Modeling the effects of plant resistance, herbivore virulence, and parasitism, on the population dynamics of aphids and parasitoids in wheat and soybean in different climates

Invasions by insects that become pests are an increasing problem for agriculture. Introductions of parasitoids from the regions of pest origin and breeding plants resistant to invasive pests can reduce the abundances and impacts of pests, while providing safe, sustainable alternatives to insecticides. However, impacts of parasitoids and plant resistance are likely to interact, and the abiotic environment, and in particular, climate change is likely to affect these interactions. Here I report results from simulations with mathematical models of population dynamics of aphids and parasitoids on resistant versus susceptible plants, parameterized with published results, designed to test the following hypotheses: (1) parasitoids can reduce abundances and frequencies of virulent aphids able to overcome plant resistance, (2) temperature regime affects the impacts of parasitoids on virulent aphids, and (3) the outcomes of these interactions vary with crop. Two systems were modeled: the soybean aphid, Aphis glycines, on soybean, and the Russian wheat aphid, Diuraphis noeia, on wheat. The parasitoids in the models are in the genus Aphelinus, species of which have a long association with biological control of invasive pests. In the simulations with these models, parasitoids reduced the abundances, and on wheat, the percent of virulent aphids. The impacts of parasitoids on virulent aphids were greater in southern locations than in northern locations, and the impacts on virulent aphids were greater on wheat than on soybean. Indeed, parasitoids actually increased the frequencies of virulent aphids on soybean when only susceptible plants were present, while reducing the abundance of all aphids. If one accepts that comparisons of population dynamics in southern versus northern locations indicate the likely affects of climate change in the northern locations, these results suggest that climate change would lead to decreased abundance and frequency of virulent aphids in northern locations.