The ARRIVE guidelines 2.0: Updated guidelines for reporting animal research

被引:1184
作者
du Sert, Nathalie Percie [1 ]
Hurst, Viki [1 ]
Ahluwalia, Amrita [2 ,3 ]
Alam, Sabina [4 ]
Avey, Marc T. [5 ]
Baker, Monya [6 ]
Browne, William J. [7 ]
Clark, Alejandra [8 ]
Cuthill, Innes C. [9 ]
Dirnagl, Ulrich [10 ,11 ]
Emerson, Michael [12 ]
Garner, Paul [13 ]
Holgate, Stephen T. [14 ]
Howells, David W. [15 ]
Karp, Natasha A. [16 ]
Lazic, Stanley E. [17 ]
Lidster, Katie [1 ]
MacCallum, Catriona J. [18 ]
Macleod, Malcolm [19 ]
Pearl, Esther J. [1 ]
Petersen, Ole H. [20 ]
Rawle, Frances [21 ]
Reynolds, Penny [22 ]
Rooney, Kieron [23 ]
Sena, Emily S. [19 ]
Silberberg, Shai D. [24 ]
Steckler, Thomas [25 ]
Wuerbel, Hanno [26 ]
机构
[1] NC3Rs, London, England
[2] William Harvey Res Inst, London, England
[3] Queen Mary Univ London, Barts Cardiovasc CTU, London, England
[4] Taylor & Francis Grp, London, England
[5] ICF, Hlth Sci Practice, Durham, NC USA
[6] Nature, San Francisco, CA USA
[7] Univ Bristol, Sch Educ, Bristol, Avon, England
[8] PLOS ONE, Cambridge, England
[9] Univ Bristol, Sch Biol Sci, Bristol, Avon, England
[10] Charite Univ Med Berlin, QUEST Ctr Transforming Biomed Res, Berlin Inst Hlth, Berlin, Germany
[11] Charite Univ Med Berlin, Dept Expt Neurol, Berlin, Germany
[12] Imperial Coll London, Natl Heart & Lung Inst, London, England
[13] Univ Liverpool Liverpool Sch Trop Med, Ctr Evidence Synth Global Hlth, Clin Sci Dept, Liverpool, Merseyside, England
[14] Univ Southampton, Clin & Expt Sci, Southampton, Hants, England
[15] Univ Tasmania, Tasmanian Sch Med, Hobart, Tas, Australia
[16] AstraZeneca, Data Sci & Quantitat Biol, Discovery Sci, R&D, Cambridge, England
[17] Priorisai Inc, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[18] Hindawi Ltd, London, England
[19] Univ Edinburgh, Ctr Clin Brain Sci, Edinburgh, Midlothian, Scotland
[20] Cardiff Univ, Acad Europaea Knowledge Hub, Cardiff, Wales
[21] MRC, London, England
[22] Univ Florida, Coll Med, Dept Anesthesiol, Stat Anesthesiol Res STAR Core, Gainesville, FL USA
[23] Univ Sydney, Fac Med & Hlth, Discipline Exercise & Sport Sci, Sydney, NSW, Australia
[24] NINDS, Bldg 36,Rm 4D04, Bethesda, MD 20892 USA
[25] Janssen Pharmaceut NV, Beerse, Belgium
[26] Univ Bern, Vetsuisse Fac, Vet Publ Hlth Inst, Bern, Switzerland
基金
英国国家替代、减少和改良动物研究中心;
关键词
IMPROVING BIOSCIENCE RESEARCH; IN-VIVO EXPERIMENTS; POLICIES; REPRODUCIBILITY; STANDARDS; DESIGN; CALL;
D O I
10.1371/journal.pbio.3000410
中图分类号
Q5 [生物化学]; Q7 [分子生物学];
学科分类号
071010 ; 081704 ;
摘要
Reproducible science requires transparent reporting. The ARRIVE guidelines (Animal Research: Reporting of In Vivo Experiments) were originally developed in 2010 to improve the reporting of animal research. They consist of a checklist of information to include in publications describing in vivo experiments to enable others to scrutinise the work adequately, evaluate its methodological rigour, and reproduce the methods and results. Despite considerable levels of endorsement by funders and journals over the years, adherence to the guidelines has been inconsistent, and the anticipated improvements in the quality of reporting in animal research publications have not been achieved. Here, we introduce ARRIVE 2.0. The guidelines have been updated and information reorganised to facilitate their use in practice. We used a Delphi exercise to prioritise and divide the items of the guidelines into 2 sets, the "ARRIVE Essential 10," which constitutes the minimum requirement, and the "Recommended Set," which describes the research context. This division facilitates improved reporting of animal research by supporting a stepwise approach to implementation. This helps journal editors and reviewers verify that the most important items are being reported in manuscripts. We have also developed the accompanying Explanation and Elaboration (E&E) document, which serves (1) to explain the rationale behind each item in the guidelines, (2) to clarify key concepts, and (3) to provide illustrative examples. We aim, through these changes, to help ensure that researchers, reviewers, and journal editors are better equipped to improve the rigour and transparency of the scientific process and thus reproducibility.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 53 条
[1]   A comparison of conflict of interest policies at peer-reviewed journals in different scientific disciplines [J].
Ancker, Jessica S. ;
Flanagin, Annette .
SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING ETHICS, 2007, 13 (02) :147-157
[2]   Enhancing reproducibility [J].
不详 .
NATURE METHODS, 2013, 10 (05) :367-367
[3]   The Devil Is in the Details: Incomplete Reporting in Preclinical Animal Research [J].
Avey, Marc T. ;
Moher, David ;
Sullivan, Katrina J. ;
Fergusson, Dean ;
Griffin, Gilly ;
Grimshaw, Jeremy M. ;
Hutton, Brian ;
Lalu, Manoj M. ;
Macleod, Malcolm ;
Marshall, John ;
Mei, Shirley H. J. ;
Rudnicki, Michael ;
Stewart, Duncan J. ;
Turgeon, Aexis F. ;
Mclntyre, Lauralyn .
PLOS ONE, 2016, 11 (11)
[4]  
Bate S.T., 2014, DESIGN STAT ANAL ANI
[5]   Reproducibility in Science Improving the Standard for Basic and Preclinical Research [J].
Begley, C. Glenn ;
Ioannidis, John P. A. .
CIRCULATION RESEARCH, 2015, 116 (01) :116-126
[6]   Raise standards for preclinical cancer research [J].
Begley, C. Glenn ;
Ellis, Lee M. .
NATURE, 2012, 483 (7391) :531-533
[7]   Registered reports at the European Journal of Neuroscience: consolidating and extending peer-reviewed study pre-registration [J].
Chambers, Christopher D. ;
Forstmann, Birte ;
Pruszynski, J. Andrew .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF NEUROSCIENCE, 2017, 45 (05) :627-628
[8]   Experimental design and analysis and their reporting II: updated and simplified guidance for authors and peer reviewers [J].
Curtis, Michael J. ;
Alexander, Steve ;
Cirino, Giuseppe ;
Docherty, James R. ;
George, Christopher H. ;
Giembycz, Mark A. ;
Hoyer, Daniel ;
Insel, Paul A. ;
Izzo, Angelo A. ;
Ji, Yong ;
MacEwan, David J. ;
Sobey, Christopher G. ;
Stanford, S. Clare ;
Teixeira, Mauro M. ;
Wonnacott, Sue ;
Ahluwalia, Amrita .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF PHARMACOLOGY, 2018, 175 (07) :987-993
[9]   Reporting animal research: Explanation and elaboration for the ARRIVE guidelines 2.0 [J].
du Sert, Nathalie Percie ;
Ahluwalia, Amrita ;
Alam, Sabina ;
Avey, Marc T. ;
Baker, Monya ;
Browne, William J. ;
Clark, Alejandra ;
Cuthill, Innes C. ;
Dirnagl, Ulrich ;
Emerson, Michael ;
Garner, Paul ;
Holgate, Stephen T. ;
Howells, David W. ;
Hurst, Viki ;
Karp, Natasha A. ;
Lazic, Stanley E. ;
Lidster, Katie ;
MacCallum, Catriona J. ;
Macleod, Malcolm ;
Pearl, Esther J. ;
Petersen, Ole H. ;
Rawle, Frances ;
Reynolds, Penny ;
Rooney, Kieron ;
Sena, Emily S. ;
Silberberg, Shai D. ;
Steckler, Thomas ;
Wuerbel, Hanno .
PLOS BIOLOGY, 2020, 18 (07)
[10]   The Experimental Design Assistant [J].
du Sert, Nathalie Percie ;
Bamsey, Ian ;
Bate, Simon T. ;
Berdoy, Manuel ;
Clark, Robin A. ;
Cuthill, Innes ;
Fry, Derek ;
Karp, Natasha A. ;
Macleod, Malcolm ;
Moon, Lawrence ;
Stanford, S. Clare ;
Lings, Brian .
PLOS BIOLOGY, 2017, 15 (09)