Observation of size-independent effects in nanoparticle retention behavior during asymmetric-flow field-flow fractionation

In this work, we highlight the size-independent influence of the material properties of nanoparticles (NPs) on their retention behavior in asymmetric-flow field-flow fractionation (A4F) by comparing four NP populations with similar nominal size. The phenomena described here suggest there are limits to the effectiveness and accuracy of using a single type of NP standard (polystyrene beads most typically) in order to generically calibrate retention time in normal mode elution. The dual objectives of this paper are to (1) demonstrate the uncertainties resulting from current practice and (2) initiate a discussion of these effects and their origins. The results presented here illustrate clearly that the retention time is higher for metallic NPs relative to lower (bulk) density NPs. By modifying the fundamental field-flow fractionation equation to account for differences in particle density, we show that the effect of the gravitational force is finite but insignificant for NPs. We postulate that the observed material-dependent retention behavior may be attributed to differences in the attractive van der Waals force between the NPs and the accumulation wall (membrane surface). We hope that our results will stimulate discussion and reassessment of the calibration procedure, perhaps by more fully accounting for all influential material parameters relevant to the fractionation of nanoscale particles by A4F.