Swab pooling enables rapid expansion of high-throughput capacity for SARS-CoV-2 community testing

被引:0
作者
Fagg, Jamie [1 ]
Beale, Rupert [1 ,2 ]
Futschik, Matthias E. [3 ,4 ]
Turek, Elena [5 ]
Chapman, David [5 ]
Halstead, Susan [6 ]
Jones, Marc [7 ]
Cole-Hamilton, Joanna [3 ]
Gunson, Rory [8 ]
Sudhanva, Malur [3 ,9 ]
Klapper, Paul E. [3 ,10 ]
Vansteenhouse, Harper [6 ]
Tunkel, Sarah [3 ]
Dominiczak, Anna [6 ]
Peto, Timothy E. A. [11 ]
Fowler, Tom [3 ,12 ]
机构
[1] Royal Free London NHS Fdn Trust, London, England
[2] UCL, Div Med, Royal Free Hosp, Pond St, London NW3 2QG, England
[3] UK Hlth Secur Agcy, London, England
[4] Univ Plymouth, Fac Hlth, Sch Biomed Sci, Plymouth, England
[5] Deloitte, London, England
[6] Univ Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland
[7] Glasgow Univ, Pathol Labs, Glasgow, Scotland
[8] West Scotland Specialist Virol Ctr, Glasgow, Scotland
[9] Kings Coll Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, London, England
[10] Univ Manchester, Manchester, England
[11] Univ Oxford, Oxford, England
[12] Queen Mary Univ London, William Harvey Res Inst, London, England
关键词
COVID-19; SARS-CoV-2; Pool testing; Swab pooling; High-throughput; Community testing; COST-EFFECTIVENESS;
D O I
10.1016/j.jcv.2023.105574
中图分类号
Q93 [微生物学];
学科分类号
071005 ; 100705 ;
摘要
Background: The challenges of rapid upscaling of testing capacity were a major lesson from the COVID-19 pandemic response. The need for process adjustments in high-throughput testing laboratories made sample pooling a challenging option to implement.Objective: This study aimed to evaluate whether pooling samples at source (swab pooling) was as effective as qRT-PCR testing of individuals in identifying cases of SARS-CoV-2 in real-world community testing conditions using the same high-throughput pipeline.Methods: Two cohorts of 10 (Pool10: 1,030 participants and 103 pools) and 6 (Pool6: 1,284 participants and 214 pools) samples per pool were tested for concordance, sensitivity, specificity, and Ct value differences with individual testing as reference.Results: Swab pooling allowed unmodified application of an existing high-throughput SARS-Cov-2 testing pipeline with only marginal loss of accuracy. For Pool10, concordance was 98.1% (95% Confidence interval: 93.3-99.8%), sensitivity was 95.7% (85.5-99.5%), and specificity was 100.0% (93.6-100.0%). For Pool6, concordance was 97.2% (94.0-99.0%), sensitivity was 97.5% (93.7-99.3%), and specificity was 96.4% (87.7-99.6%). Differences of outcomes measure between pool size were not significant. Most positive individual samples, which were not detected in pools, had very low viral concentration. If only individual samples with a viral concentration > 400 copies/ml (i.e. Ct value < 30) were considered positive, the overall sensitivity of pooling increased to 99.5%.Conclusion: The study demonstrated high sensitivity and specificity by swab pooling and the immediate capability of high-throughput laboratories to implement this method making it an option in planning of rapid upscaling of laboratory capacity for future pandemics.
引用
收藏
页数:7
相关论文
共 28 条
[1]   Cost Effectiveness of Sample Pooling to Test for SARS-CoV-2 [J].
Abdalhamid, Baha ;
Bilder, Christopher Richard ;
Garrett, Jodi Louise ;
Iwen, Peter Charles .
JOURNAL OF INFECTION IN DEVELOPING COUNTRIES, 2020, 14 (10) :1136-1137
[2]   Pooled nasopharyngeal swab collection in a single vial for the diagnosis of SARS CoV-2 infection: An effective cost saving method [J].
Agarwal, Reshu ;
Gupta, Ekta ;
Dubey, Shantanu ;
Padhi, Abhishek ;
Khodare, Arvind ;
Kumar, Guresh ;
Sarin, Shiv Kumar .
INDIAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL MICROBIOLOGY, 2021, 39 (02) :231-234
[3]   Lessons from applied large-scale pooling of 133,816 SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR tests [J].
Barak, Netta ;
Ben-Ami, Roni ;
Sido, Tal ;
Perri, Amir ;
Shtoyer, Aviad ;
Rivkin, Mila ;
Licht, Tamar ;
Peretz, Ayelet ;
Magenheim, Judith ;
Fogel, Irit ;
Livneh, Ayalah ;
Daitch, Yutti ;
Oiknine-Djian, Esther ;
Benedek, Gil ;
Dor, Yuval ;
Wolf, Dana G. ;
Yassour, Moran .
SCIENCE TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2021, 13 (589)
[4]   Comparing two sample pooling strategies for SARS-CoV-2 RNA detection for efficient screening of COVID-19 [J].
Chen, Fenghua ;
Geng, Zhi ;
Wang, Jian ;
Liuchang, Wenbo ;
Huang, Da ;
Xu, Yuandong ;
Wang, Zheng ;
Wang, Lin .
JOURNAL OF MEDICAL VIROLOGY, 2021, 93 (05) :2805-2809
[5]   Swab pooling: A new method for large-scale RT-qPCR screening of SARS-CoV-2 avoiding sample dilution [J].
Christoff, Ana Paula ;
Flores Cruz, Giuliano Netto ;
Rodrigues Sereia, Aline Fernanda ;
Boberg, Dellyana Rodrigues ;
de Bastiani, Daniela Carolina ;
Yamanaka, Lais Eiko ;
Fongaro, Gislaine ;
Stoco, Patricia Hermes ;
Bazzo, Maria Luiza ;
Grisard, Edmundo Carlos ;
Hernandes, Camila ;
Valter de Oliveira, Luiz Felipe .
PLOS ONE, 2021, 16 (02)
[6]   Effective bubble-based testing for SARS-CoV-2 using swab-pooling [J].
Cohen, Yuval ;
Bamberger, Nadav ;
Mor, Orna ;
Walfisch, Ronen ;
Fleishon, Shay ;
Varkovitzky, Itay ;
Younger, Asaf ;
Levi, Danit Oz ;
Kohn, Yishai ;
Steinberg, David M. ;
Zeevi, Danny ;
Erster, Oran ;
Mendelson, Ella ;
Livneh, Zvi .
CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2022, 28 (06) :859-864
[7]  
Crone Michael, 2021, Wellcome Open Res, V6, P268, DOI 10.12688/wellcomeopenres.17226.1
[8]   Effective high-throughput RT-qPCR screening for SARS-CoV-2 infections in children [J].
Dewald, Felix ;
Suarez, Isabelle ;
Johnen, Ronja ;
Grossbach, Jan ;
Moran-Tovar, Roberto ;
Steger, Gertrud ;
Joachim, Alexander ;
Rubio, Gibran Horemheb ;
Fries, Mira ;
Behr, Florian ;
Kley, Joao ;
Lingnau, Andreas ;
Kretschmer, Alina ;
Gude, Carina ;
Beazes-Flores, Guadelupe ;
del Valle, David Laveaga ;
Roblero-Hernandez, Alberto ;
Magana-Cerino, Jesus ;
Hernandez, Adriana Torres ;
Ruiz-Quinones, Jesus ;
Schega, Konstantin ;
Linne, Viktoria ;
Junker, Lena ;
Wunsch, Marie ;
Heger, Eva ;
Knops, Elena ;
Di Cristanziano, Veronica ;
Meyer, Meike ;
Huenseler, Christoph ;
Weber, Lutz T. ;
Lueers, Jan-Christoffer ;
Quade, Gustav ;
Wisplinghoff, Hilmar ;
Tiemann, Carsten ;
Zotz, Rainer ;
Jomaa, Hassan ;
Pranada, Arthur ;
Herzum, Ileana ;
Cullen, Paul ;
Schmitz, Franz-Josef ;
Philipsen, Paul ;
Kirchner, Georg ;
Knabbe, Cornelius ;
Hellmich, Martin ;
Buess, Michael ;
Wolff, Anna ;
Kossow, Annelene ;
Niessen, Johannes ;
Jeworutzki, Sebastian ;
Schraepler, Joerg-Peter .
NATURE COMMUNICATIONS, 2022, 13 (01)
[9]   The detection of defective members of large populations [J].
Dorfman, R .
ANNALS OF MATHEMATICAL STATISTICS, 1943, 14 :436-440
[10]   Comparative cost-effectiveness of SARS-CoV-2 testing strategies in the USA: a modelling study [J].
Du, Zhanwei ;
Pandey, Abhishek ;
Bai, Yuan ;
Fitzpatrick, Meagan C. ;
Chinazzi, Matteo ;
Pastore y Piontti, Ana ;
Lachmann, Michael ;
Vespignani, Alessandro ;
Cowling, Benjamin J. ;
Galvani, Alison P. ;
Meyers, Lauren Ancel .
LANCET PUBLIC HEALTH, 2021, 6 (03) :E184-E191