Nonpharmaceutical interventions reduce the incidence and mortality of COVID-19: A study based on the survey from the International COVID-19 Research Network (ICRN)

被引:8
作者
Park, Seung Hyun [1 ]
Hong, Sung Hwi [1 ]
Kim, Kwanghyun [2 ,3 ]
Lee, Seung Won [4 ]
Yon, Dong Keon [5 ]
Jung, Sun Jae [2 ,3 ]
Abdeen, Ziad [6 ]
Abou Ghayda, Ramy [7 ]
Ahmed, Mohamed Lemine Cheikh Brahim [8 ,9 ]
Al Serouri, Abdulwahed [10 ]
Al-Herz, Waleed [11 ]
Al-Shamsi, Humaid O. [12 ]
Ali, Sheeza [13 ]
Ali, Kosar [14 ]
Baatarkhuu, Oidov [15 ]
Nielsen, Henning Bay [16 ,17 ]
Bernini-Carri, Enrico [18 ]
Bondarenko, Anastasiia [19 ]
Cassell, Ayun [20 ]
Cham, Akway [21 ]
Chua, Melvin L. K. [22 ,23 ,24 ]
Dadabhai, Sufia [25 ]
Darre, Tchin [26 ]
Davtyan, Hayk [27 ]
Dragioti, Elena [28 ]
East, Barbora [29 ]
Edwards, Robert Jeffrey [30 ]
Ferioli, Martina [31 ]
Georgiev, Tsvetoslav [32 ]
Ghandour, Lilian A. [33 ]
Harapan, Harapan [34 ]
Hsueh, Po-Ren [35 ,36 ]
Mallah, Saad I. [37 ]
Ikram, Aamer [38 ]
Inoue, Shigeru [39 ]
Jacob, Louis [40 ,41 ]
Jankovic, Slobodan M. [42 ]
Jayarajah, Umesh [43 ]
Jesenak, Milos [44 ]
Kakodkar, Pramath [45 ]
Kapata, Nathan [46 ]
Kebede, Yohannes [47 ]
Khader, Yousef [48 ]
Kifle, Meron [49 ]
Koh, David [50 ]
Males, Visnja Kokic [51 ]
Kotfis, Katarzyna [52 ]
Koyanagi, Ai [53 ]
Kretchy, James-Paul [54 ]
Lakoh, Sulaiman [55 ]
机构
[1] Yonsei Univ, Coll Med, Seoul, South Korea
[2] Yonsei Univ, Dept Prevent Med, Coll Med, Seoul, South Korea
[3] Yonsei Univ, Dept Publ Hlth, Seoul, South Korea
[4] Sungkyunkwan Univ, Dept Precis Med, Sch Med, Suwon, South Korea
[5] Kyung Hee Univ, Coll Med, Med Ctr, Ctr Digital Hlth,Med Sci Res Inst, Seoul, South Korea
[6] Al Quds Univ, Fac Med, Dept Community Hlth, East Jerusalem, Palestine
[7] Univ Hosp Case Western Reserve Univ, Urol Inst, Cleveland, OH USA
[8] Univ Nouakchott Al Aasriya, Nouakchott, Mauritania
[9] Mauritanian Assoc Sci Res Dev AMDRS, Nouakchott, Mauritania
[10] Yemen Field Epidemiol Training Program, Sanaa, Yemen
[11] Kuwait Univ, Fac Med, Jabriya, Kuwait
[12] Burjeel Med City, Burjeel Canc Inst, Abu Dhabi, U Arab Emirates
[13] Maldives Natl Univ, Sch Med, Male, Maldives
[14] Univ Sulaimani, Coll Med, Sulaymaniyah, Iraq
[15] Mongolian Natl Univ Med Sci, Dept Infect Dis, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia
[16] Zealand Univ Hosp Roskilde, Dept Anesthesia & Intens Care, Roskilde, Denmark
[17] Univ Copenhagen, Dept Nutr Exercise & Sports, Copenhagen, Denmark
[18] Council Europe CEMEC, European Ctr Disaster Med, Strasbourg, France
[19] Int European Univ, Dept Pediat Immunol Infect & Rare Dis, Kiev, Ukraine
[20] John F Kennedy Med Ctr, Edison, NJ USA
[21] Univ Juba, Sch Med, Juba, South Sudan
[22] Natl Canc Ctr Singapore, Div Radiat Oncol, Dept Head & Neck & Thorac Canc, Singapore, Singapore
[23] Duke NUS Med Sch, Oncol Acad Programme, Singapore, Singapore
[24] Natl Canc Ctr Singapore, Div Med Sci, Singapore, Singapore
[25] Johns Hopkins Bloomberg Sch Publ Hlth, Dept Epidemiol, Baltimore, MD USA
[26] Univ Lome, Dept Pathol, Lome, Togo
[27] TB Res & Prevent Ctr, Yerevan, Armenia
[28] Linkoping Univ, Pain & Rehabil Ctr, Dept Hlth Med & Caring Sci, Linkoping, Sweden
[29] Charles Univ Prague, Motol Univ Hosp, Med Fac 1, Dept Surg 3, Prague, Czech Republic
[30] Med Res Fdn Trinidad & Tobago, Port Of Spain, Trinidad Tobago
[31] IRCCS Azienda Osped Univ Bologna, Resp & Crit Care Unit, Bologna, Italy
[32] Med Univ Varna, Dept Internal Med 1, Varna, Bulgaria
[33] Amer Univ Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon
[34] Univ Syiah Kuala, Dept Microbiol, Banda Aceh, Indonesia
[35] China Med Univ, China Med Univ Hosp, Dept Lab Med, Taichung, Taiwan
[36] China Med Univ, China Med Univ Hosp, Dept Internal Med, Taichung, Taiwan
[37] Royal Coll Surg Ireland Bahrain, Al Sayh, Bahrain
[38] Natl Inst Hlth, Islamabad, Pakistan
[39] Tokyo Med Univ, Dept Prevent Med & Publ Hlth, Tokyo, Japan
[40] ISCIII, Res & Dev Unit, Parc Sanitari St Joan de Deu, CIBERSAM, Barcelona, Spain
[41] Univ Versailles St Quentin En Yvelines, Fac Med, Montigny Le Bretonneux, France
[42] Univ Kragujevac, Fac Med Sci, Kragujevac, Serbia
[43] Univ Colombo, Postgrad Inst Med, Colombo, Sri Lanka
[44] Comenius Univ, Univ Teaching Hosp Martin, Jessenius Fac Med Martin, Dept Pediat, Bratislava, Slovakia
[45] Natl Univ Ireland, Galway, Ireland
[46] Zambia Natl Publ Hlth Inst, Lusaka, Zambia
[47] Jimma Univ, Dept Hlth Behav & Soc, Jimma, Ethiopia
[48] Jordan Univ Sci & Technol, Dept Publ Hlth, Irbid, Jordan
[49] Univ Oxford, Ctr Trop Med & Global Hlth, Dept Clin Med, Oxford, England
[50] Natl Univ Singapore, Saw Swee Hock Sch Publ Hlth, Singapore, Singapore
关键词
COVID-19; isolation; mask; nonpharmacologic interventions; quarantine; sanitizer; CORONAVIRUS DISEASE 2019; COUNTRIES; INFLUENZA; HEALTH;
D O I
10.1002/jmv.28354
中图分类号
Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 100705 ;
摘要
The recently emerged novel coronavirus, "severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2)," caused a highly contagious disease called coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). It has severely damaged the world's most developed countries and has turned into a major threat for low- and middle-income countries. Since its emergence in late 2019, medical interventions have been substantial, and most countries relied on public health measures collectively known as nonpharmaceutical interventions (NPIs). We aimed to centralize the accumulative knowledge of NPIs against COVID-19 for each country under one worldwide consortium. International COVID-19 Research Network collaborators developed a cross-sectional online survey to assess the implications of NPIs and sanitary supply on the incidence and mortality of COVID-19. The survey was conducted between January 1 and February 1, 2021, and participants from 92 countries/territories completed it. The association between NPIs, sanitation supplies, and incidence and mortality were examined by multivariate regression, with the log-transformed value of population as an offset value. The majority of countries/territories applied several preventive strategies, including social distancing (100.0%), quarantine (100.0%), isolation (98.9%), and school closure (97.8%). Individual-level preventive measures such as personal hygiene (100.0%) and wearing facial masks (94.6% at hospitals; 93.5% at mass transportation; 91.3% in mass gathering facilities) were also frequently applied. Quarantine at a designated place was negatively associated with incidence and mortality compared to home quarantine. Isolation at a designated place was also associated with reduced mortality compared to home isolation. Recommendations to use sanitizer for personal hygiene reduced incidence compared to the recommendation to use soap. Deprivation of masks was associated with increased incidence. Higher incidence and mortality were found in countries/territories with higher economic levels. Mask deprivation was pervasive regardless of economic level. NPIs against COVID-19 such as using sanitizer, quarantine, and isolation can decrease the incidence and mortality of COVID-19.
引用
收藏
页数:17
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Synchronized nonpharmaceutical interventions for the control of COVID-19
    Bing Zhang
    Shiwen Liang
    Gang Wang
    Chi Zhang
    Cai Chen
    Min Zou
    Wei Shen
    Haoyu Long
    Daihai He
    Yuelong Shu
    Xiangjun Du
    Nonlinear Dynamics, 2021, 106 : 1477 - 1489
  • [2] Synchronized nonpharmaceutical interventions for the control of COVID-19
    Zhang, Bing
    Liang, Shiwen
    Wang, Gang
    Zhang, Chi
    Chen, Cai
    Zou, Min
    Shen, Wei
    Long, Haoyu
    He, Daihai
    Shu, Yuelong
    Du, Xiangjun
    NONLINEAR DYNAMICS, 2021, 106 (02) : 1477 - 1489
  • [3] Nonpharmaceutical interventions for tackling the COVID-19 epidemic in Brazil
    Garcia, Leila Posenato
    Duarte, Elisete
    EPIDEMIOLOGIA E SERVICOS DE SAUDE, 2020, 29 (02):
  • [4] Nonpharmaceutical interventions contribute to the control of COVID-19 in China based on a pairwise model
    Luo, Xiao-Feng
    Feng, Shanshan
    Yang, Junyuan
    Peng, Xiao-Long
    Cao, Xiaochun
    Zhang, Juping
    Yao, Meiping
    Zhu, Huaiping
    Li, Michael Y.
    Wang, Hao
    Jin, Zhen
    INFECTIOUS DISEASE MODELLING, 2021, 6 : 643 - 663
  • [5] The impact of COVID-19 nonpharmaceutical interventions on the future dynamics of endemic infections
    Baker, Rachel E.
    Park, Sang Woo
    Yang, Wenchang
    Vecchi, Gabriel A.
    Metcalf, C. Jessica E.
    Grenfell, Bryan T.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, 2020, 117 (48) : 30547 - 30553
  • [6] Nonpharmaceutical interventions in Turkey and worldwide during COVID-19 pandemic
    Ilhan, Mustafa Necmi
    Tuzun, Hakan
    Kilic, Rahmi
    Yildirim, Nuran
    TURKISH JOURNAL OF MEDICAL SCIENCES, 2021, 51 : 3207 - 3214
  • [7] From Prediction to Prescription: Evolutionary Optimization of Nonpharmaceutical Interventions in the COVID-19 Pandemic
    Miikkulainen, Risto
    Francon, Olivier
    Meyerson, Elliot
    Qiu, Xin
    Sargent, Darren
    Canzani, Elisa
    Hodjat, Babak
    IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON EVOLUTIONARY COMPUTATION, 2021, 25 (02) : 386 - 401
  • [8] Quantifying the Impact of COVID-19 Nonpharmaceutical Interventions on Influenza Transmission in the United States
    Qi, Yuchen
    Shaman, Jeffrey
    Pei, Sen
    JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2021, 224 (09) : 1500 - 1508
  • [9] HPV and Covid-19 Era: effects of nonpharmaceutical interventions on HPV transmission
    Luigi, Ronga
    Stefania, Stolfa
    Francesca, Indraccolo
    Federica, Romanelli
    Fiore, Bavaro Davide
    Annalisa, Saracino
    Francesco, Di Gennaro
    Eugenio, Milano
    Mandorino, Manuela
    Adriana, Mosca
    Eleonora, Sparapano
    Carmela, De Carlo
    Lucia, Nisi
    Enrica, Ranieri
    Michele, Mastria
    Maria Teresa, Montagna
    Raffaele, Del Prete
    PATHOGENS AND GLOBAL HEALTH, 2023, 117 (08) : 735 - 743
  • [10] Mortality from COVID-19
    Franchini, M.
    Bongiovanni, G.
    Cruciani, M.
    ANNALI DI IGIENE MEDICINA PREVENTIVA E DI COMUNITA, 2021, 33 (05): : 521 - 523