Hardwoods influence effect of climate and intraspecific competition on growth of woodland longleaf pine trees

Longleaf pine woodlands of the North American Coastal Plain are proposed to be resilient to climate change impacts, but little is known about changes in limiting factors to longleaf pine growth as climate has changed in late 20th century and early 21st century. Moreover, the role that neighborhood trees play in the context of climate change remains largely unexplored. We used static and moving window tree ring and climatic analyses to measure the effects of climate on longleaf pine growth at a site in southwest Georgia, USA. We then performed maximum likelihood analysis to examine the influence of neighboring hardwoods on the response of longleaf pine growth to the joint effects of competition and climate. Analysis of climate data from local stations in southwest Georgia over six decades indicated that mean air temperature decreased until the late 20th century then began to rise, and that the variability of spring and summer precipitation has increased. Tree ring and climate analyses indicated longleaf pine radial growth is sensitive to precipitation and air temperature, and that the strength of correlation of longleaf pine growth to summer air temperature and summer precipitation increased since the 1950s. Likelihood models, which were applied over a shorter (23-year) period and explicitly incorporated competition, did not support a link between summer temperature and growth but did indicate summer precipitation increased growth. Furthermore, basal area (BA) of neighboring hardwoods was correlated with greater pine growth per millimeter of precipitation. BA of neighboring longleaf pine negatively affected growth of conspecific trees; the presence of hardwoods increased the competitive effect when BA of neighboring pine trees was low (<10 m(2) ha(-1)) but decreased the competitive effect when BA of neighboring pine trees was high (=10 m(2) ha(-1)). These results suggest that retention or recruitment of hardwood trees when restoring longleaf pine woodlands may contribute to increased ability to withstand dry summers and may help to allay concerns of managers that retention of hardwoods will unduly affect growth of residual mature longleaf pines.