Long-term results after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using patellar tendon versus hamstring tendon autograft with a minimum follow-up of 10 years-a systematic review

被引:11
作者
Sollberger, V. D. [1 ]
Korthaus, A. [2 ]
Barg, A. [2 ,3 ]
Pagenstert, G. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Basel, CLARAHOF Clin Orthopaed Surg, Clarahofweg 19a, CH-4058 Basel, Switzerland
[2] Univ Med Ctr Hamburg Eppendorf, Dept Trauma & Orthopaed Surg, Martinistr 52, D-20251 Hamburg, Germany
[3] BG Hosp Hamburg, Dept Trauma Surg Orthopaed & Sports Traumatol, Bergedorfer Str 10, D-21033 Hamburg, Germany
关键词
Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction; Anterior cruciate ligament injury; Patellar tendon; Hamstring tendon; Knee instability; Osteoarthritis; Long-term outcome; RISK-FACTORS; GRAFTS; ACL; BONE; SEMITENDINOSUS; OSTEOARTHRITIS; METAANALYSIS; STABILITY; REVISION; OUTCOMES;
D O I
10.1007/s00402-022-04687-9
中图分类号
R826.8 [整形外科学]; R782.2 [口腔颌面部整形外科学]; R726.2 [小儿整形外科学]; R62 [整形外科学(修复外科学)];
学科分类号
摘要
Introduction A lot of research addresses superiority of the two commonly used autografts bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and hamstring tendon for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, without getting to consensus. While there are numerous studies and reviews on short- to mid-term follow-up, not much literature is available on long-term follow-up. As patients suffering ACL injuries are often of young age and high athletic activity, it is crucial to have the best evidence possible for graft choice to minimize consequences, like osteoarthritis later on. Materials and methods A search of the online databases, PubMed and Embase, was carried out last on 31st March 2022 for studies comparing BPTB and hamstring tendon (HT) autografts for ACL reconstruction in human patients with a minimum follow-up of 10 years. The methodological quality of each study has been evaluated using the modified Coleman Methodology Score. Results on the three variables patient-oriented outcomes, clinical testing and measurements and radiographic outcomes were gathered and are presented in this review. Results Of 1299 records found, nine studies with a total of 1833 patients were identified and included in this systematic review. The methodological quality of the studies ranged from a Coleman Score of 63-88. Many studies reported no or only few statistically significant differences. Significant results in favour of BPTB were found for activity levels and for instrumented laxity testing with the KT-1000 arthrometer. Better outcomes for HT were found in IKDC-SKF, the KOOS, donor site morbidity, pivot shift test, radiographic osteoarthritis (IKDC C or D) and contralateral ACL rupture. No studies presented significant differences in terms of Lysholm Score or Tegner Activity Score, Lachman test, single-legged hop test, deficits in range of motion, osteoarthritis using the Kellgren and Lawrence classification or graft rupture. Conclusion We cannot recommend one graft to be superior, since both grafts show disadvantages in the long-term follow-up. Considering the limitation of our systematic review of no quantitative analysis, we cannot draw further conclusions from the many insignificant results presented by individual studies.
引用
收藏
页码:4277 / 4289
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Peroneus longus tendon autograft has functional outcomes comparable to hamstring tendon autograft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
He, Jinshen ;
Tang, Qi ;
Ernst, Sara ;
Linde, Monica A. ;
Smolinski, Patrick ;
Wu, Song ;
Fu, Freddie .
KNEE SURGERY SPORTS TRAUMATOLOGY ARTHROSCOPY, 2021, 29 (09) :2869-2879
[42]   Arthroscopic posterior cruciate ligament reconstruction by using hamstring tendon autograft and transosseous screw fixation: minimal 3 years follow-up [J].
Norbakhsh, Seyed Taghi ;
Zafarani, Zohreh ;
Najafi, Arvin ;
Aslani, Hamidreza .
ARCHIVES OF ORTHOPAEDIC AND TRAUMA SURGERY, 2014, 134 (12) :1723-1730
[43]   Predictors of Osteoarthritis Development at a Median 25 Years After Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Using a Patellar Tendon Autograft [J].
Lindanger, Line ;
Strand, Torbjorn ;
Molster, Anders Odd ;
Solheim, Eirik ;
Fischer-Bredenbeck, Cornelia ;
Ousdal, Olga Therese ;
Inderhaug, Eivind .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2022, 50 (05) :1195-1204
[44]   Complications following harvesting of patellar tendon or hamstring tendon grafts for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: Systematic review of literature [J].
Hardy, A. ;
Casabianca, L. ;
Andrieu, K. ;
Baverel, L. ;
Noailles, T. .
ORTHOPAEDICS & TRAUMATOLOGY-SURGERY & RESEARCH, 2017, 103 (08) :S245-S248
[45]   A meta-analysis of bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft versus four-strand hamstring tendon autograft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction [J].
Xie, Xiaobo ;
Liu, Xuzhou ;
Chen, Zhongran ;
Yu, Yingdian ;
Peng, Sheng ;
Li, Qi .
KNEE, 2015, 22 (02) :100-110
[46]   Is Quadriceps Tendon Autograft a Better Choice Than Hamstring Autograft for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction? A Comparative Study With a Mean Follow-up of 3.6 Years [J].
Cavaignac, Etienne ;
Coulin, Benoit ;
Tscholl, Philippe ;
Fatmy, Nik Nik Mohd ;
Duthon, Victoria ;
Menetrey, Jacques .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2017, 45 (06) :1326-1332
[47]   Revision anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with hamstring tendon autograft - 5- to 9-year follow-up [J].
Salmon, Lucy J. ;
Pinczewski, Leo A. ;
Russell, Vivianne J. ;
Refshauge, Kathryn .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2006, 34 (10) :1604-1614
[48]   Long-term Outcomes of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction Using Quadriceps Tendon-Patellar Bone Autograft [J].
Lee, Do Weon ;
Lee, Joonhee ;
Jang, Seonpyo ;
Ro, Du Hyun ;
Lee, Myung Chul ;
Han, Hyuk-Soo .
ORTHOPAEDIC JOURNAL OF SPORTS MEDICINE, 2021, 9 (06)
[49]   Outcomes Following Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction with Patellar Tendon vs Hamstring Autografts: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials with a Mean Follow-up of 15 Years [J].
Hoge, Connor G. ;
Matar, Robert N. ;
Khalil, Lafi S. ;
Buchan, John A. ;
Johnson, Cole M. ;
Grawe, Brian M. .
ARCHIVES OF BONE AND JOINT SURGERY-ABJS, 2022, 10 (04) :311-319
[50]   Can peroneus longus tendon autograft become an alternative to hamstring tendon autograft for anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of comparative studies [J].
Opoku, Michael ;
Abdramane, Abakar Mahamat ;
Abdirahman, Ahmed ;
Fang, Mingqing ;
Li, Yusheng ;
Xiao, Wenfeng .
JOURNAL OF ORTHOPAEDIC SURGERY AND RESEARCH, 2025, 20 (01)