Accuracy and reproducibility analysis of different reference axes for femoral prosthesis rotation alignment in TKA based on 3D CT femoral model

BackgroundThere are many reference axes to determine the rotational positioning of the femoral prosthesis in total knee arthroplasty (TKA), mainly including the surgical transepicondylar axis (sTEA), anatomical transepicondylar axis (aTEA), Whiteside line, and the posterior condylar line (PCL), etc., but there is still no definite conclusion on which is the most accurate reference axis.ObjectiveTo explore the reproducibility of each reference axis of femoral external osteotomy based on the 3D CT femoral model, compare the deviation of the simulated femoral prosthesis rotation alignment, positioned based on each reference axis, with the gold standard sTEA, and analyze the accuracy of each reference axis.MethodsThe imaging data of 120 patients with knee osteoarthritis who underwent a 3D CT examination of the knee in our hospital from June 2018 to December 2021 were retrospectively collected. The 3D model of the femur was established by Mimics software. The line relative to PCL externally rotated 3 & DEG; (PCL + 3 & DEG;), aTEA, and the vertical line of the Whiteside line were constructed and compared with the gold standard sTEA. Intra-observer, as well as inter-observer reproducibility analysis, was performed by the intra-group correlation coefficient (ICC) and Bland-Altman method.ResultsThe angle & ANGLE;WS, between the vertical line of Whiteside and sTEA, was 2.54 & PLUSMN; 2.30 & DEG;, with an outlier of 54.2%; the angle & ANGLE;aTEA, between aTEA and sTEA, was 4.21 & PLUSMN; 1.01 & DEG;, with an outlier of 99.1%; the angle & ANGLE;PCL, between PCL + 3 & DEG; external rotation and sTEA, was 0.50 & PLUSMN; 1.06 & DEG;, with the highest accuracy and an outlier of 5.8%, and the differences among all three were statistically significant, P < 0.05. The intra-observer ICC values of & ANGLE;WS, & ANGLE;aTEA, and & ANGLE;PCL were 0.975 (0.964-0.982), 0.926 (0.896-0.948), and 0.924(0.892,0.946), respectively, and the reproducibility levels were excellent; the inter-observer ICC values of & ANGLE;WS, & ANGLE;aTEA, and & ANGLE;PCL were 0.968(0.955-0.978), 0.906 (0.868-0.934) and 0.970 (0.957,0.979), respectively, with excellent reproducibility levels; Bland-Altman plots suggested that the scatter points of intra-observer and inter-observer measurement differences more than 95% were within the limits of agreement.ConclusionThe reference axis for locating the distal femoral external rotation osteotomy based on the 3D CT femoral model has good reproducibility. The PCL is easy to operate, has the highest precision, and the lowest outliers among the reference axes is therefore recommended.