Electrical stimulation therapy for pain and related symptoms in multiple sclerosis: A systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:0
作者
Wu, Fan [1 ]
Li, Xin [2 ]
Liang, Juping [1 ]
Zhang, Tongtong [2 ]
Tao, Jing [1 ]
Yang, Xiaoyan [1 ]
Zhou, Xuan [1 ,4 ]
Du, Qing [1 ,3 ,4 ]
机构
[1] Shanghai Jiao Tong Univ, Dept Rehabil, Xinhua Hosp Affiliated, Sch Med, Shanghai, Peoples R China
[2] Shanghai Univ Sport, Sch Exercise & Hlth, Shanghai, Peoples R China
[3] Shanghai Univ Med & Hlth Sci, Chongming Hosp, Shanghai, Peoples R China
[4] 1665 Kongjiang Rd, Shanghai 200092, Peoples R China
关键词
Electrical stimulation therapy; Multiple sclerosis; Pain; Depression; Systematic review; Meta; -analysis; LOW-BACK-PAIN; NERVE-STIMULATION; MANAGEMENT; EFFICACY; TENS; MECHANISMS; PEOPLE;
D O I
10.1016/j.msard.2023.105114
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Background: The effectiveness of electrical stimulation therapy (EST) for pain, depression, fatigue, disability, and quality of life in multiple sclerosis (MS) remains uncertain. This study aims to analyze and discuss the efficacy of various EST treatments in alleviating pain among MS patients. Methods: The primary search was conducted using PubMed, Web of Science, Cochrane Library, Embase, and the Cumulative Index of Nursing and Allied Health Literature databases until September 25, 2023. Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) including patients with MS pain receiving EST compared with other therapies were included. Pain intensity, quality of life, and neuropsychiatric symptoms were reported. The mean difference (MD) with 95 % confidence intervals (CIs) was estimated separately for outcomes to understand the mean effect size. Results: Ten RCTs containing 315 participants were included. The pooled data from 8 trials including 267 participants showed that the EST was superior in alleviating pain (MD = -1.75, 95 % CI -2.85--0.64, P = 0.002, I2=73 %) evaluated by the visual analog scale. In subgroup analysis, medium-term EST treatment showed the highest effect size compared to short-term and long-term treatment (MDmedium-term = -2.17, 95 % CI -3.51--0.84, P = 0.001, I2 = 0 %). However, no significant differences were found in terms of pain-related quality of life, depression, fatigue, and pain-related disability. No adverse events related to EST were reported. A high risk of bias was identified in three of the ten included studies. Conclusions: EST is effective and safe for alleviating pain in MS, but it should be noted that limited sample sizes and methodological issues were present in the included studies. More robust assessment criteria and high-quality RCTs are required for patients with MS. Trial registration: CRD42023406787. (https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/display_record.php?Reco rdID=406787).
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 37 条
[1]   A pilot investigation of the hypoalgesic effects of transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation upon low back pain in people with multiple sclerosis [J].
Al-Smadi, J ;
Warke, K ;
Wilson, I ;
Cramp, AFL ;
Noble, G ;
Walsh, DM ;
Lowe-Strong, AS .
CLINICAL REHABILITATION, 2003, 17 (07) :742-749
[2]   Low intensity transcranial electric stimulation: Safety, ethical, legal regulatory and application guidelines [J].
Antal, A. ;
Alekseichuk, I. ;
Bikson, M. ;
Brockmoeller, J. ;
Brunoni, A. R. ;
Chen, R. ;
Cohen, L. G. ;
Dowthwaite, G. ;
Ellrich, J. ;
Floeel, A. ;
Fregni, F. ;
George, M. S. ;
Hamilton, R. ;
Haueisen, J. ;
Herrmann, C. S. ;
Hummel, F. C. ;
Lefaucheur, J. P. ;
Liebetanz, D. ;
Loo, C. K. ;
McCaig, C. D. ;
Miniussi, C. ;
Miranda, P. C. ;
Moliadze, V. ;
Nitsche, M. A. ;
Nowak, R. ;
Padberg, F. ;
Pascual-Leone, A. ;
Poppendieck, W. ;
Priori, A. ;
Rossi, S. ;
Rossini, P. M. ;
Rothwell, J. ;
Rueger, M. A. ;
Ruffini, G. ;
Schellhorn, K. ;
Siebner, H. R. ;
Ugawa, Y. ;
Wexler, A. ;
Ziemann, U. ;
Hallett, M. ;
Paulus, W. .
CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 2017, 128 (09) :1774-1809
[3]   Prefrontal tDCS Decreases Pain in Patients with Multiple Sclerosis [J].
Ayache, Samar S. ;
Palm, Ulrich ;
Chalah, Moussa A. ;
Al-Ani, Tarik ;
Brignol, Arnaud ;
Abdellaoui, Mohamed ;
Dimitri, Dalia ;
Sorel, Marc ;
Creange, Alain ;
Lefaucheur, Jean-Pascal .
FRONTIERS IN NEUROSCIENCE, 2016, 10
[4]   Multiple Sclerosis: Mechanisms and Immunotherapy [J].
Baecher-Allan, Clare ;
Kaskow, Belinda J. ;
Weiner, Howard L. .
NEURON, 2018, 97 (04) :742-768
[5]   The Effects of Transcutaneous Spinal Direct Current Stimulation on Neuropathic Pain in Multiple Sclerosis: Clinical and Neurophysiological Assessment [J].
Berra, Eliana ;
Bergamaschi, Roberto ;
De Icco, Roberto ;
Dagna, Carlotta ;
Perrotta, Armando ;
Rovaris, Marco ;
Grasso, Maria Grazia ;
Anastasio, Maria G. ;
Pinardi, Giovanna ;
Martello, Federico ;
Tamburin, Stefano ;
Sandrini, Giorgio ;
Tassorelli, Cristina .
FRONTIERS IN HUMAN NEUROSCIENCE, 2019, 13
[6]   Fatigue in Multiple Sclerosis: Neural Correlates and the Role of Non-Invasive Brain Stimulation [J].
Chalah, Moussa A. ;
Riachi, Naji ;
Ahdab, Rechdi ;
Creange, Alain ;
Lefaucheur, Jean-Pascal ;
Ayache, Samar S. .
FRONTIERS IN CELLULAR NEUROSCIENCE, 2015, 9
[7]   Sensory Complaints of the Upper Extremities in Multiple Sclerosis: Relative Efficacy of Nortriptyline and Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation [J].
Chitsaz, Ahmad ;
Janghorbani, Mohsen ;
Shaygannejad, Vahid ;
Ashtari, Fereshteh ;
Heshmatipour, Mojtaba ;
Freeman, Jennifer .
CLINICAL JOURNAL OF PAIN, 2009, 25 (04) :281-285
[8]   Multiple sclerosis [J].
Compston, Alastair ;
Coles, Alasdair .
LANCET, 2008, 372 (9648) :1502-1517
[9]   Pharmacotherapeutic Options for Managing Pain in Multiple Sclerosis [J].
Di Stefano, Giulia ;
De Stefano, Gianfranco ;
Di Lionardo, Andrea ;
Cruccu, Giorgio ;
Truini, Andrea .
CNS DRUGS, 2020, 34 (07) :749-761
[10]  
Garcia-Moreno J M, 1999, Neurologia, V14, P154