A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis Comparing the Diagnostic Accuracy Tests of COVID-19

被引:8
作者
Vilca-Alosilla, Juan Jeferson [1 ,2 ]
Candia-Puma, Mayron Antonio [1 ,2 ]
Coronel-Monje, Katiusca [1 ,2 ]
Goyzueta-Mamani, Luis Daniel [1 ,3 ]
Galdino, Alexsandro Sobreira [4 ]
Machado-de-Avila, Ricardo Andrez [5 ]
Giunchetti, Rodolfo Cordeiro [6 ,7 ]
Coelho, Eduardo Antonio Ferraz [8 ,9 ]
Chavez-Fumagalli, Miguel Angel [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Catolica Santa Maria, Computat Biol & Chem Res Grp, Vicerrectorado Invest, Arequipa 04000, Peru
[2] Univ Catolica Santa Maria, Fac Ciencias Farmaceut Bioquim & Biotecnol, Arequipa 04000, Peru
[3] La Qara Res Ctr, Sustainable Innovat Biomat Dept, Arequipa 04000, Peru
[4] Univ Fed Sao Joao Del Rei, Lab Biotecnol Microrganismos, BR-35501296 Divinopolis, MG, Brazil
[5] Univ Extremo Catarinense, Programa Posgrad Ciencias Saude, BR-88806000 Criciuma, SC, Brazil
[6] Univ Fed Minas Gerais, Lab Biol Interacoes Celulares, Inst Ciencias Biol, BR-31270901 Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil
[7] INCT DT, BR-40015970 Salvador, BA, Brazil
[8] Univ Fed Minas Gerais, Fac Med, Programa Posgrad Ciencias Saude Infectol & Med Tro, BR-31270901 Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil
[9] Univ Fed Minas Gerais, Dept Patol Clin, COLTEC, BR-31270901 Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil
关键词
SARS-CoV-2; diagnostic tests; meta-analysis; systematic review; sensitivity; specificity; SARS-COV-2 ANTIGEN TEST; CLINICAL VALIDATION; SEROLOGIC TESTS; IMMUNOASSAYS; CORONAVIRUS; ASSAY; SENSITIVITY; VACCINATION; INFECTION; DISEASE;
D O I
10.3390/diagnostics13091549
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
In this paper, we present a systematic review and meta-analysis that aims to evaluate the reliability of coronavirus disease diagnostic tests in 2019 (COVID-19). This article seeks to describe the scientific discoveries made because of diagnostic tests conducted in recent years during the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) pandemic. Between 2020 and 2021, searches for published papers on the COVID-19 diagnostic were made in the PubMed database. Ninety-nine scientific articles that satisfied the requirements were analyzed and included in the meta-analysis, and the specificity and sensitivity of the diagnostic accuracy were assessed. When compared to serological tests such as the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), chemiluminescence immunoassay (CLIA), lateral flow immunoassay (LFIA), and chemiluminescent microparticle immunoassay (CMIA), molecular tests such as reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP), and clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) performed better in terms of sensitivity and specificity. Additionally, the area under the curve restricted to the false-positive rates (AUC(FPR)) of 0.984 obtained by the antiviral neutralization bioassay (ANB) diagnostic test revealed significant potential for the identification of COVID-19. It has been established that the various diagnostic tests have been effectively adapted for the detection of SARS-CoV-2; nevertheless, their performance still must be enhanced to contain potential COVID-19 outbreaks, which will also help contain potential infectious agent outbreaks in the future.
引用
收藏
页数:30
相关论文
共 181 条
[1]   The Promise and Peril of Antibody Testing for COVID-19 [J].
Abbasi, Jennifer .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2020, 323 (19) :1881-1883
[2]   The value of anal swab RT-PCR for COVID-19 diagnosis in adult Indonesian patients [J].
Abdullah, Murdani ;
Sudrajat, Dedy Gunawanjati ;
Muzellina, Virly Nanda ;
Kurniawan, Juferdy ;
Rizka, Aulia ;
Utari, Amanda Pitarini ;
Pribadi, Rabbinu Rangga ;
Idrus, Muhammad Firhat ;
Yusra, Yusra ;
Meilany, Sofy ;
Surandy, Andry ;
Shatri, Hamzah ;
Rinaldi, Ikhwan ;
Pitoyo, Ceva Wicaksono ;
Renaldi, Kaka .
BMJ OPEN GASTROENTEROLOGY, 2021, 8 (01)
[3]   Time scale performance of rapid antigen testing for SARS-CoV-2: Evaluation of 10 rapid antigen assays [J].
Abusrewil, Zakarya ;
Alhudiri, Inas M. ;
Kaal, Hamza H. ;
El Meshri, Salah Eldin ;
Ebrahim, Fawzi O. ;
Dalyoum, Tarek ;
Efrefer, Abdussamee A. ;
Ibrahim, Khaled ;
Elfghi, Mohammed B. ;
Abusrewil, Suleiman ;
Elzagheid, Adam .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2021, 93 (12) :6512-6518
[4]   Molecular diagnostic technologies for COVID-19: Limitations and challenges [J].
Afzal, Adeel .
JOURNAL OF ADVANCED RESEARCH, 2020, 26 :149-159
[5]   Saliva for molecular detection of SARS-CoV-2 in school-age children [J].
Al Suwaidi, Hanan ;
Senok, Abiola ;
Varghese, Rupa ;
Deesi, Zulfa ;
Khansaheb, Hamda ;
Pokasirakath, Sabeel ;
Chacko, Bino ;
Abufara, Ibrahim ;
Loney, Tom ;
Alsheikh-Ali, Alawi .
CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2021, 27 (09) :1330-1335
[6]   Field evaluation of a rapid antigen test (Panbio™ COVID-19 Ag Rapid Test Device) for COVID-19 diagnosis in primary healthcare centres [J].
Albert, Eliseo ;
Torres, Ignacio ;
Bueno, Felipe ;
Huntley, Dixie ;
Molla, Estefania ;
Angel Fernandez-Fuentes, Miguel ;
Martinez, Mireia ;
Poujois, Sandrine ;
Forque, Lorena ;
Valdivia, Arantxa ;
Solano de la Asuncion, Carlos ;
Ferrer, Josep ;
Colomina, Javier ;
Navarro, David .
CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2021, 27 (03) :472.e7-472.e10
[7]   Assessment of 12 qualitative RT-PCR commercial kits for the detection of SARS-CoV-2 [J].
Altamimi, Asmaa M. ;
Obeid, Dalia A. ;
Alaifan, Taghreed A. ;
Taha, Moroje T. ;
Alhothali, Marwa T. ;
Alzahrani, Fahad A. ;
Albarrag, Ahmad M. .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2021, 93 (05) :3219-3226
[8]   Evaluation of a Lyophilized CRISPR-Cas12 Assay for a Sensitive, Specific, and Rapid Detection of SARS-CoV-2 [J].
Ana Curti, Lucia ;
Primost, Ivana ;
Valla, Sofia ;
Ibanez Alegre, Daiana ;
Olguin Perglione, Cecilia ;
Daniel Repizo, Guillermo ;
Lara, Julia ;
Parcerisa, Ivana ;
Palacios, Antonela ;
Eugenia Llases, Maria ;
Rinflerch, Adriana ;
Barrios, Melanie ;
Pereyra Bonnet, Federico ;
Alejandra Gimenez, Carla ;
Natalia Marcone, Debora .
VIRUSES-BASEL, 2021, 13 (03)
[9]   Development and performance characteristics evaluation of a new Bioelectric Recognition Assay (BERA) method for rapid Sars-CoV-2 detection in clinical samples [J].
Apostolou, Theofylaktos ;
Kyritsi, Maria ;
Vontas, Alexandros ;
Loizou, Konstantinos ;
Hadjilouka, Agni ;
Speletas, Mathaios ;
Mouchtouri, Varvara ;
Hadjichristodoulou, Christos .
JOURNAL OF VIROLOGICAL METHODS, 2021, 293
[10]   Efficacy and validity of automated quantitative chemiluminescent enzyme immunoassay for SARS-CoV-2 antigen test from saliva specimen in the diagnosis of COVID-19 [J].
Asai, Nobuhiro ;
Sakanashi, Daisuke ;
Ohashi, Wataru ;
Nakamura, Akiko ;
Kawamoto, Yuzuka ;
Miyazaki, Narimi ;
Ohno, Tomoko ;
Yamada, Atsuko ;
Chida, Sumie ;
Shibata, Yuichi ;
Kato, Hideo ;
Shiota, Arufumi ;
Hagihara, Mao ;
Koita, Isao ;
Yamagishi, Yuka ;
Suematsu, Hiroyuki ;
Ohta, Hirotoshi ;
Mikamo, Hiroshige .
JOURNAL OF INFECTION AND CHEMOTHERAPY, 2021, 27 (07) :1039-1042