A randomised trial of social support group intervention for people with aphasia: A Novel application of virtual reality

被引:35
|
作者
Marshall, Jane [1 ]
Devane, Niamh [1 ]
Talbot, Richard [1 ]
Caute, Anna [1 ,2 ]
Cruice, Madeline [1 ]
Hilari, Katerina [1 ]
MacKenzie, Gillian [1 ]
Maguire, Kimberley [1 ]
Patel, Anita [3 ]
Roper, Abi [1 ]
Wilson, Stephanie [4 ]
机构
[1] City Univ London, Ctr Language & Commun Sci Res, London, England
[2] Univ Essex, Sch Hlth & Social Care, Colchester, Essex, England
[3] Queen Mary Univ London, Anita Patel Hlth Econ Consulting Ltd, London, England
[4] City Univ London, Ctr Human Comp Interact Design, London, England
来源
PLOS ONE | 2020年 / 15卷 / 09期
关键词
QUALITY-OF-LIFE; LONG-TERM STROKE; COMMUNITY APHASIA; TREATMENT FIDELITY; THERAPY; SPEECH; COMMUNICATION; IDENTITY; WELL; PERSPECTIVES;
D O I
10.1371/journal.pone.0239715
中图分类号
O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
About a third of strokes cause aphasia, or language loss, with profound consequences for the person's social participation and quality of life. These problems may be mitigated by group social support. But this intervention is not available to all individuals. This study investigated whether it is feasible to deliver group social support to people with aphasia via a multi-user, virtual reality platform. It also explored the indicative effects of intervention and the costs. Intervention aimed to promote wellbeing and communicative success. It enabled participants to form new social connections and share experiences of living with aphasia. It comprised 14 sessions delivered over 6 months and was led by community based co-ordinators and volunteers. Feasibility measures comprised: recruitment and retention rates, compliance with intervention and assessment of treatment fidelity. Effects of intervention were explored using a waitlist randomised controlled design, with outcome measures of wellbeing, communication, social connectedness and quality of life. Two intervention groups were randomised to an immediate condition and two were randomised to a delayed condition. The main analysis explored scores on the measures between two time points, between which those in the immediate condition had received intervention, but those in the delayed group had not (yet). A comprehensive approach to economic data collection ensured that all costs of treatment delivery were recorded. Feasibility findings showed that the recruitment target was met (N = 34) and 85.3% (29/34) of participants completed intervention. All groups ran the 14 sessions as planned, and participants attended a mean of 11.4 sessions (s.d. 2.8), which was 81.6% of the intended dose. Fidelity checking showed minimal drift from the manualised intervention. No significant change was observed on any of the outcome measures, although the study was not powered to detect these. Costs varied across the four groups, from 7,483 pound - 12,562 pound British Pounds Sterling ($10,972 - $18,419 US dollars), depending on travel costs, the relative contributions of volunteers and the number of hardware loans that were needed. The results suggest that a larger trial of remote group support, using virtual reality, would be merited. However the treatment content and regime, and the selection of outcome measures should be reviewed before conducting the trial.
引用
收藏
页数:21
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Delivering group support for people with aphasia in a virtual world: experiences of service providers
    Caute, Anna
    Cruice, Madeline
    Devane, Niamh
    Patel, Anita
    Roper, Abi
    Talbot, Richard
    Wilson, Stephanie
    Marshall, Jane
    DISABILITY AND REHABILITATION, 2022, 44 (26) : 8264 - 8282
  • [2] Evaluating the Benefits of Aphasia Intervention Delivered in Virtual Reality: Results of a Quasi-Randomised Study
    Marshall, Jane
    Booth, Tracey
    Devane, Niamh
    Galliers, Julia
    Greenwood, Helen
    Hilari, Katerina
    Talbot, Richard
    Wilson, Stephanie
    Woolf, Celia
    PLOS ONE, 2016, 11 (08):
  • [3] The impact of the telerehabilitation group aphasia intervention and networking programme on communication, participation, and quality of life in people with aphasia
    Pitt, Rachelle
    Theodoros, Deborah
    Hill, Anne J.
    Russell, Trevor
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPEECH-LANGUAGE PATHOLOGY, 2019, 21 (05) : 513 - 523
  • [4] Singing for people with aphasia (SPA): a protocol for a pilot randomised controlled trial of a group singing intervention to improve well-being
    Tarrant, Mark
    Carter, Mary
    Dean, Sarah Gerard
    Taylor, Rod S.
    Warren, Fiona C.
    Spencer, Anne
    Adamson, Jane
    Landa, Paolo
    Code, Chris
    Calitri, Raff
    BMJ OPEN, 2018, 8 (09):
  • [5] Singing for people with aphasia (SPA): results of a pilot feasibility randomised controlled trial of a group singing intervention investigating acceptability and feasibility
    Tarrant, Mark
    Carter, Mary
    Dean, Sarah Gerard
    Taylor, Rod
    Warren, Fiona C.
    Spencer, Anne
    Adamson, Jane
    Landa, Paolo
    Code, Chris
    Backhouse, Amy
    Lamont, Ruth A.
    Calitri, Raff
    BMJ OPEN, 2021, 11 (01):
  • [6] Automated digital counselling with social network support as a novel intervention for patients with heart failure: protocol for randomised controlled trial
    Peiris, Rachel Grace
    Ross, Heather
    Chan, Christopher T.
    Poon, Stephanie
    Auguste, Bourne Lewis
    Rac, Valeria E.
    Farkouh, Michael
    McDonald, Michael
    Kaczorowski, Janusz
    Code, Jillianne
    Posada, Juan Duero
    Ong, Stephanie
    Kobulnik, Jeremy
    Tomlinson, George
    Huszti, Ella
    Arcand, JoAnne
    Thomas, Scott G.
    Akbari, Ayub
    Maunder, Robert
    Grover, Steven
    Seto, Emily
    Simard, Anne
    Pope, Brad
    Bains, Marc
    McIntyre, Carmen
    Torbay, Chris
    Syed, Fatima
    Nolan, Robert P.
    BMJ OPEN, 2022, 12 (09):
  • [7] A randomised controlled trial of support group intervention after breast cancer treatment: Results on anxiety and depression
    Bjorneklett, Helena Granstam
    Lindemalm, Christina
    Rosenblad, Andreas
    Ojutkangas, Marja-Leena
    Letocha, Henry
    Strang, Peter
    Bergkvist, Leif
    ACTA ONCOLOGICA, 2012, 51 (02) : 198 - 207
  • [8] Virtual reality in social skills training programs for people with schizophrenia: A systematic review and focus group
    Oliveira, Catarina
    de Almeida, Raquel Simoes
    Marques, Antonio
    BRITISH JOURNAL OF OCCUPATIONAL THERAPY, 2021, 84 (09) : 571 - 581
  • [9] A randomised controlled trial of a computerised intervention for children with social communication difficulties to support peer collaboration
    Murphy, Suzanne M.
    Faulkner, Dorothy M.
    Reynolds, Laura R.
    RESEARCH IN DEVELOPMENTAL DISABILITIES, 2014, 35 (11) : 2821 - 2839
  • [10] Social positioning by people with Alzheimer's disease in a support group
    Hedman, Ragnhild
    Hellstrom, Ingrid
    Ternestedt, Britt-Marie
    Hansebo, Gorel
    Norberg, Astrid
    JOURNAL OF AGING STUDIES, 2014, 28 : 11 - 21