Gela histological scoring system for post-treatment biopsies of patients with gastric MALT lymphoma is feasible and reliable in routine practice

被引:76
作者
Copie-Bergman, Christiane [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Wotherspoon, Andrew C. [4 ]
Capella, Carlo [5 ,6 ]
Motta, Teresio [7 ]
Pedrinis, Ennio [8 ]
Pileri, Stefano A. [9 ,10 ]
Bertoni, Francesco [11 ]
Conconi, Annarita [12 ]
Zucca, Emanuele [11 ]
Ponzoni, Maurilio [13 ]
Ferreri, Andres J. M. [14 ]
机构
[1] Grp Henri Mondor Albert Chenevier, AP HP, Dept Pathol, Creteil, France
[2] Univ Paris Est Creteil, Fac Med, Creteil, France
[3] Hop Henri Mondor, INSERM, F-94010 Creteil, France
[4] Royal Marsden Hosp, Dept Histopathol, London SW3 6JJ, England
[5] Osped Circolo Varese, Dept Anat Pathol, Varese, Italy
[6] Univ Insubria, Varese, Italy
[7] Osped Bolognini Seriate, Unita Operat Anat Patol, Seriate, Italy
[8] Ist Cantonale Patol, Locarno, Switzerland
[9] Univ Bologna, Chair Pathol, Dept Haematol & Oncol Sci L&A Seragnoli, Bologna, Italy
[10] Univ Bologna, Unit Haematopathol, Dept Haematol & Oncol Sci L&A Seragnoli, Bologna, Italy
[11] Oncol Inst So Switzerland IOSI, Bellinzona, Switzerland
[12] Univ Piemonte Orientale Amedeo Avogadro, AOU Maggiore Carita, Novara, Italy
[13] Ist Sci San Raffaele, Pathol Unit, Unit Lymphoid Malignancies, I-20132 Milan, Italy
[14] Ist Sci San Raffaele, Unit Lymphoid Malignancies, Dept Oncohematol, I-20132 Milan, Italy
关键词
gastric MALT lymphoma; inter-observer agreement; histological scoring system; response criteria for lymphoma; HELICOBACTER-PYLORI ERADICATION; POLYMERASE-CHAIN-REACTION; MARGINAL ZONE LYMPHOMA; LONG-TERM PERSISTENCE; MOLECULAR FOLLOW-UP; B-CELL LYMPHOMA; TISSUE LYMPHOMA; REMISSION; INFECTION; CRITERIA;
D O I
10.1111/bjh.12078
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
The International Extranodal Lymphoma Study Group ( IELSG) promoted this study to determine the inter-observer agreement in the application of the Groupe d' Etude des Lymphomes de l' Adulte ( GELA) histological scoring system for evaluating residual disease in post-treatment gastric biopsies of patients with gastric Mucosa-Associated Lymphoid Tissue ( MALT) lymphoma ( GML). Twenty-one patients with Helicobacter pylori -associated GML and treated with anti-H. pylori therapies were considered. A total of 154 biopsy sets from follow-up endoscopic procedures after H. pylori eradication were examined independently by seven pathologists from four European countries, following histological criteria suggested by the GELA scoring system. The overall concordance rate was 83% with a kappa value of 0.64, indicating a significant agreement among the seven observers. Most non-concordant responses clustered across the border of complete remission ( CR) and probable minimal residual disease ( pMRD), a distinction that does not imply critical clinical impact. Accordingly, when the analysis considered CR/pMRD as a single entity, the responses showed an overall concordance rate of 89% with kappa value of 0.83, thus indicating a high degree of inter-observer agreement. This study provides additional validation of the GELA histological grading system. This scheme can therefore be recommended in routine practice and deserves to be used in prospective clinical trials.
引用
收藏
页码:47 / 52
页数:6
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]   Molecular follow-up in gastric mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue lymphomas: early analysis of the LY03 cooperative trial [J].
Bertoni, F ;
Conconi, A ;
Capella, C ;
Motta, T ;
Giardini, R ;
Ponzoni, M ;
Pedrinis, E ;
Novero, D ;
Rinaldi, P ;
Cazzaniga, G ;
Biondi, A ;
Wotherspoon, A ;
Hancock, BW ;
Smith, P ;
Souhami, R ;
Cotter, FE ;
Cavalli, F ;
Zucca, E .
BLOOD, 2002, 99 (07) :2541-2544
[2]   Revised response criteria for malignant lymphoma [J].
Cheson, Bruce D. ;
Pfistner, Beate ;
Juweid, Malik E. ;
Gascoyne, Randy D. ;
Specht, Lena ;
Horning, Sandra J. ;
Coiffier, Bertrand ;
Fisher, Richard I. ;
Hagenbeek, Anton ;
Zucca, Emanuele ;
Rosen, Steven T. ;
Stroobants, Sigrid ;
Lister, T. Andrew ;
Hoppe, Richard T. ;
Dreyling, Martin ;
Tobinai, Kensei ;
Vose, Julie M. ;
Connors, Joseph M. ;
Federico, Massimo ;
Diehl, Volker .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2007, 25 (05) :579-586
[3]   A COEFFICIENT OF AGREEMENT FOR NOMINAL SCALES [J].
COHEN, J .
EDUCATIONAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL MEASUREMENT, 1960, 20 (01) :37-46
[4]   Proposal for a new histological grading system for post-treatment evaluation of gastric MALT lymphoma [J].
Copie-Bergman, C ;
Gaulard, P ;
Lavergne-Slove, A ;
Brousse, N ;
Fléjou, JF ;
Dordonne, K ;
de Mascarel, A ;
Wotherspoon, AC .
GUT, 2003, 52 (11) :1656-1656
[5]  
Copie-Bergman C., 2008, EXTRANODAL LYMPHOMAS, P114
[6]   Clinical, histological and molecular follow-up of 60 patients with gastric marginal zone lymphoma of mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue [J].
de Mascarel, A ;
Ruskone-Fourmestraux, A ;
Lavergne-Slove, A ;
Megraud, F ;
Dubus, P ;
Merlio, JP .
VIRCHOWS ARCHIV, 2005, 446 (03) :219-224
[7]   Gastric MALT lymphoma: from aetiology to treatment [J].
Du, MQ ;
Isaccson, PG .
LANCET ONCOLOGY, 2002, 3 (02) :97-104
[8]   Long term outcome of patients with gastric marginal zone B cell lymphoma of mucosa associated lymphoid tissue (MALT) following exclusive Helicobacter pylori eradication therapy:: experience from a large prospective series [J].
Fischbach, W ;
Goebeler-Kolve, ME ;
Dragosics, B ;
Greiner, A ;
Stolte, M .
GUT, 2004, 53 (01) :34-37
[9]   Chlorambucil versus observation after anti-Helicobacter therapy in gastric MALT lymphomas: results of the international randomised LY03 trial [J].
Hancock, Barry W. ;
Qian, Wendi ;
Linch, David ;
Delchier, Jean-Charles ;
Smith, Paul ;
Jakupovic, Ira ;
Burton, Cathy ;
Souhami, Robert ;
Wotherspoon, Andrew ;
Copie-Bergman, Christiane ;
Capella, Carlo ;
Traulle, Catherine ;
Levy, Michael ;
Cortelazzo, Sergio ;
Ferreri, Andres J. M. ;
Ambrosetti, Achille ;
Pinotti, Graziella ;
Martinelli, Giovanni ;
Vitolo, Umberto ;
Cavalli, Franco ;
Gisselbrecht, Christian ;
Zucca, Emanuele .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF HAEMATOLOGY, 2009, 144 (03) :367-375
[10]   Wotherspoon criteria combined with B cell clonality analysis by advanced polymerase chain reaction technology discriminates covert gastric marginal zone lymphoma from chronic gastritis [J].
Hummel, M ;
Oeschger, S ;
Barth, TFE ;
Loddenkemper, C ;
Cogliatti, SB ;
Marx, A ;
Wacker, HH ;
Feller, AC ;
Bernd, HW ;
Hansmann, ML ;
Stein, H ;
Möller, O .
GUT, 2006, 55 (06) :782-787