Freudian Psychoanalysis in Rene Girard's Mimetic Theory

被引:0
作者
Vinolo, Stephane [1 ]
机构
[1] Pontificia Univ Catolica Ecuador, Quito, Ecuador
来源
TOPICOS-REVISTA DE FILOSOFIA | 2023年 / 67期
关键词
desire; Sigmund Freud; Rene Girard; identification; narcissism;
D O I
10.21555/top.v670.2280
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
In constructing the theory of mimetic desire, Girard comments on Freud's work on multiple occasions. In fact, almost all of the themes addressed by Girard have resonance in psychoanalysis: desire, mimesis, violence, collective homicide, the emergence of culture-each of these concepts exists in Freud's work. However, the Girardian reading always displaces these concepts to think them under the light of a unique mechanism that does not introduce any rupture nor discontinuity. In this text, I show how, according to Girard, Freudian concepts suffer from an original difficulty that lies in the fact that Freud was never able to break away from an objectual conception of desire.
引用
收藏
页码:345 / 368
页数:24
相关论文
共 50 条
[31]   OUTSIDE THE CITY, BETWEEN THE CITIES: RENE GIRARD AND RADICAL EVIL [J].
Kirwan, Michael .
COMMUNIO VIATORUM, 2009, 51 (01) :22-36
[32]   BEING SAVED FROM SALVATION: RENE GIRARD & THE VICTIMS OF RELIGION [J].
Kirwan, Michael S. J. .
COMMUNIO VIATORUM, 2010, 52 (01) :27-47
[33]   Christianity and violence. Theological contributions from Rene Girard [J].
Sbardella, Ellton Luis ;
Peretti, Clelia .
ESTUDOS TEOLOGICOS, 2019, 59 (01) :47-60
[34]   Communism in the Context of Girard's Theory of Sacrifice and Scapegoating [J].
Lampret, Urska .
BOGOSLOVNI VESTNIK-THEOLOGICAL QUARTERLY-EPHEMERIDES THEOLOGICAE, 2016, 76 (02) :303-312
[35]   "Variation" in Approaches to Human Psyche: Exploring Al-Ghazali's Influence on Freudian Psychoanalysis [J].
Mobarak, Tanzia .
COMPARATIVE LITERATURE-EAST & WEST, 2022, 6 (01) :64-79
[36]   Positivity and Negativity: A comparison Between Byung Chul Han and Rene Girard [J].
Galvis, Gustavo Sanabria .
REVISTA DE FILOSOFIA UIS, 2025, 24 (01)
[37]   Unconscious in Revolution. Surface, Contingency and Ontology in Freudian Psychoanalysis [J].
Caranci Saez, Carlos .
ARAUCARIA-REVISTA IBEROAMERICANA DE FILOSOFIA POLITICA Y HUMANIDADES, 2021, 23 (48) :33-55
[38]   The Epistemic Predicament of a Pseudoscience: Social Constructivism Confronts Freudian Psychoanalysis [J].
Boudry, Maarten ;
Buekens, Filip .
THEORIA-A SWEDISH JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, 2011, 77 (02) :159-179
[39]   From Dionysus to the Anti-Christ: Rene Girard's Defense of Christianity and Erik Peterson's Closure of Any Political Theology [J].
Schmidt, Christoph .
POLITICAL THEOLOGY, 2015, 16 (02) :101-115
[40]   Imaging Sin and the Passage to Holiness: Rene Girard, Ecclesial Vision, and the Spiritual Reshaping of Desires [J].
McLaughlin, Brett S. J. .
IRISH THEOLOGICAL QUARTERLY, 2022, 87 (02) :131-147