Clinical Results of Surgical Treatment for Comminuted Radial Head and Neck Fracture: Headless Compression Screws Versus Plate Fixation

Background We surgically treated comminuted radial head and neck fractures using headless compression screws, including multiple screws for the radial head and a single oblique screw for the radial neck. This study aimed to compare the clinical and radiological results for comminuted radial head and neck fractures between surgery using headless compression screws with a single oblique screw for the radial neck, our new procedure, and a plate system precontoured to the proximal radius. Methods This retrospective study included 23 patients (11 and 12 in the screw and plate groups, respectively). The fractures were type 3 according to the Mason-Johnston classification modified by Broberg and Morrey. Clinical outcomes analyzed included the motion range of the elbow and forearm, Mayo Elbow Performance Score, and radiological assessments. In addition, postoperative complications were also investigated. The average follow-up was 18 months. Results The bone union was achieved in all the patients, and there were no significant differences in clinical outcomes and radiological assessments except forearm supination (p = 0.02). Furthermore, additional surgical procedures were performed in one and five patients in the screw and plate groups, respectively (p = 0.16). Posterior nerve palsy was observed in two patients in the plate group. Complications were observed in one and six patients in the screw and plate groups, respectively (p = 0.07). Conclusion Both surgical procedures achieved good clinical and radiological outcomes with bone and ligament injury repair. The screw group had a greater range of forearm supination than the plate group.