Probing the early Universe cosmology with NANOGrav: Possibilities and limitations

被引:27
作者
Ben-Dayan, Ido [1 ]
Kumar, Utkarsh [1 ]
Thattarampilly, Udaykrishna [1 ]
Verma, Amresh [1 ]
机构
[1] Ariel Univ, Phys Dept, IL-4070001 Ariel, Israel
关键词
D O I
10.1103/PhysRevD.108.103507
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
A stochastic gravitational wave background is a prediction of a number of astrophysical and cosmological phenomena including early Universe cosmology. Recently, the NANOGrav Collaboration reported conclusive evidence for a stochastic gravitational wave background. We analyze the NANOGrav signal, assuming it is of primordial origin, including the reheating phase. We use the latest measurements from NANOGrav to constrain the Universe's reheating equation of state wre, the reheating temperature Tre, the tensor-to-scalar ratio r, and the tensor tilt n,. Assuming the constant equation of state wre to be responsible for the reheating phase, we find a preference for instant reheating, wre = 0.36 thorn 0.15 -0.28 , and a very blue tilt n, = 1.94 thorn 0.43 -0.88 . We find a degeneracy between the tensor-to-scalar ratio r and Tre and suggest ways to break this degeneracy. In all cases where the reheating temperature is constrained, it is constrained to be very low, with Tre <= 105 GeV. We further find that a scale-invariant spectrum, as suggested by inflation, implies a stiff equation of state wre = 19/3. If extrapolated, the blue-tilted primordial spectrum that agrees with the NANOGrav signal at corresponding frequencies is incompatible with the LIGO bound. This incompatibility is another challenge for connecting NANOGrav with the primordial spectrum. We discuss a number of ways to circumvent this issue. We split the spectrum into a sum of astrophysical and primordial spectra and constrain the astrophysical and primordial components using NANOGrav data and the LIGO bound. In another attempt, we use the same data and constrain the running of the spectrum. Any of these, or a combination of such methods, can be used to reconcile the NANOGrav data and the LIGO bound with the primordial power spectrum.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 104 条
[1]   Upper limits on the isotropic gravitational-wave background from Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo's third observing run [J].
Abbott, R. ;
Abbott, T. D. ;
Abraham, S. ;
Acernese, F. ;
Ackley, K. ;
Adams, A. ;
Adams, C. ;
Adhikari, R. X. ;
Adya, V. B. ;
Affeldt, C. ;
Agarwal, D. ;
Agathos, M. ;
Agatsuma, K. ;
Aggarwal, N. ;
Aguiar, O. D. ;
Aiello, L. ;
Ain, A. ;
Akutsu, T. ;
Aleman, K. M. ;
Allen, G. ;
Allocca, A. ;
Altin, P. A. ;
Amato, A. ;
Anand, S. ;
Ananyeva, A. ;
Anderson, S. B. ;
Anderson, W. G. ;
Ando, M. ;
Angelova, S., V ;
Ansoldi, S. ;
Antelis, J. M. ;
Antier, S. ;
Appert, S. ;
Arai, Koya ;
Arai, Koji ;
Arai, Y. ;
Araki, S. ;
Araya, A. ;
Araya, M. C. ;
Areeda, J. S. ;
Arene, M. ;
Aritomi, N. ;
Arnaud, N. ;
Aronson, S. M. ;
Asada, H. ;
Asali, Y. ;
Ashton, G. ;
Aso, Y. ;
Aston, S. M. ;
Astone, P. .
PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 2021, 104 (02)
[2]   Improved Constraints on Primordial Gravitational Waves using Planck, WMAP, and BICEP/Keck Observations through the 2018 Observing Season [J].
Ade, P. A. R. ;
Ahmed, Z. ;
Amiri, M. ;
Barkats, D. ;
Thakur, R. Basu ;
Bischoff, C. A. ;
Beck, D. ;
Bock, J. J. ;
Boenish, H. ;
Bullock, E. ;
Buza, V ;
Cheshire, J. R. ;
Connors, J. ;
Cornelison, J. ;
Crumrine, M. ;
Cukierman, A. ;
Denison, E., V ;
Dierickx, M. ;
Duband, L. ;
Eiben, M. ;
Fatigoni, S. ;
Filippini, J. P. ;
Fliescher, S. ;
Goeckner-Wald, N. ;
Goldfinger, D. C. ;
Grayson, J. ;
Grimes, P. ;
Hall, G. ;
Halal, G. ;
Halpern, M. ;
Hand, E. ;
Harrison, S. ;
Henderson, S. ;
Hildebrandt, S. R. ;
Hilton, G. C. ;
Hubmayr, J. ;
Hui, H. ;
Irwin, K. D. ;
Kang, J. ;
Karkare, K. S. ;
Karpel, E. ;
Kefeli, S. ;
Kernasovskiy, S. A. ;
Kovac, J. M. ;
Kuo, C. L. ;
Lau, K. ;
Leitch, E. M. ;
Lennox, A. ;
Megerian, K. G. ;
Minutolo, L. .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2021, 127 (15)
[3]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Search for Signals from New Physics [J].
Afzal, Adeela ;
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash M. ;
Archibald, Anne ;
Arzoumanian, Zaven T. ;
Baker, Paul ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Blanco-Pillado, Jose Juan ;
Blecha, Laura K. ;
Boddy, Kimberly ;
Brazier, Adam R. ;
Brook, Paul ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Burnette, Rand ;
Case, Robin ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Chatziioannou, Katerina D. ;
Cheeseboro, Belinda ;
Chen, Siyuan ;
Cohen, Tyler M. ;
Cordes, James J. ;
Cornish, Neil ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn J. ;
Cutler, Curt E. ;
DeCesar, Megan ;
DeGan, Dallas B. ;
Demorest, Paul ;
Deng, Heling ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
von Eckardstein, Richard C. ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel E. ;
Freedman, Gabriel ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate A. ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Gersbach, Kyle ;
Glaser, Joseph C. ;
Good, Deborah ;
Guertin, Lydia ;
Gueltekin, Kayhan S. ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey ;
Hourihane, Sophie ;
Islo, Kristina J. ;
Jennings, Ross D. ;
Johnson, Aaron L. .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 951 (01)
[4]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Search for Anisotropy in the Gravitational-wave Background [J].
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash ;
Archibald, Anne M. ;
Arzoumanian, Zaven ;
Baker, Paul T. ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Blecha, Laura ;
Brazier, Adam ;
Brook, Paul R. ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Casey-Clyde, J. Andrew ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Cohen, Tyler ;
Cordes, James M. ;
Cornish, Neil J. ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn ;
DeCesar, Megan E. ;
Demorest, Paul B. ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth C. ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel ;
Freedman, Gabriel E. ;
Gardiner, Emiko ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Glaser, Joseph ;
Good, Deborah C. ;
Gultekin, Kayhan ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey S. ;
Jennings, Ross J. ;
Johnson, Aaron D. ;
Jones, Megan L. ;
Kaiser, Andrew R. ;
Kaplan, David L. ;
Kelley, Luke Zolt ;
Kerr, Matthew ;
Key, Joey S. ;
Laal, Nima ;
Lam, Michael T. ;
Lamb, William G. ;
Lazio, T. Joseph W. ;
Lewandowska, Natalia ;
Liu, Tingting ;
Lorimer, Duncan R. ;
Luo, Jing .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 956 (01)
[5]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Constraints on Supermassive Black Hole Binaries from the Gravitational-wave Background [J].
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash ;
Archibald, Anne M. ;
Baker, Paul T. ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Blecha, Laura ;
Bonilla, Alexander ;
Brazier, Adam ;
Brook, Paul ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Burnette, Rand ;
Case, Robin ;
Casey-Clyde, J. Andrew ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Chatziioannou, Katerina ;
Cheeseboro, Belinda D. ;
Chen, Siyuan ;
Cohen, Tyler ;
Cordes, James M. ;
Cornish, Neil J. ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn ;
Cutler, Curt E. ;
D'Orazio, Daniel J. ;
DeCesar, Megan E. ;
DeGan, Dallas ;
Demorest, Paul B. ;
Deng, Heling ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel ;
Freedman, Gabriel E. ;
Gardiner, Emiko ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Gersbach, Kyle A. ;
Glaser, Joseph ;
Good, Deborah C. ;
Gultekin, Kayhan ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey ;
Hourihane, Sophie J. ;
Islo, Kristina ;
Jennings, Ross L. ;
Johnson, Aaron ;
Jones, Megan L. ;
Kaiser, Andrew R. .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 952 (02)
[6]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Bayesian Limits on Gravitational Waves from Individual Supermassive Black Hole Binaries [J].
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash ;
Archibald, Anne M. ;
Arzoumanian, Zaven ;
Baker, Paul T. ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Blecha, Laura ;
Brazier, Adam ;
Brook, Paul R. ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Case, Robin ;
Casey-Clyde, J. Andrew ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Cohen, Tyler ;
Cordes, James M. ;
Cornish, Neil J. ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn ;
DeCesar, Megan E. ;
Demorest, Paul B. ;
Digman, Matthew C. ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth C. ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel ;
Freedman, Gabriel E. ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Glaser, Joseph ;
Good, Deborah C. ;
Gueltekin, Kayhan ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey S. ;
Hourihane, Sophie ;
Jennings, Ross J. ;
Johnson, Aaron D. ;
Jones, Megan L. ;
Kaiser, Andrew R. ;
Kaplan, David L. ;
Kelley, Luke Zoltan ;
Kerr, Matthew ;
Key, Joey S. ;
Laal, Nima ;
Lam, Michael T. ;
Lamb, William G. ;
Lazio, T. Joseph W. ;
Lewandowska, Natalia ;
Liu, Tingting .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 951 (02)
[7]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Detector Characterization and Noise Budget [J].
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash ;
Archibald, Anne M. ;
Arzoumanian, Zaven ;
Baker, Paul T. ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Blecha, Laura ;
Brazier, Adam ;
Brook, Paul R. ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Cohen, Tyler ;
Cordes, James M. ;
Cornish, Neil J. ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn ;
DeCesar, Megan E. ;
Demorest, Paul B. ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth C. ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel ;
Freedman, Gabriel E. ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Glaser, Joseph ;
Good, Deborah C. ;
Guertin, Lydia ;
Gultekin, Kayhan ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey S. ;
Jennings, Ross J. ;
Johnson, Aaron D. ;
Jones, Megan L. ;
Kaiser, Andrew R. ;
Kaplan, David L. ;
Kelley, Luke Zoltan ;
Kerr, Matthew ;
Key, Joey S. ;
Laal, Nima ;
Lam, Michael T. ;
Lamb, William G. ;
Lazio, T. Joseph W. ;
Lewandowska, Natalia ;
Liu, Tingting ;
Lorimer, Duncan R. ;
Luo, Jing ;
Lynch, Ryan S. .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 951 (01)
[8]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Observations and Timing of 68 Millisecond Pulsars [J].
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Alam, Md Faisal ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash ;
Archibald, Anne M. ;
Arzoumanian, Zaven ;
Baker, Paul T. ;
Blecha, Laura ;
Bonidie, Victoria ;
Brazier, Adam ;
Brook, Paul R. ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Chapman, Christopher ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Cohen, Tyler ;
Cordes, James M. ;
Cornish, Neil J. ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn ;
DeCesar, Megan E. ;
Demorest, Paul B. ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth C. ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel ;
Freedman, Gabriel E. ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Glaser, Joseph ;
Good, Deborah C. ;
Gueltekin, Kayhan ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey S. ;
Jennings, Ross J. ;
Jessup, Cody ;
Johnson, Aaron D. ;
Jones, Megan L. ;
Kaiser, Andrew R. ;
Kaplan, David L. ;
Kelley, Luke Zoltan ;
Kerr, Matthew ;
Key, Joey S. ;
Kuske, Anastasia ;
Laal, Nima ;
Lam, Michael T. ;
Lamb, William G. ;
W. Lazio, T. Joseph W. ;
Lewandowska, Natalia .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 951 (01)
[9]   The NANOGrav 15 yr Data Set: Evidence for a Gravitational-wave Background [J].
Agazie, Gabriella ;
Anumarlapudi, Akash ;
Archibald, Anne M. ;
Arzoumanian, Zaven ;
Baker, Paul T. ;
Becsy, Bence ;
Blecha, Laura ;
Brazier, Adam ;
Brook, Paul R. ;
Burke-Spolaor, Sarah ;
Burnette, Rand ;
Case, Robin ;
Charisi, Maria ;
Chatterjee, Shami ;
Chatziioannou, Katerina ;
Cheeseboro, Belinda D. ;
Chen, Siyuan ;
Cohen, Tyler ;
Cordes, James M. ;
Cornish, Neil ;
Crawford, Fronefield ;
Cromartie, H. Thankful ;
Crowter, Kathryn ;
Cutler, Curt J. ;
DeCesar, Megan E. ;
DeGan, Dallas ;
Demorest, Paul B. ;
Deng, Heling ;
Dolch, Timothy ;
Drachler, Brendan ;
Ellis, Justin A. ;
Ferrara, Elizabeth C. ;
Fiore, William ;
Fonseca, Emmanuel ;
Freedman, Gabriel E. ;
Garver-Daniels, Nate ;
Gentile, Peter A. ;
Gersbach, Kyle A. ;
Glaser, Joseph ;
Good, Deborah C. ;
Gueltekin, Kayhan ;
Hazboun, Jeffrey S. ;
Hourihane, Sophie ;
Islo, Kristina ;
Jennings, Ross J. ;
Johnson, Aaron D. ;
Jones, Megan L. ;
Kaiser, Andrew R. ;
Kaplan, David L. ;
Kelley, Luke Zoltan .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL LETTERS, 2023, 951 (01)
[10]   Planck 2018 results: VIII. Gravitational lensing [J].
Aghanim, N. ;
Akrami, Y. ;
Ashdown, M. ;
Aumont, J. ;
Baccigalupi, C. ;
Ballardini, M. ;
Banday, A. J. ;
Barreiro, R. B. ;
Bartolo, N. ;
Basak, S. ;
Benabed, K. ;
Bernard, J. -P. ;
Bersanelli, M. ;
Bielewicz, P. ;
Bock, J. J. ;
Bond, J. R. ;
Borrill, J. ;
Bouchet, F. R. ;
Boulanger, F. ;
Bucher, M. ;
Burigana, C. ;
Calabrese, E. ;
Cardoso, J. -F. ;
Carron, J. ;
Challinor, A. ;
Chiang, H. C. ;
Colombo, L. P. L. ;
Combet, C. ;
Crill, B. P. ;
Cuttaia, F. ;
de Bernardis, P. ;
de Zotti, G. ;
Delabrouille, J. ;
Di Valentino, E. ;
Diego, J. M. ;
Dore, O. ;
Douspis, M. ;
Ducout, A. ;
Dupac, X. ;
Efstathiou, G. ;
Elsner, F. ;
Ensslin, T. A. ;
Eriksen, H. K. ;
Fantaye, Y. ;
Fernandez-Cobos, R. ;
Finelli, F. ;
Forastieri, F. ;
Frailis, M. ;
Fraisse, A. A. ;
Franceschi, E. .
ASTRONOMY & ASTROPHYSICS, 2020, 641 (641)