A botanical reference set illustrating a weight of evidence approach for skin sensitization risk assessment

被引:0
作者
Gao, Yuan [1 ]
Ryan, Cindy A. [2 ]
Ellingson, Kim [3 ]
Krutz, Nora [4 ]
Kern, Petra S. [4 ]
机构
[1] Procter & Gamble Technol Beijing Co Ltd, Beijing, Peoples R China
[2] ToxTech Solut LLC, Milan, IN USA
[3] Mason Business Ctr, Procter & Gamble, 8700 Mason Montgomery Rd, Mason, OH 45040 USA
[4] Procter & Gamble Serv Co NV, Strombeek-bever, Belgium
关键词
Botanical; Natural substance; Skin sensitization; Risk assessment; Weight of evidence (WoE); ALLERGIC CONTACT-DERMATITIS; THRESHOLD DST APPROACH; CASHEW NUT SHELL; SAFETY ASSESSMENT; POISON OAK; IVY URUSHIOL; INGREDIENTS; IDENTIFICATION; PLANTS; L;
D O I
10.1016/j.fct.2023.114413
中图分类号
TS2 [食品工业];
学科分类号
0832 ;
摘要
Recent years have seen an increase in the use of botanicals and natural substances (BNS) in consumer products such as cosmetics and household care products. Most work conducted to date to assess botanicals for human safety has focused their use as dietary supplements and thus on systemic toxicity. However, the induction of skin sensitization is a possible adverse effect of natural products in particular those that come into skin contact, especially for cosmetics that remain on the skin and are not rinsed off following use. Assessments of BNS ingredients are often challenging for a number of reasons: the BNS are complex mixtures that can be of mostly unknown composition; the composition can be highly variable even within the same plant species and dependent on how processed; the physical form of the BNS raw material can vary from a highly concentrated powdered extract to a liquid extract containing only a small percentage of the BNS; testing of the BNS raw materials in New Approach Methods (NAM) has uncertainty as these methods are often not developed or validated for complex mixtures. In this study, a reference set of 14 selected BNS which span the range of skin sensitization potential was complied. These data were used in a Weight of Evidence (WoE) approach to evaluate their skin sensitization potential with each of the data rich BNS being classified as either having strong evidence of inducing skin sensitization based on human topical use history, animal data, clinical data, composition data and NAM data, or having some but more limited (weak) evidence of inducing skin sensitization, or having strong evidence of no skin sensitization potential. When available data have sufficient potency related information, sensitization potency assessment is also provided based on WoE, classifying these BNS as either strong, moderate, or weak sensitizers, or non-sensitizers. An outline for a BNS skin sensitization risk assessment framework is proposed starting with exposure-based waiving and WoE assessment for higher exposures. In addition to demonstrating the application of the WoE approach, the reference set presented here provides a set of 'data rich' botanicals which cover a range of sensitization potencies that could be used for evaluating existing test methods or aid in the development of new predictive models for skin sensitization.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
[31]   An assessment of the skin sensitisation hazard of a group of polyfunctional silicones using a weight of evidence approach [J].
Petry, Thomas ;
Bosch, Axel ;
Coste, Xavier ;
Dupuis, Valerie ;
Eigler, Dorothea ;
Germain, Pierre .
REGULATORY TOXICOLOGY AND PHARMACOLOGY, 2012, 64 (02) :305-314
[32]   Bayesian integrated testing strategy (ITS) for skin sensitization potency assessment: a decision support system for quantitative weight of evidence and adaptive testing strategy [J].
Jaworska, Joanna S. ;
Natsch, Andreas ;
Ryan, Cindy ;
Strickland, Judy ;
Ashikaga, Takao ;
Miyazawa, Masaaki .
ARCHIVES OF TOXICOLOGY, 2015, 89 (12) :2355-2383
[33]   Skin sensitization quantitative risk assessment for occupational exposure of hairdressers to hair dye ingredients [J].
Goebel, Carsten ;
Diepgen, Thomas L. ;
Bloemeke, Brunhilde ;
Gaspari, Anthony A. ;
Schnuch, Axel ;
Fuchs, Anne ;
Schlotmann, Kordula ;
Krasteva, Maya ;
Kimber, Ian .
REGULATORY TOXICOLOGY AND PHARMACOLOGY, 2018, 95 :124-132
[34]   Reactivity Profiling: Covalent Modification of Single Nucleophile Peptides for Skin Sensitization Risk Assessment [J].
Aleksic, Maja ;
Thain, Emma ;
Roger, Delphine ;
Saib, Ouarda ;
Davies, Michael ;
Li, Jin ;
Aptula, Aynur ;
Zazzeroni, Raniero .
TOXICOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2009, 108 (02) :401-411
[35]   Plant extracts, polymers and new approach methods: Practical experience with skin sensitization assessment [J].
Kolle, Susanne N. ;
Flach, Melanie ;
Kleber, Marcus ;
Basketter, David A. ;
Wareing, Britta ;
Mehling, Annette ;
Hareng, Lars ;
Watzek, Nico ;
Bade, Steffen ;
Funk-Weyer, Dorothee ;
Landsiedel, Robert .
REGULATORY TOXICOLOGY AND PHARMACOLOGY, 2023, 138
[36]   Adjustment of a no expected sensitization induction level derived from Bayesian network integrated testing strategy for skin sensitization risk assessment [J].
Otsubo, Yuki ;
Nishijo, Taku ;
Mizumachi, Hideyuki ;
Saito, Kazutoshi ;
Miyazawa, Masaaki ;
Sakaguchi, Hitoshi .
JOURNAL OF TOXICOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2020, 45 (01) :57-67
[37]   Evaluation of combinations of in vitro sensitization test descriptors for the artificial neural network-based risk assessment model of skin sensitization [J].
Hirota, Morihiko ;
Fukui, Shiho ;
Okamoto, Kenji ;
Kurotani, Satoru ;
Imai, Noriyasu ;
Fujishiro, Miyuki ;
Kyotani, Daiki ;
Kato, Yoshinao ;
Kasahara, Toshihiko ;
Fujita, Masaharu ;
Toyoda, Akemi ;
Sekiya, Daisuke ;
Watanabe, Shinichi ;
Seto, Hirokazu ;
Takenouchi, Osamu ;
Ashikaga, Takao ;
Miyazawa, Masaaki .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 2015, 35 (11) :1333-1347
[38]   From Pathways to People: Applying the Adverse Outcome Pathway (AOP) for Skin Sensitization to Risk Assessment [J].
MacKay, Cameron ;
Davies, Michael ;
Summerfield, Vicki ;
Maxwell, Gavin .
ALTEX-ALTERNATIVES TO ANIMAL EXPERIMENTATION, 2013, 30 (04) :473-486
[39]   Deriving a Continuous Point of Departure for Skin Sensitization Risk Assessment Using a Bayesian Network Model [J].
Tourneix, Fleur ;
Carron, Leopold ;
Jouffe, Lionel ;
Hoffmann, Sebastian ;
Alepee, Nathalie .
TOXICS, 2024, 12 (08)
[40]   Chemical stability and in chemico reactivity of 24 fragrance ingredients of concern for skin sensitization risk assessment [J].
Avonto, Cristina ;
Wang, Mei ;
Chittiboyina, Amar G. ;
Vukmanovic, Stanislav ;
Khan, Ikhlas A. .
TOXICOLOGY IN VITRO, 2018, 46 :237-245