Comparative analyses of estimated and calorimetrically determined energy balance in high-yielding dairy cows

Our aim was to compare the energy balance estimated (EBest) according to equations published by various energy feeding systems (German Society for Nutrition Physiology, French National Institute for Agricultural Research, and US National Research Council) and the EB calculated by use of calorimetrically measured heat production (EBhp) of 20 high-yielding (>= 10,000 kg/305 d) German Holstein cows at -4 (pregnant, nonlactating) and 2 wk (early lactation) relative to parturition. In addition to heat production, feed and water intake, physical activity (including standing-lying behavior), body weight, body condition score, body temperature, plasma concentrations of fatty acids and beta-hydroxybutyrate, milk yield, and milk composition were measured to characterize the metabolic status. The EBhp was balanced [2.74 +/- 4.09 MJ of metabolizable energy (ME)/d; +/- standard error] before calving, but strongly negative (-84.7 +/- 7.48 MJ of ME/d) at wk 2 of lactation. At both time points, EBhp and EBest differed significantly. On average, the equations overestimated the antepartum EB by 33 MJ of ME/d and underestimated the postpartum negative EB by 67 MJ of ME/d, respectively. Because the same ME intake and energy-corrected milk values were used for calculation of EBest and EBhp in our study, we considered that the factors (0.488 to 0.534 MJ of ME/kg(0.75)) currently used to calculate the ME requirements for maintenance probably underestimate the needs of high-yielding dairy cows, particularly during early lactation. In accord, heat production values determined under standard conditions of thermoneutrality and locomotion restriction amounted to 0.76 +/- 0.02 MJ of ME/kg(0.75) (4 wk antepartum) and 1.02 +/- 0.02 MJ of ME/kg(0.75) (2 wk postpartum), respectively. The expected positive correlation between EBhp and DMI was observed in pregnant cows only; however, a bias of 26 MJ of ME/d between mean actual energy intake and ME intake predicted according to German Society for Nutrition Physiology was found in cows at wk 4 antepartum. At both investigated time points, mobilization of tissue energy reserves (reflected by plasma fatty acid concentration) was related to EBhp. In early lactating cows, metabolic body weight (kg(0.75)) and the percentage of milk fat showed the strongest correlation (correlation coefficient = -0.70 and -0.73) to EBhp. Our findings must be taken into account when experimental data are interpreted because the true energy status might be significantly overestimated when EBest is used.