Although the normality assumption has been regarded as a mathematical convenience for inferential purposes due to its nice distributional properties, there has been a growing interest regarding generalized classes of distributions that span a much broader spectrum in terms of symmetry and peakedness behavior. In this respect, Fleishman's power polynomial method seems to have been gaining popularity in statistical theory and practice because of its flexibility and ease of execution. In this article, we conduct multiple imputation for univariate continuous data under Fleishman polynomials to explore the extent to which this procedure works properly. We also make comparisons with normal imputation models via widely accepted accuracy and precision measures using simulated data that exhibit different distributional features as characterized by competing specifications of the third and fourth moments. Finally, we discuss generalizations to the multivariate case. Multiple imputation under power polynomials that cover most of the feasible area in the skewness-elongation plane appears to have substantial potential of capturing real missing-data trends.