Ethnicity and Policing in the Global South: Descriptive Representation and Expectations of Police Bias

被引:3
|
作者
Lyon, Nicholas [1 ,3 ]
Malik, Mashail [2 ]
机构
[1] Stanford Univ, Stanford, CA USA
[2] Harvard Univ, Cambridge, MA USA
[3] Stanford Univ, Dept Polit Sci, Encina Hall West Suite 100, Stanford, CA 94305 USA
关键词
race and ethnicity; policing; descriptive representation; survey experiment; state legitimacy; PROCEDURAL JUSTICE; PUBLIC-GOODS; TRAFFIC STOPS; LEGITIMACY; RACE; BLACK; DIVERSITY; ATTITUDES; SUPPORT; GENDER;
D O I
10.1177/00104140231178747
中图分类号
D0 [政治学、政治理论];
学科分类号
0302 ; 030201 ;
摘要
City residents in the Global South commonly encounter the police. Yet, outside of established democracies, we know little about how ethnicity shapes everyday policing in diverse urban contexts. Existing approaches generate competing expectations, with some arguing that officers are more rather than less discriminatory towards coethnics. We test these theories through a survey experiment conducted in Karachi, Pakistan-one of the world's largest megacities. We find that civilians are only marginally less likely to expect procedural justice from non-coethnic officers, even in a context where ethnicity is highly salient. However, suggestive evidence indicates that this small effect is significantly magnified for respondents who perceive their group to be underrepresented in the police. Descriptive representation is therefore a powerful moderator of the relationship between ethnicity and expectations of police bias. These results have implications for the development of effective and legitimate police institutions in weakly institutionalized contexts.
引用
收藏
页码:851 / 881
页数:31
相关论文
共 32 条
  • [21] Factors affecting strategy commitment to community-oriented policing (COP) among South Korean police officers
    Lee, Chang-Hun
    Lee, Chang-Bae
    POLICING-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF POLICE STRATEGIES & MANAGEMENT, 2011, 34 (04) : 713 - 734
  • [22] Re-theorizing the progress of women in policing: An alternative perspective from the Global South
    Carrington, Kerry
    Rodgers, Jess
    Sozzo, Maximo
    Puyol, Maria Victoria
    THEORETICAL CRIMINOLOGY, 2023, 27 (02) : 283 - 304
  • [23] UNDER-REPRESENTATION OF GLOBAL LEADERS FROM ASIA: COMPETENCY GAP OR AN UNCONSCIOUS BIAS?
    Narayanan, Jayanth
    Zhao, Sophia
    JOURNAL OF LEADERSHIP STUDIES, 2020, 14 (02) : 55 - 57
  • [24] Policing in South Australia's remote and rural communities: preliminary observations from a novel police diversionary strategy for young Indigenous offenders
    Blandford, James
    Sarre, Rick
    POLICE PRACTICE AND RESEARCH, 2009, 10 (03) : 187 - 197
  • [25] Widening access to veterinary education: descriptive analysis of ethnicity, societal representation and educational background of applicants to veterinary education in Aotearoa New Zealand
    Jillings, E. K. P.
    Curtis, E.
    Gardner, D.
    Parkinson, T. J.
    Hecker, K. G.
    Cogger, N.
    NEW ZEALAND VETERINARY JOURNAL, 2021, 69 (03) : 147 - 157
  • [26] Does descriptive representation lead to social desirability bias? Over-reporting of voting among blacks and Latinos in the United States
    Stout, Christopher Timothy
    Martin, Paul J.
    RESEARCH & POLITICS, 2016, 3 (02):
  • [27] "Here be dragons!" The gross under-representation of the Global South on editorial boards in Geography
    Hedding, David William
    Breetzke, Gregory
    GEOGRAPHICAL JOURNAL, 2021, 187 (04) : 331 - 345
  • [28] Forum: Navigating the Global South Landscape: Insights and Implications for Representation and Inclusion in ISA Journals
    Chagas-Bastos, Fabricio H.
    Resende, Erica
    Ghosn, Faten
    Lisle, Debbie
    INTERNATIONAL STUDIES PERSPECTIVES, 2023, 24 (04) : 441 - 466
  • [29] Unheard voices speak up: the Arabidopsis community and the representation of researchers from the Global South
    Auge, Gabriela
    Estevez, Jose M.
    JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL BOTANY, 2024, 75 (08) : 2193 - 2195
  • [30] Gender Matters: Climate Change, Gender Bias, and Women's Farming in the Global South and North
    Glazebrook, Tricia
    Noll, Samantha
    Opoku, Emmanuela
    AGRICULTURE-BASEL, 2020, 10 (07): : 1 - 25