Embryo Loss and Moral Status

被引:7
作者
Delaney, James [1 ]
机构
[1] Niagara Univ, New York, NY 14109 USA
来源
JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY | 2023年 / 48卷 / 03期
关键词
embryo; miscarriage; moral status; well-being; ABORTION;
D O I
10.1093/jmp/jhad010
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
There is a significant debate over the moral status of human embryos. This debate has important implications for practices like abortion and IVF. Some argue that embryos have the same moral status as infants, children, and adults. However, critics claim that the frequency of pregnancy loss/miscarriage/spontaneous abortion shows a moral inconsistency in this view. One line of criticism is that those who know the facts about pregnancy loss and nevertheless attempt to conceive children are willing to sacrifice embryos lost for the healthy children they ultimately have. I respond to this criticism and argue that on the most plausible accounts of well-being, these embryos are not made worse off and thus not "sacrifices." I then make some more general remarks about what people's typical views about pregnancy loss show about their views toward the moral status of embryos.
引用
收藏
页码:252 / 264
页数:13
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [21] Moral status of pre-implantation embryos
    Kentenich H.
    Shenfield F.
    Pennings G.
    Sureau C.
    Cohen J.
    Devroey P.
    Tarlatzis B.
    Gynäkologische Endokrinologie, 2007, 5 (4) : 243 - 246
  • [22] The moral status of preembryos, embryos, fetuses, and infants
    Strong, C
    JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 1997, 22 (05): : 457 - 478
  • [23] MORAL STATUS AND CONSCIOUSNESS
    Niikawa, Takuya
    ANALELE UNIVERSITATII BUCURESTI-FILOSOFIE-ANNALS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF BUCHAREST-PHILOSOPHY, 2018, 67 (01): : 235 - 257
  • [24] Sacred mountains and beloved fetuses: can loving or worshipping something give it moral status?
    Elizabeth Harman
    Philosophical Studies, 2007, 133 : 55 - 81
  • [25] Sacred mountains and beloved fetuses: can loving or worshipping something give it moral status?
    Harman, Elizabeth
    PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2007, 133 (01) : 55 - 81
  • [26] On the moral status of hominins
    Wareham, C. S.
    MONASH BIOETHICS REVIEW, 2020, 38 (02) : 205 - 218
  • [27] SPECIESISM AND MORAL STATUS
    Singer, Peter
    METAPHILOSOPHY, 2009, 40 (3-4) : 567 - 581
  • [28] On the moral status of hominins
    C. S. Wareham
    Monash Bioethics Review, 2020, 38 : 205 - 218
  • [29] Agency and Moral Status
    Sebo, Jeff
    JOURNAL OF MORAL PHILOSOPHY, 2017, 14 (01) : 1 - 22
  • [30] Moving beyond the moral status of organoid-entities
    Barnhart, Andrew J.
    Dierickx, Kris
    BIOETHICS, 2023, 37 (02) : 103 - 110