'Nothing works' in secure residential youth care?

被引：58
作者：
Souverein, F. A. [2 ]
Van der Helm, G. H. P. [1 ]
Stams, G. J. J. M. [2 ]
机构：
[1] Leiden Univ Appl Sci, Youth Expert Ctr, NL-2300 AJ Leiden, Netherlands
[2] Univ Amsterdam, Grad Sch Child Dev & Educ, NL-1018 VZ Amsterdam, Netherlands
来源：
CHILDREN AND YOUTH SERVICES REVIEW | 2013年 / 35卷 / 12期
关键词：
Secure residential youth care; Effectiveness; Recommendations; 2-YEAR FOLLOW-UP; JUVENILE-OFFENDERS; METAANALYSIS; BEHAVIOR; INTERVENTIONS; RECIDIVISM; PLACEMENT; PROGRAMS; OUTCOMES; HARMFUL;
D O I：
10.1016/j.childyouth.2013.09.010
中图分类号：
D669 [社会生活与社会问题]; C913 [社会生活与社会问题];
学科分类号：
1204 ;
摘要：
A debate about the effectiveness of secure residential youth care is currently going on. While some continue to support secure residential youth care, others conclude that 'nothing works' in secure residential youth care, and argue that non-residential treatment is superior to secure residential treatment. This article reviews recent research on this topic. The conclusion is that evidence for the effectiveness of non-residential treatment for youth with severe behavioural problems and/or criminal behaviour is sparse if considered as an alternative for secure residential youth care. Secure residential treatment shows a modest, but positive effect. We need to overhaul the myth that 'nothing works' in secure residential youth care, and focus on how to optimise the effects of secure residential youth care. (C) 2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码：1941 / 1945
页数：5
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Surviving against the odds. The impact of peer support workers on a chronically suicidal adolescent in secure residential youth care: a single case report from the Netherlands
    Kaijadoe, Shireen P. T.
    Nijhof, Karin S.
    Klip, Helen
    Popma, Arne
    Scholte, Ron H. J.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF QUALITATIVE STUDIES ON HEALTH AND WELL-BEING, 2024, 19 (01)
  • [32] Organizational social context and psychopathology of youth in residential care: The intervening role of youth-caregiver relationship quality
    Silva, Carla Sofia
    Calheiros, Maria Manuela
    Carvalho, Helena
    Magalhaes, Eunice
    APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY-AN INTERNATIONAL REVIEW-PSYCHOLOGIE APPLIQUEE-REVUE INTERNATIONALE, 2022, 71 (02): : 564 - 586
  • [33] Youth perspectives on parents' involvement in residential care in Israel
    Sulimani-Aidan, Yafit
    Paldi, Yuval
    JOURNAL OF SOCIAL WORK, 2020, 20 (01) : 64 - 82
  • [34] Characteristics of and Services Provided to Youth in Secure Care Facilities
    Gagnon, Joseph C.
    Barber, Brian
    BEHAVIORAL DISORDERS, 2010, 36 (01) : 7 - 19
  • [35] "You are nothing and you have nothing": Exploring social justice for youth leaving care in African contexts
    Kelly, Berni
    van Breda, Adrian D.
    Frimpong-Manso, Kwabena
    CHILDREN AND YOUTH SERVICES REVIEW, 2025, 172
  • [36] Increasing Youth Engagement in Residential Group Care: A Mixed Methods Pilot Study of a Youth-Guided Incentive Program
    Boel-Studt, Shamra
    Schelbe, Lisa
    Hansen, Megan Deichen
    Tobia, Lauren
    CHILD & YOUTH CARE FORUM, 2018, 47 (06) : 863 - 880
  • [37] Family-centred practice and family outcomes in residential youth care: A systematic review
    Tang, Emily
    de Haan, Amaranta D.
    Kuiper, Chris H. Z.
    Harder, Annemiek T.
    CHILD & FAMILY SOCIAL WORK, 2024, 29 (03) : 598 - 614
  • [38] Professionalizing Care Workers: Outcomes of a 'Motivational Interviewing' Training in Residential Youth Care
    Eenshuistra, Annika
    Harder, Annemiek T.
    Knorth, Erik J.
    RESIDENTIAL TREATMENT FOR CHILDREN & YOUTH, 2021, 38 (03) : 248 - 268
  • [39] The youth-caregiver relationship quality in residential youth care: Professionals' perceptions and experiences
    Magalhaes, Eunice
    Ferreira, Margarida
    Ornelas, Sandra
    Silva, Carla Sofia
    Camilo, Claudia
    Calheiros, Maria Manuela
    JOURNAL OF SOCIAL AND PERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS, 2024, 41 (04) : 822 - 845
  • [40] To Change or Not to Change? A Study regarding the Satisfaction of Care Workers and Adolescents with the Motivational Interviewing Based Residential Youth Care Training Program Up2U
    Eenshuistra, Annika
    Bhola, Priscilla M.
    Hoek-Dekker, Arienne J.
    Knorth, Erik J.
    Harder, Annemiek T.
    CHILD & YOUTH SERVICES, 2023, 44 (03) : 300 - 327
12345