A dynamic reference model: a framework for assessing biodiversity restoration goals in a fire-dependent ecosystem

被引:40
|
作者
Kirkman, L. Katherine [1 ]
Barnett, Analie [2 ]
Williams, Brett W. [3 ]
Hiers, J. Kevin [3 ]
Pokswinski, Scott M. [1 ]
Mitchell, Robert J. [1 ]
机构
[1] Joseph W Jones Ecol Res Ctr, Newton, GA 39870 USA
[2] Nature Conservancy, Atlanta, GA 30303 USA
[3] Jackson Guard, Niceville, FL 32578 USA
关键词
Eglin Air Force Base; Florida; USA; fire exclusion; longleaf pine restoration; midstory reduction; nonmetric multidimensional scaling; Pinus palustris; prescribed fire; reference sites; HARDWOOD REDUCTION TECHNIQUES; LONGLEAF PINE; PLANT COMMUNITY; ECOLOGICAL RESTORATION; REFERENCE INFORMATION; ASSEMBLAGE RESPONSE; OAK SAVANNAS; VEGETATION; FOREST; MANAGEMENT;
D O I
10.1890/13-0021.1
中图分类号
Q14 [生态学(生物生态学)];
学科分类号
071012 ; 0713 ;
摘要
The use of reference models as templates of historical or natural conditions to assess restoration progress is inherently logical; however, difficulties occur in application because of the need to incorporate temporal variation in ecosystems caused by disturbance and succession, as well as seasonal, interannual, or decadal variability. The landscape-scale restoration of the globally threatened and fire-dependent longleaf pine ecosystem in the southeastern United States is an example in which restoration efforts are even more complicated by the limited availability of extant reference sites. This study uses the dynamic reference conceptual framework to assess the direction and rate of recovery with respect to biodiversity restoration goals using a 15-year vegetation data set from an experimental restoration treatment in fire-excluded, hardwood-encroached longleaf pine sandhills. We compared ground-cover vegetation response to midstory hardwood removal through herbicide application, mechanical removal, and fire only. Nonmetric multidimensional scaling ordinations and proportional similarity analyses suggest that, while vegetation changed in all treatments over time, no differences in species composition or hardwood density in the ground cover were attributable to hardwood reduction treatments after 15 years with frequent prescribed fire. Furthermore, the results of this study indicate that considerable variability is associated with reference sites over time. Sites identified in 1994 as attainable restoration targets had become a moving target themselves, changing in magnitude consistent with alterations in restoration plots attributable to treatment effects and shaped by the modest increase in fire frequency imposed since 1998. In a broad restoration context, this study demonstrates a conceptual framework to better understand and integrate the range of spatial and temporal variation associated with the best available reference sites. It also illustrates a practical tool for statistically defining reference sites and for measuring restoration success in continually changing conditions that should be widely applicable to other ecosystems and restoration goals.
引用
收藏
页码:1574 / 1587
页数:14
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Trait space of rare plants in a fire-dependent ecosystem
    Ames, Gregory M.
    Wall, Wade A.
    Hohmann, Matthew G.
    Wright, Justin P.
    CONSERVATION BIOLOGY, 2017, 31 (04) : 903 - 911
  • [2] Altered ignition catchments threaten a hyperdiverse fire-dependent ecosystem
    Slingsby, Jasper A.
    Moncrieff, Glenn R.
    Rogers, Annabelle J.
    February, Edmund C.
    GLOBAL CHANGE BIOLOGY, 2020, 26 (02) : 616 - 628
  • [3] A climate-based approach to the restoration of fire-dependent ecosystems
    Beckage, B
    Platt, WJ
    Panko, B
    RESTORATION ECOLOGY, 2005, 13 (03) : 429 - 431
  • [4] Forest restoration in a surface fire-dependent ecosystem: An example from a mixed conifer forest, southwestern Colorado, USA
    Korb, Julie E.
    Fule, Peter Z.
    Stoddard, Michael T.
    FOREST ECOLOGY AND MANAGEMENT, 2012, 269 : 10 - 18
  • [5] Productivity and species richness across an environmental gradient in a fire-dependent ecosystem
    Kirkman, LK
    Mitchell, RJ
    Helton, RC
    Drew, MB
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BOTANY, 2001, 88 (11) : 2119 - 2128
  • [6] Examining the knowing-doing gap in the conservation of a fire-dependent ecosystem
    Costanza, Jennifer K.
    Weiss, Jack
    Moody, Aaron
    BIOLOGICAL CONSERVATION, 2013, 158 : 107 - 115
  • [7] Factors influencing the persistence of a fire-sensitive Artemisia species in a fire-dependent ecosystem
    Dornbusch, Megan J.
    Limb, Ryan F.
    Bloom-Cornelius, Ilana, V
    Elmore, R. Dwayne
    Weir, John R.
    Fuhlendorf, Samuel D.
    ECOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS, 2022, 32 (05)
  • [8] The effect of urban growth on landscape-scale restoration for a fire-dependent songbird
    Pickens, Bradley A.
    Marcus, Jeffrey F.
    Carpenter, John P.
    Anderson, Scott
    Taillie, Paul J.
    Collazo, Jaime A.
    JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT, 2017, 191 : 105 - 115
  • [9] Deciding Where to Burn: Stakeholder Priorities for Prescribed Burning of a Fire-Dependent Ecosystem
    Costanza, Jennifer K.
    Moody, Aaron
    ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY, 2011, 16 (01):
  • [10] Invasion of a non-native forb reduces flammability in a fire-dependent ecosystem
    Barnes, Alexander G.
    Kane, Jeffrey M.
    McKenzie, David A.
    Koerner, Brenda A.
    ECOSPHERE, 2022, 13 (03):