Comparison of the Combustion of Pine Species with Two Sizes of Calorimeter: 10 g vs. 100 g

This study aims to analyze the scale effects on the combustion dynamics and smoke emitted during the burning of vegetation species under laboratory conditions. Experiments were carried out at two scales of combustion with two fuels (Pinus pinaster and Pinus laricio needles). Two oxygen consumption calorimetry devices were used: the cone calorimeter with samples in the scale of 10 g, and Large Scale Heat Release rate calorimeter (LSHR) with samples in the scale of 100 g. Fuel loads of 1.2 kg m(-2) and 1.04 kg m(-2) were considered respectively for Pinus pinaster and Pinus laricio needles. The parameters investigated to analyze the combustion dynamics are the heat release rate, combustion efficiency and mass loss rate. Measuring the extinction coefficient allowed us to obtain the soot emission factor. The emission factors of the combustion gases were obtained by using FTIR and NDIR detectors. A carbon mass balance showed that more than 95% of carbon was recovered. This study revealed an effect of scale on the combustion dynamics (peak HRR of 806 kW m(-2) and 651 kW m(-2) respectively at the bench scale and at full scale for Pinus pinaster), total smoke production, soot emission factor (1.32 g kg(-1) and 5.17 g kg(-1) respectively at the bench scale and at full scale for Pinus pinaster) and nitrogen compounds emission factors (2.47 g kg(-1) and 5.25 g kg(-1) for the NO respectively with the cone calorimeter and LSHR for Pinus laricio). Combustion efficiency appeared to be largely independent of the combustion scale (96.89% and 96.61% respectively at the bench scale and at full scale for Pinus pinaster). We also observed differences in the fire behavior for both types of needles.