Investigation into the accuracy and measurement methods of sequential 3D dental scan alignment

被引:160
作者
O'Toole, Saoirse [3 ]
Osnes, Cecilie [2 ,4 ]
Bartlett, David [1 ]
Keeling, Andrew [4 ]
机构
[1] Kings Coll London, Dent Inst, Fac Dent Oral & Craniofacial Sci, Ctr Clin Oral & Translat Sci,Guys Hosp, Tower Wing, London SE1 9RT, England
[2] Univ Siena, Dept Med Technol, Siena, Italy
[3] Kings Coll London, Dent Inst, Dept Prosthodont, Guys Hosp, Floor 25,Tower Wing, London SE1 9RT, England
[4] Leeds Sch Dent, Dept Restorat Dent, Clarendon Way, Leeds LS2 9LU, W Yorkshire, England
关键词
Tooth wear; Tooth erosion; Diagnostic imaging; Dental technology; TOOTH WEAR;
D O I
10.1016/j.dental.2019.01.012
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Objectives. Alignment procedures have yet to be standardised and may influence the measurement outcome. This investigation assessed the accuracy of commonly used alignment techniques and their impact on measurement metrics. Methods. Datasets of 10 natural molar teeth were created with a structured-light model-scanner (Rexcan DS2, Europac 3D, Crewe). A 300 mu m depth layer was then digitally removed from the occlusal surface creating a defect of known size. The datasets were duplicated, randomly repositioned and re-alignment attempted using a "best-fit" alignment, landmark-based alignment or reference alignment in Geomagic Control (3D Systems, Darmstadt, Germany). The re-alignment accuracy was mathematically assessed using the mean angular and translation differences between the original alignment and the re-aligned datasets. The effect of the re-alignment on conventional measurement metrics was calculated by analysing differences between the known defect size and defect size after re-alignment. Data were analysed in SPSS v24(ANOVA, post hoc Games Howell test, p <0.05). Results. The mean translation error (SD) was 139 mu m (42) using landmark alignment, 130 mu m (26) for best-fit and 22 mu m (9) for reference alignment (p < 0.001). The mean angular error (SD) between the datasets was 2.52 (1.18) degrees for landmark alignment, 0.56 (0.38) degrees for best-fit alignment and 0.26 (0.12) degrees for reference alignment (p < 0.001). Using a reference alignment statistically reduced the mean profilometric change, volume change and percentage of surface change errors (p < 0.001). Significance. Reference alignment produced significantly lower alignment errors and truer measurements. Best-fit and landmark-based alignment algorithms significantly underestimated the size of the defect. Challenges remain in identifying reference surfaces in a robust, clinically relevant method. Crown Copyright (C) 2019 Published by Elsevier Inc. on behalf of The Academy of Dental Materials. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:495 / 500
页数:6
相关论文
共 19 条
[1]   A Proposed Methodology to Assess the Accuracy of 3D Scanners and Casts and Monitor Tooth Wear Progression in Patients [J].
Ahmed, Khaled E. ;
Whitters, John ;
Ju, Xiangyang ;
Pierce, S. Gareth ;
MacLeod, Charles N. ;
Murray, Colin A. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PROSTHODONTICS, 2016, 29 (05) :514-521
[2]   Impact of manual control point selection accuracy on automated surface matching of digital dental models [J].
Becker, Kathrin ;
Wilmes, Benedict ;
Grandjean, Chantal ;
Drescher, Dieter .
CLINICAL ORAL INVESTIGATIONS, 2018, 22 (02) :801-810
[3]   A METHOD FOR REGISTRATION OF 3-D SHAPES [J].
BESL, PJ ;
MCKAY, ND .
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON PATTERN ANALYSIS AND MACHINE INTELLIGENCE, 1992, 14 (02) :239-256
[4]  
Camardella Leonardo Tavares, 2017, Dental Press J. Orthod., V22, P65
[5]  
Chadwick R G, 2005, J Clin Pediatr Dent, V29, P157
[6]   Rationalization of quantitative tooth surface loss data for epidemiological research [J].
Chadwick, RG ;
Mitchell, HL ;
Ward, S .
JOURNAL OF ORAL REHABILITATION, 2004, 31 (01) :42-46
[7]  
Clozza E, 2012, INT J ORAL MAX IMPL, V27, P770
[8]   Wear of two denture teeth materials in vivo-2-year results [J].
Heintze, Siegward D. ;
Zellweger, Gaby ;
Sbicego, Sandro ;
Rousson, Valentin ;
Munoz-Viveros, Carlos ;
Stober, Thomas .
DENTAL MATERIALS, 2013, 29 (09) :E191-E204
[9]   An in vitro study into the accuracy of a novel method for recording the mandibular transverse horizontal axis [J].
Keeling, A. J. ;
Brunton, P. A. ;
Holt, R. J. .
JOURNAL OF DENTISTRY, 2014, 42 (02) :122-128
[10]  
Marghalani A, 2016, J PROSTHET DENT, V2017, P574