Incorrect Interpretation in the Light of the Law of Interpretation

被引:0
|
作者
Konca, Paulina [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Silesia, Katowice, Poland
来源
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR THE SEMIOTICS OF LAW-REVUE INTERNATIONALE DE SEMIOTIQUE JURIDIQUE | 2023年 / 36卷 / 02期
关键词
Canons of interpretation; Construction; Extrinsic and intrinsic aids; Interpretation; Law of interpretation; Legal text; STATUTORY INTERPRETATION; CODIFIED CANONS; RULES;
D O I
10.1007/s11196-022-09892-8
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
There are certain standards of legal interpretation. Interpretive directives are heterogeneous-both in terms of the issues they address and of the form. Not all authors consider the canons of interpretation to be norms like any other ones. Moreover, some claim that the term "incorrect interpretation" refers only to an arbitrarily chosen concept. I intend to investigate whether, despite the objections raised, interpretative directives can be said to have the status of legal norms. I wonder whether the so-called law of interpretation (LoI), can provide a normative key to assess the correctness of the interpretation of legal texts. Text raises important questions concerning LoI. Firstly, the question of the status of interpretative directives and the problem of their defeasibility. Second, it refers to the problem of compliance with interpretative directives and the consequences of their violation, drawing attention to the two contexts of legal interpretation (the context of discovery and justification) and to the fact that canons of interpretation can constitute a standard for the correctness of the interpretative procedure and for its result. Third, this paper refers to the problem of vagueness of interpretative directives, analysing the advantages of maintaining it to a certain extent, as well as the possibilities of reducing it in the rest. The fourth issue analysed is the multiplicity of canons and the lack of a defined hierarchy of them. I conclude by pointing out that LoI should provide a model by which to assess the correctness of an interpretation.
引用
收藏
页码:629 / 648
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] THE COMMON LAW OF INTERPRETATION
    Baldacci, Christopher J.
    VIRGINIA LAW REVIEW, 2022, 108 (05) : 1243 - 1288
  • [2] READING LAW: THE INTERPRETATION OF LEGAL TEXTS
    Eskridge, William N., Jr.
    COLUMBIA LAW REVIEW, 2013, 113 (02) : 531 - 592
  • [3] ON THE BROAD INTERPRETATION OF LAW
    Rodriguez-Toubes Muniz, Joaquin
    DERECHOS Y LIBERTADES, 2019, (40) : 67 - 108
  • [4] Interpretation in Law I
    Gaher, Frantisek
    FILOZOFIA, 2015, 70 (08): : 647 - 658
  • [5] Interpretation in Law II
    Gaher, Frantisek
    FILOZOFIA, 2015, 70 (10): : 789 - 799
  • [6] The Future of the Interpretation of Canon Law
    Kroczek, Piotr
    REVUE CIRKEVNIHO PRAVA-CHURCH LAW REVIEW, 2018, 72 (03): : 11 - 24
  • [7] The role of interpretation in the law discourse
    Rekosh, K. K.
    MGIMO REVIEW OF INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS, 2011, (06): : 209 - 216
  • [8] THE CONCEPTS AND THE ESSENCE OF INTERPRETATION OF LAW
    Bilous, Oleh
    Liutikov, Pavlo
    BALTIC JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC STUDIES, 2021, 7 (01) : 139 - 144
  • [9] INTERPRETATION OF SECONDARY INSTRUMENTS IN INTERNATIONAL LAW
    Costelloe, Daniel
    Fitzmaurice, Malgosia
    POLISH YEARBOOK OF INTERNATIONAL LAW, 2015, 35 : 47 - 82
  • [10] Interpretation of Unilateral Acts in International Law
    Eva Kassoti
    Netherlands International Law Review, 2022, 69 : 295 - 326