"Heroic" medicine in neurology: A historical perspective

被引:0
作者
Sakalauskaite-Juodeikiene, Egle [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Vilnius Univ, Inst Clin Med, Fac Med, Clin Neurol & Neurosurg, MK Ciurlionio G 21, LT-03101 Vilnius, Lithuania
[2] Vilnius Univ, Inst Hlth Sci, Fac Med, Ctr Hlth Eth Law & Hist, Vilnius, Lithuania
关键词
heroic medicine; humoralism; neurology; neurosurgery; nineteenth century history; solidism;
D O I
10.1111/ene.16135
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Background and purpose: Repetitive bloodletting, promoting profuse diarrhoea and vomiting, the formation of artificial ulcers, and other aggressive treatment methods based on humoral theory and Brunonian medicine were used for patients with nervous system (NS) diseases until the end of the 19th century. These methods are also termed "heroic" medicine by modern medical historians.Methods: I analysed doctoral dissertations on the subject of NS diseases, clinical reports from 1806 to 1842 from the Vilnius University clinics, and other primary sources. This study was conducted in the vein of a historical-medical analysis and synthesis of primary sources, using comparative analysis, analogy, descriptive methods, and the method of retrospective diagnosis.Results: Copious bloodletting, purgatives, leeches, cupping therapy, and other potentially harmful methods were frequently employed as habitual treatments for patients with NS diseases. Calomel was used as a purgative and an anti-inflammatory drug, and acidum borussicum was prescribed for patients with hydrophobia. After analysing three clinical cases, I revealed how principles of desperate, "heroic" medicine were applied to treat severe NS diseases with the "strongest" drugs, described in the scientific literature of the time.Conclusions: My work was not intended to judge or criticize historical treatment methods but to demonstrate on what contemporary scientific theories they were based. We should not rule out the idea that some aggressive treatment methods used nowadays, although they eradicate or reduce the burden of a NS disease, or even prolong patients' lives, may offer exceptional examples of 21st century "heroic" medicine for future generations.
引用
收藏
页数:8
相关论文
共 49 条
  • [41] Childhood medulloblastoma-a single institution's historical perspective on survival and functional morbidity
    Phipps, Kim
    Kirkman, Matthew A.
    Aquilina, Kristian
    Gaze, Mark
    Michalski, Antony
    Wade, Angie
    Hayward, Richard
    CHILDS NERVOUS SYSTEM, 2019, 35 (12) : 2327 - 2338
  • [42] Factors associated with poor anticoagulation control with vitamin K antagonists among outpatients attended in Internal Medicine and Neurology. The ALADIN study
    Contreras Muruaga, M. M.
    Reig, G.
    Vivancos, J.
    Gonzalez, A.
    Cardona, P.
    Ramirez-Moreno, J. M.
    Marti-Fabregas, J.
    Suarez Fernandez, C.
    REVISTA CLINICA ESPANOLA, 2018, 218 (07): : 327 - 335
  • [43] Periodic surveillance of nosocomial infections in two neurology intensive care units. A valuable tool for quality management in intensive care medicine
    Zolldann, D
    Poetter, C
    Hilker, R
    Neveling, M
    Waitschies, B
    Klein, W
    Nolden-Koch, M
    Block, F
    Wenchel, HM
    Lemmen, SW
    ANAESTHESIST, 2003, 52 (08): : 690 - 696
  • [44] Clinical profile and satisfaction with anticoagulated treatment in patients with non-valvular atrial fibrillation attended in Internal Medicine and Neurology departments of Spain
    Reig-Rosello, Gemma
    Mar Contreras, M.
    Suarez-Fernandez, Carmen
    Gonzalez-Hernandez, Ayoze
    Cardona, Pere
    Pons-Amate, Jose M.
    Marti-Fabregas, Joan
    Vivancos, Jose
    REVISTA DE NEUROLOGIA, 2017, 65 (08) : 361 - 367
  • [45] From Brownian motion to virtual biopsy: a historical perspective from 40 years of diffusion MRI
    Le Bihan, Denis
    JAPANESE JOURNAL OF RADIOLOGY, 2024, 42 (12) : 1357 - 1371
  • [46] Perceptions and attitudes regarding complementary, alternative, and integrative medicine among published neurology authors: a large-scale, international cross-sectional survey
    Ng, Jeremy Y.
    Li, Stephanie Y.
    Cramer, Holger
    BMC NEUROLOGY, 2024, 24 (01)
  • [47] Madeline Earle Stanton (1898-1980): Librarian and Consultant of the Medical Historical Library at Yale University, Research Assistant in Bibliography in the Yale Department of the History of Medicine, Associate Editor of the Journal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, and Secretary and Protege of Harvey Cushing
    Jenkins, Abigail
    Venkatesh, Pooja
    Tissot, Marianne I. J.
    Detchou, Donald
    Barrie, Umaru
    Aoun, Salah G.
    WORLD NEUROSURGERY, 2023, 179 : 60 - 65
  • [48] THE EVOLUTION OF MICROSCOPE (AEOS) EXOSCOPE IN THE WORLD OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND ITS APPLICATION IN LUMBAR DISC HERNIATIONS SURGERY: A COMPREHENSIVE STUDY FROM HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE TO CURRENT PRACTICES IN ROMANIA AT THE HOSPITAL,,PROF.DR.N.OBLU", IASI, ROMANIA
    Eva, Lucian
    Munteanu, Maria-Raluca
    Duceac , Madalina
    Olaru, Iulia
    Marcu, Constantin
    Dabija, Marius-Gabriel
    ROMANIAN JOURNAL OF ORAL REHABILITATION, 2024, 16 (04): : 402 - 412