Two problems on invariance for interventionist or policy purposes

被引:0
|
作者
Ivarola, Leonardo [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Buenos Aires, CONICET, Buenos Aires, Argentina
来源
PENSAMIENTO | 2023年 / 79卷 / 304期
关键词
Invariance; Intervention; Open-ended results; Mechanisms; Black swan; EXPLANATION; MECHANISMS; WORK;
D O I
10.14422/pen.v79.i304.y2023.023
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
The use of invariant knowledge for achieving interventionist or political purposes is commonly accepted by manipulability approaches. However, such use raises two philosophical issues that will be examined in this paper. The first problem is ontological, and refers to the difficulty of finding genuine stable causal factors in the social sciences. In this regard, it is showed that social phenomena do not respond to the logic of stable factors such as mechanisms or << capacities >>, but is more suited to the logic of << possibility trees >> or << open-ended results >>. The other problem is epistemological, and refers to that even if stable social contributions are founded, nothing guarantees that such stability prevails in future. Different thesis supporting this stance will be examined, such as the so-called << Lucas critique >> or the << black swan theory >>.
引用
收藏
页码:1005 / 1024
页数:20
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Toward Tailored Interventions: Sympathetic and Parasympathetic Functioning Predicts Responses to an Intervention for Conduct Problems Delivered in Two Formats
    Andrea L. Glenn
    John E. Lochman
    Thomas Dishion
    Nicole P. Powell
    Caroline Boxmeyer
    Francesca Kassing
    Lixin Qu
    Devon Romero
    Prevention Science, 2019, 20 : 30 - 40
  • [42] Toward Tailored Interventions: Sympathetic and Parasympathetic Functioning Predicts Responses to an Intervention for Conduct Problems Delivered in Two Formats
    Glenn, Andrea L.
    Lochman, John E.
    Dishion, Thomas
    Powell, Nicole P.
    Boxmeyer, Caroline
    Kassing, Francesca
    Qu, Lixin
    Romero, Devon
    PREVENTION SCIENCE, 2019, 20 (01) : 30 - 40
  • [43] Comparison of two approaches to prevention of mental health problems in college students: Enhancing coping and executive function skills
    Bettis, Alexandra H.
    Coiro, Mary Jo
    England, Jessica
    Murphy, Lexa K.
    Zelkowitz, Rachel L.
    Dejardins, Leandra
    Eskridge, Rachel
    Adery, Laura Hieber
    Yarboi, Janet
    Pardo, Daniel
    Compas, Bruce E.
    JOURNAL OF AMERICAN COLLEGE HEALTH, 2017, 65 (05) : 313 - 322
  • [44] Evaluating the effectiveness of a transdiagnostic universal prevention program for both internalizing and externalizing problems in children: two feasibility studies
    Kishida, Kohei
    Hida, Noriko
    Ishikawa, Shin-ichi
    CHILD AND ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY AND MENTAL HEALTH, 2022, 16 (01)
  • [45] Therapist-Assisted Online Treatment for Child Conduct Problems in Rural and Urban Families: Two Randomized Controlled Trials
    Dadds, Mark R.
    Thai, Christina
    Diaz, Antonio Mendoza
    Broderick, Joshua
    Moul, Caroline
    Tully, Lucy A.
    Hawes, David J.
    Davies, Suzanne
    Burchfield, Katherine
    Cane, Lindsay
    JOURNAL OF CONSULTING AND CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGY, 2019, 87 (08) : 706 - 719
  • [46] A two-step approach for the analysis of hybrids in comparative social policy analysis: a nuanced typology of childcare between policies and regimes
    Ciccia, Rossella
    QUALITY & QUANTITY, 2017, 51 (06) : 2761 - 2780
  • [47] Two-year outcome of an intervention program for university students who have parents with alcohol problems: A randomized controlled trial
    Hansson, Helena
    Rundberg, Jenny
    Zetterlind, Ulla
    Johnsson, Kent Ove
    Berglund, Mats
    ALCOHOLISM-CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL RESEARCH, 2007, 31 (11) : 1927 - 1933
  • [48] Street-level bureaucrats' discretion between individual and institutional factors: The analysis of the minimum income policy implementation in two Italian regions
    Andreotti, Alberta
    Coletto, Diego
    Rio, Anna
    SOCIAL POLICY & ADMINISTRATION, 2024, 58 (03) : 368 - 384
  • [49] Early-term birth and its association with universal two-child policy: a national cross-sectional study in China
    Zhang, Jie
    Williams, Gareth J.
    Wang, Guanghua
    Chen, Jingjing
    Zhang, Mengyu
    Du, Wenchong
    Zhu, Jing
    Zhang, Jun
    Hua, Jing
    BMJ OPEN, 2021, 11 (12):
  • [50] Two Sides of the Same Coin: Cannabis Dependence and Mental Health Problems in Help-Seeking Adolescent and Young Adult Outpatients
    Norberg, Melissa M.
    Battisti, Robert A.
    Copeland, Jan
    Hermens, Daniel F.
    Hickie, Ian B.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MENTAL HEALTH AND ADDICTION, 2012, 10 (06) : 818 - 828