Time to put aside the false dichotomy between personality disorders and psychotic symptoms

被引:0
作者
Leclerc, Philippe [1 ,5 ]
Gamache, Dominick [2 ,3 ]
Cailhol, Lionel [4 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sherbrooke, Fac Educ, Sherbrooke, PQ, Canada
[2] Univ Quebec Trois Rivieres, Dept Psychol, Trois Rivieres, PQ, Canada
[3] CERVO Brain Res Ctr, Quebec City, PQ, Canada
[4] Ctr Integre Univ St & Serv Sociaux Est Delile Demo, Dept Psychiat, Montreal, PQ, Canada
[5] Univ Sherbrooke, Fac Educ, Sherbrooke, PQ J1K 2R1, Canada
关键词
critical review; dimensional diagnosis; personality disorders; psychosis; psychotic symptoms; AUDITORY VERBAL HALLUCINATIONS; PSYCHOPATHOLOGY HITOP; HIERARCHICAL TAXONOMY; PREVALENCE; TRAUMA; STATE; CARE;
D O I
10.1002/jclp.23655
中图分类号
B849 [应用心理学];
学科分类号
040203 ;
摘要
Unlike internalizing and externalizing symptoms, psychotic symptoms (e.g., hallucinations, delusions) are manifestations of personality disorders (PDs) that are more controversial and poorly understood. This leaves clinicians with very little guidance for clinical practice, especially for diagnosis. What is more, most reviews have focused strictly on the links between psychotic symptoms and the categorically defined borderline PD, which contrasts with the growing movement that emphasizes a dimensional perspective (especially in psychology). Thus, the objectives of this critical review will be to (a) expose typical cases where PDs and psychotic symptoms might cooccur; (b) assess the state of scientific knowledge surrounding PD and psychotic symptoms; and (c) provide clinicians and researchers with recommendations to keep the field moving forward. We conclude that researchers and clinicians should move past the false "PD or psychosis" dichotomy since they often cooccur, avoid (as far as possible) making psychotic symptoms an exclusion criterion in PD research to enhance ecological validity, and consider dimensional PD diagnosis as a potential unifying solution to the dilemma posed by this cooccurrence.
引用
收藏
页码:1003 / 1014
页数:12
相关论文
共 58 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 2018, ICD-11 for mortality and morbidity statistics
[2]   Borderline personality disorder and auditory verbal hallucinations [J].
Beatson, Josephine .
AUSTRALASIAN PSYCHIATRY, 2019, 27 (06) :548-551
[3]   Avoiding Misdiagnosis When Auditory Verbal Hallucinations Are Present in Borderline Personality Disorder [J].
Beatson, Josephine A. ;
Broadbear, Jillian H. ;
Duncan, Charlotte ;
Bourton, David ;
Rao, Sathya .
JOURNAL OF NERVOUS AND MENTAL DISEASE, 2019, 207 (12) :1048-1055
[4]   Psychological processes mediating the association between developmental trauma and specific psychotic symptoms in adults: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Bloomfield, Michael A. P. ;
Chang, Tinya ;
Woodl, Maximillian J. ;
Lyons, Laura M. ;
Cheng, Zhen ;
Bauer-Staeb, Clarissa ;
Hobbs, Catherine ;
Bracke, Sophie ;
Kennerley, Helen ;
Isham, Louise ;
Brewin, Chris ;
Billings, Jo ;
Greene, Talya ;
Lewis, Glyn .
WORLD PSYCHIATRY, 2021, 20 (01) :107-123
[5]   Comorbid Personality Disorders in Individuals With an At-Risk Mental State for Psychosis: A Meta-Analytic Review [J].
Boldrini, Tommaso ;
Tanzilli, Annalisa ;
Pontillo, Maria ;
Chirumbolo, Antonio ;
Vicari, Stefano ;
Lingiardi, Vittorio .
FRONTIERS IN PSYCHIATRY, 2019, 10
[6]   Utilization of Health Care Services by Patients With Cluster B Personality Disorders or Schizophrenia [J].
Cailhol, Lionel ;
Pelletier, Eric ;
Rochette, Louis ;
Renaud, Suzane ;
Koch, Marion ;
David, Pierre ;
Villeneuve, Evens ;
Lunghi, Carlotta ;
Lesage, Alain .
PSYCHIATRIC SERVICES, 2021, 72 (12) :1392-1399
[7]   The p Factor: One General Psychopathology Factor in the Structure of Psychiatric Disorders? [J].
Caspi, Avshalom ;
Houts, Renate M. ;
Belsky, Daniel W. ;
Goldman-Mellor, Sidra J. ;
Harrington, HonaLee ;
Israel, Salomon ;
Meier, Madeline H. ;
Ramrakha, Sandhya ;
Shalev, Idan ;
Poulton, Richie ;
Moffitt, Terrie E. .
CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 2014, 2 (02) :119-137
[8]   Psychotic symptoms in borderline personality disorder: developmental aspects [J].
Cavelti, Marialuisa ;
Thompson, Katherine ;
Chanen, Andrew M. ;
Kaess, Michael .
CURRENT OPINION IN PSYCHOLOGY, 2021, 37 :26-31
[9]  
Chiappini S, 2022, J PERS DISORD, V36, P505, DOI 10.1521/pedi.2022.36.5.505
[10]   Are neurological and psychiatric disorders different? [J].
David, Anthony S. ;
Nicholson, Timothy .
BRITISH JOURNAL OF PSYCHIATRY, 2015, 207 (05) :373-374