Ethnicity and Policing in the Global South: Descriptive Representation and Expectations of Police Bias

被引:3
|
作者
Lyon, Nicholas [1 ,3 ]
Malik, Mashail [2 ]
机构
[1] Stanford Univ, Stanford, CA USA
[2] Harvard Univ, Cambridge, MA USA
[3] Stanford Univ, Dept Polit Sci, Encina Hall West Suite 100, Stanford, CA 94305 USA
关键词
race and ethnicity; policing; descriptive representation; survey experiment; state legitimacy; PROCEDURAL JUSTICE; PUBLIC-GOODS; TRAFFIC STOPS; LEGITIMACY; RACE; BLACK; DIVERSITY; ATTITUDES; SUPPORT; GENDER;
D O I
10.1177/00104140231178747
中图分类号
D0 [政治学、政治理论];
学科分类号
0302 ; 030201 ;
摘要
City residents in the Global South commonly encounter the police. Yet, outside of established democracies, we know little about how ethnicity shapes everyday policing in diverse urban contexts. Existing approaches generate competing expectations, with some arguing that officers are more rather than less discriminatory towards coethnics. We test these theories through a survey experiment conducted in Karachi, Pakistan-one of the world's largest megacities. We find that civilians are only marginally less likely to expect procedural justice from non-coethnic officers, even in a context where ethnicity is highly salient. However, suggestive evidence indicates that this small effect is significantly magnified for respondents who perceive their group to be underrepresented in the police. Descriptive representation is therefore a powerful moderator of the relationship between ethnicity and expectations of police bias. These results have implications for the development of effective and legitimate police institutions in weakly institutionalized contexts.
引用
收藏
页码:851 / 881
页数:31
相关论文
共 31 条
  • [1] Policing Ethnicity: Lab-in-the-Field Evidence on Discrimination, Cooperation, and Ethnic Balancing in the Liberian National Police
    Blair, Robert A.
    Karim, Sabrina M.
    Gilligan, Michael J.
    Beardsley, Kyle
    QUARTERLY JOURNAL OF POLITICAL SCIENCE, 2022, 17 (02) : 141 - 181
  • [2] The Complexity of Descriptive Representation and Bureaucracy: The Case of South Africa
    Naff, Katherine C.
    Capers, K. Juree
    INTERNATIONAL PUBLIC MANAGEMENT JOURNAL, 2014, 17 (04) : 515 - 539
  • [3] Better for everyone: black descriptive representation and police traffic stops
    Christiani, Leah
    Shoub, Kelsey
    Baumgartner, Frank R.
    Epp, Derek A.
    Roach, Kevin
    POLITICS GROUPS AND IDENTITIES, 2022, 10 (05) : 807 - 816
  • [4] Symbolic representation in policing: How officer characteristics shape police-suspect interactions
    Rhee, Yong-Chan
    Menifield, Charles E.
    Song, Miyeon
    PUBLIC MANAGEMENT REVIEW, 2024,
  • [5] Community policing does not build citizen trust in police or reduce crime in the Global South
    Blair, Graeme
    Weinstein, Jeremy M.
    Christia, Fotini
    Arias, Eric
    Badran, Emile
    Blair, Robert A.
    Cheema, Ali
    Farooqui, Ahsan
    Fetzer, Thiemo
    Grossman, Guy
    Haim, Dotan
    Hameed, Zulfiqar
    Hanson, Rebecca
    Hasanain, Ali
    Kronick, Dorothy
    Morse, Benjamin S.
    Muggah, Robert
    Nadeem, Fatiq
    Tsai, Lily L.
    Nanes, Matthew
    Slough, Tara
    Ravanilla, Nico
    Shapiro, Jacob N.
    Silva, Barbara
    Souza, Pedro C. L.
    Wilke, Anna M.
    SCIENCE, 2021, 374 (6571) : 1098 - +
  • [6] The Role of Race, Ethnicity, and Party on Attitudes Toward Descriptive Representation
    Casellas, Jason P.
    Wallace, Sophia J.
    AMERICAN POLITICS RESEARCH, 2015, 43 (01) : 144 - 169
  • [7] Trust and Confidence in Police Officers and the Institution of Policing: The Views of African Americans in the American South
    Pryce, Daniel K.
    Chenane, Joselyne L.
    CRIME & DELINQUENCY, 2021, 67 (6-7) : 808 - 838
  • [8] Descriptive representation and AIDS policy in South Africa
    Lieberman, Evan S.
    CONTEMPORARY POLITICS, 2012, 18 (02) : 156 - 173
  • [9] "Most Officers are More or Less Colorblind": Police Officers' Reflections on the Role of Race and Ethnicity in Policing
    Kammersgaard, Tobias
    Sogaard, Thomas Friis
    Kolind, Torsten
    Hunt, Geoffrey
    RACE AND JUSTICE, 2024, 14 (04): : 465 - 489
  • [10] Diversity Policing-Policing Diversity: Performing Ethnicity in Police and Private-Security Work in Sweden
    Lofstrand, Cecilia Hansen
    Uhnoo, Sara
    SOCIAL INCLUSION, 2014, 2 (03): : 75 - 87