Structure of Malaria Pigment and Related Propanoate-Linked Metalloporphyrin Dimers

Malaria pigment, the heme detoxification product of malaria's invasion, digestion, and growth inside mammalian red blood cells, is an insoluble phase of iron(III)protoporphyrin-IX. Even though its structure was determined in 2000 by powder X-ray diffraction, significant questions remain about its formation and possible interaction with quinoline antimalarial drugs. A recent structural study, also with X-ray powder diffraction, has reconfirmed that the material isolated from the parasite is isostructural with its synthetic equivalent. It was recently suggested that other isomers may also be formed and may be present in synthetic samples. In particular, a series of stereoisomers are possible for the arrangement of vinyl groups on the periphery of the dimerized porphyrin rings. In principle, any given dimer can have vinyl groups at the a or beta sites, and at ? or d sites. In this paper, several models are evaluated, both biphasic and homogeneous methyl/vinyl disorder, against several sets of diffraction data, both published and new. We conclude that methyl/vinyl disorder is intrinsic to the system, and that the evidence at hand does not support the existence of any other crystalline isomers in carefully prepared samples of either natural or synthetic samples. Finally, the porphyrin?porphyrin interactions are evaluated using Scheidt's indicies for porphyrin p-stacking, and we find modest to weak p-interactions in these condensed phases.