Lack of Evidence for Presenilins as Endoplasmic Reticulum Ca2+ Leak Channels

Familial Alzheimer disease (FAD) is linked to mutations in the presenilin (PS) homologs. FAD mutant PS expression has several cellular consequences, including exaggerated intracellular Ca2+ ([Ca2+](i)) signaling due to enhanced agonist sensitivity and increased magnitude of [Ca2+](i) signals. The mechanisms underlying these phenomena remain controversial. It has been proposed that PSs are constitutively active, passive endoplasmic reticulum (ER) Ca2+ leak channels and that FAD PS mutations disrupt this function resulting in ER store overfilling that increases the driving force for release upon ER Ca2+ release channel opening. To investigate this hypothesis, we employed multiple Ca2+ imaging protocols and indicators to directly measure ER Ca2+ dynamics in several cell systems. However, we did not observe consistent evidence that PSs act as ER Ca2+ leak channels. Nevertheless, we confirmed observations made using indirect measurements employed in previous reports that proposed this hypothesis. Specifically, cells lacking PS or expressing a FAD-linked PS mutation displayed increased area under the ionomycin-induced [Ca2+](i) versus time curve (AI) compared with cells expressing WT PS. However, an ER-targeted Ca2+ indicator revealed that this did not reflect overloaded ER stores. Monensin pretreatment selectively attenuated the AI in cells lacking PS or expressing a FAD PS allele. These findings contradict the hypothesis that PSs form ER Ca2+ leak channels and highlight the need to use ER-targeted Ca2+ indicators when studying ER Ca2+ dynamics.