;
Nagel, Eike ;
Gama, Vasco .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY, 2013, 61 (10) :1099-1107
[5]   Optimal medical therapy with or without PCI for stable coronary disease [J].
Boden, William E. ;
O'Rourke, Robert A. ;
Teo, Koon K. ;
Hartigan, Pamela M. ;
Maron, David J. ;
Kostuk, William J. ;
Knudtson, Merril ;
Dada, Marcin ;
Casperson, Paul ;
Harris, Crystal L. ;
Chaitman, Bernard R. ;
Shaw, Leslee ;
Gosselin, Gilbert ;
Nawaz, Shah ;
Title, Lawrence M. ;
Gau, Gerald ;
Blaustein, Alvin S. ;
Booth, David C. ;
Bates, Eric R. ;
Spertus, John A. ;
Berman, Daniel S. ;
Mancini, G. B. John ;
Weintraub, William S. ;
Boden, W. ;
O'Rourke, R. ;
Teo, K. ;
Hartigan, P. ;
Weintraub, W. ;
Maron, D. ;
Mancini, J. ;
Weintraub, W. ;
Boden, W. ;
O'Rourke, R. ;
Teo, K. ;
Hartigan, P. ;
Knudtson, M. ;
Maron, D. ;
Bates, E. ;
Blaustein, A. ;
Booth, D. ;
Carere, R. ;
Ellis, S. ;
Gosselin, G. ;
Gau, G. ;
Jacobs, A. ;
King, S., III ;
Kostuk, W. ;
Harris, C. ;
Spertus, J. ;
Peduzzi, P. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2007, 356 (15) :1503-1516
[6]   Myocardial blood flow quantification for evaluation of coronary artery disease by computed tomography [J].
Cademartiri, Filippo ;
Seitun, Sara ;
Clemente, Alberto ;
La Grutta, Ludovico ;
Toia, Patrizia ;
Runza, Giuseppe ;
Midiri, Massimo ;
Maffei, Erica .
CARDIOVASCULAR DIAGNOSIS AND THERAPY, 2017, 7 (02) :129-150
[7]   Diagnostic performance of intracoronary gradient-based methods by coronary computed tomography angiography for the evaluation of physiologically significant coronary artery stenoses: a validation study with fractional flow reserve [J].
Choi, Jin-Ho ;
Koo, Bon-Kwon ;
Yoon, Yeonyee E. ;
Min, James K. ;
Song, Young-Bin ;
Hahn, Joo-Yong ;
Choi, Seung-Hyuk ;
Gwon, Hyeon-Cheol ;
Choe, Yeon Hyeon .
EUROPEAN HEART JOURNAL-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2012, 13 (12) :1001-1007
[8]   Adenosine-stress low-dose single-scan CT myocardial perfusion imaging using a 128-slice dual-source CT: a comparison with fractional flow reserve [J].
Choo, Ki Seok ;
Hwangbo, Lee ;
Kim, June Hong ;
Park, Yong Hyun ;
Kim, Jeong Su ;
Kim, Jun ;
Chun, Kook Jin ;
Jeong, Dong Wook ;
Lim, Soo Jin .
ACTA RADIOLOGICA, 2013, 54 (04) :389-395
[9]   Integrating CT Myocardial Perfusion and CT-FFR in the Work-Up of Coronary Artery Disease [J].
Coenen, Adriaan ;
Rossi, Alexia ;
Lubbers, Marisa M. ;
Kurata, Akira ;
Kono, Atsushi K. ;
Chelu, Raluca G. ;
Segreto, Sabrina ;
Dijkshoorn, Marcel L. ;
Wragg, Andrew ;
van Geuns, Robert-Jan M. ;
Pugliese, Francesca ;
Nieman, Koen .
JACC-CARDIOVASCULAR IMAGING, 2017, 10 (07) :760-770
[10]   Diagnostic value of transmural perfusion ratio derived from dynamic CT-based myocardial perfusion imaging for the detection of haemodynamically relevant coronary artery stenosis [J].
Coenen, Adriaan ;
Lubbers, Marisa M. ;
Kurata, Akira ;
Kono, Atsushi ;
Dedic, Admir ;
Chelu, Raluca G. ;
Dijkshoorn, Marcel L. ;
Rossi, Alexia ;
van Geuns, Robert-Jan M. ;
Nieman, Koen .
EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2017, 27 (06) :2309-2316