TMS combined with EEG: Recommendations and open issues for data collection and analysis

被引:76
作者
Hernandez-Pavon, Julio C. [1 ,2 ,3 ]
Veniero, Domenica [4 ]
Bergmann, Til Ole [5 ,6 ,8 ]
Belardinelli, Paolo [7 ]
Bortoletto, Marta [9 ]
Casarotto, Silvia [10 ,11 ]
Casula, Elias P. [12 ]
Farzan, Faranak [13 ]
Fecchio, Matteo [14 ]
Julkunen, Petro [15 ,33 ]
Kallioniemi, Elisa [16 ]
Lioumis, Pantelis [17 ,18 ,19 ]
Metsomaa, Johanna [17 ,18 ,19 ]
Miniussi, Carlo
Mutanen, Tuomas P. [17 ,18 ,19 ]
Rocchi, Lorenzo [20 ,21 ]
Rogasch, Nigel C. [22 ,23 ,24 ]
Shafi, Mouhsin M. [25 ]
Siebner, Hartwig R. [26 ,27 ,28 ]
Thut, Gregor [29 ]
Zrenner, Christoph [30 ,31 ,32 ]
Ziemann, Ulf
Ilmoniemi, Risto J. [17 ,18 ,19 ]
机构
[1] Northwestern Univ, Feinberg Sch Med, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Chicago, IL USA
[2] Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, Legs Walking Lab, Chicago, IL USA
[3] Shirley Ryan AbilityLab, Ctr Brain Stimulat, Chicago, IL USA
[4] Univ Nottingham, Sch Psychol, Nottingham, England
[5] Johannes Gutenberg Univ Mainz, Focus Program Translat Neurosci FTN, Neuroimaging Ctr NIC, Med Ctr, Mainz, Germany
[6] Leibniz Inst Resilience Res LIR, Mainz, Germany
[7] Univ Trento, Ctr Mind Brain Sci CIMeC, Rovereto, TN, Italy
[8] Univ Tubingen, Dept Neurol & Stroke, Tubingen, Germany
[9] IRCCS Ist Ctr San Giovanni Dio Fatebenefratell, Neurophysiol Lab, Brescia, Italy
[10] Univ Milan, Dept Biomed & Clin Sci, Milan, Italy
[11] IRCCS Fdn Don Carlo Gnocchi ONLUS, Milan, Italy
[12] Univ Tor Vergata, Dept Syst Med, Rome, Italy
[13] Simon Fraser Univ, Sch Mech Syst Engn, Surrey, BC, England
[14] Massachusetts Gen Hosp, Dept Neurol Massachusetts, Ctr Neurotechnol & Neurorecovery, Boston, MA USA
[15] Univ Eastern Finland, Dept Tech Phys, Kuopio, Finland
[16] New Jersey Inst Technol, Dept Biomed Engn, Newark, NJ USA
[17] Aalto Univ, Dept Neurosci & Biomed Engn, Espoo, Finland
[18] Univ Helsinki, Helsinki Univ Hosp, HUS Med Imaging Ctr, BioMag Lab, Helsinki, Finland
[19] Aalto Univ, Sch Sci, Helsinki, Finland
[20] UCL, UCL Queen Sq Inst Neurol, Dept Clin & Movement Neurosci, London, England
[21] Univ Cagliari, Dept Med Sci & Publ Hlth, Cagliari, Italy
[22] Univ Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia
[23] South Australian Hlth & Med Res Inst, Adelaide, Australia
[24] Monash Univ, Melbourne, Australia
[25] Harvard Med Sch, Beth Israel Deaconess Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, Berenson Allen Ctr Noninvas Brain Stimulat, Boston, MA USA
[26] Copenhagen Univ Hosp Amager & Hvidovre, Danish Res Ctr Magnet Resonance, Ctr Funct & Diagnost Imaging & Res, Copenhagen, Denmark
[27] Copenhagen Univ Hosp Bispebjerg & Frederiksberg, Dept Neurol, Copenhagen, Denmark
[28] Univ Copenhagen, Fac Hlth & Med Sci, Dept Clin Med, Copenhagen, Denmark
[29] Univ Glasgow, Sch Psychol & Neurosci, Glasgow, Scotland
[30] Ctr Addict & Mental Hlth, Temerty Ctr Therapeut Brain Intervent, Toronto, ON, Canada
[31] Univ Tubingen, Hertie Inst Clin Brain Res, Tubingen, Germany
[32] Univ Toronto, Dept Psychiat, Toronto, ON, Canada
[33] Kuopio Univ Hosp, Dept Clin Neurophysiol, Kuopio, Finland
基金
芬兰科学院;
关键词
Transcranial magnetic stimulation; Electroencephalography; Recommendations; TMS-EEG preparation; TMS-EEG data analysis pipelines; TMS-EEG; TEPs; Artifacts; TRANSCRANIAL MAGNETIC STIMULATION; INDEPENDENT COMPONENT ANALYSIS; THETA-BURST STIMULATION; FRONTAL EYE FIELDS; EVOKED EEG; BRAIN-STIMULATION; MOTOR CORTEX; CORTICAL REACTIVITY; WAVE-FORM; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHIC RESPONSES;
D O I
10.1016/j.brs.2023.02.009
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) evokes neuronal activity in the targeted cortex and connected brain regions. The evoked brain response can be measured with electroencephalography (EEG). TMS combined with simultaneous EEG (TMS-EEG) is widely used for studying cortical reactivity and con-nectivity at high spatiotemporal resolution. Methodologically, the combination of TMS with EEG is challenging, and there are many open questions in the field. Different TMS-EEG equipment and ap-proaches for data collection and analysis are used. The lack of standardization may affect reproducibility and limit the comparability of results produced in different research laboratories. In addition, there is controversy about the extent to which auditory and somatosensory inputs contribute to transcranially evoked EEG. This review provides a guide for researchers who wish to use TMS-EEG to study the reactivity of the human cortex. A worldwide panel of experts working on TMS-EEG covered all aspects that should be considered in TMS-EEG experiments, providing methodological recommendations (when possible) for effective TMS-EEG recordings and analysis. The panel identified and discussed the chal-lenges of the technique, particularly regarding recording procedures, artifact correction, analysis, and interpretation of the transcranial evoked potentials (TEPs). Therefore, this work offers an extensive overview of TMS-EEG methodology and thus may promote standardization of experimental and computational procedures across groups.(c) 2023 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
引用
收藏
页码:567 / 593
页数:27
相关论文
共 246 条
  • [1] Study design in MRI: Basic principles
    Amaro, E
    Barker, GJ
    [J]. BRAIN AND COGNITION, 2006, 60 (03) : 220 - 232
  • [2] CEREBELLOFRONTAL CORTICAL PROJECTIONS IN HUMANS STUDIED WITH THE MAGNETIC COIL
    AMASSIAN, VE
    CRACCO, RQ
    MACCABEE, PJ
    CRACCO, JB
    [J]. ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY AND CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 1992, 85 (04): : 265 - 272
  • [3] No correlation between moving phosphene and motor thresholds: a transcranial magnetic stimulation study
    Antal, A
    Nitsche, MA
    Kincses, TZ
    Lampe, C
    Paulus, W
    [J]. NEUROREPORT, 2004, 15 (02) : 297 - 302
  • [4] TMSEEG: A MATLAB-Based Graphical User Interface for Processing Electrophysiological Signals during Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation
    Atluri, Sravya
    Frehlich, Matthew
    Mei, Ye
    Dominguez, Luis Garcia
    Rogasch, Nigel C.
    Wong, Willy
    Daskalakis, Zafiris J.
    Farzan, Faranak
    [J]. FRONTIERS IN NEURAL CIRCUITS, 2016, 10
  • [5] Fast estimation of transcranial magnetic stimulation motor threshold: is it safe?
    Awiszus, Friedemann
    [J]. BRAIN STIMULATION, 2011, 4 (01) : 58 - 59
  • [6] Dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and anterior cingulate cortex white matter alterations in late-life depression
    Bae, Jae Nam
    MacFall, James R.
    Krishnan, K. Ranga R.
    Payne, Martha E.
    Steffens, David C.
    Taylor, Warren D.
    [J]. BIOLOGICAL PSYCHIATRY, 2006, 60 (12) : 1356 - 1363
  • [7] Electromagnetic brain mapping
    Baillet, S
    Mosher, JC
    Leahy, RM
    [J]. IEEE SIGNAL PROCESSING MAGAZINE, 2001, 18 (06) : 14 - 30
  • [8] BARKER AT, 1985, LANCET, V1, P1106
  • [9] Neuronavigation Increases the Physiologic and Behavioral Effects of Low-Frequency rTMS of Primary Motor Cortex in Healthy Subjects
    Bashir, S.
    Edwards, D.
    Pascual-Leone, A.
    [J]. BRAIN TOPOGRAPHY, 2011, 24 (01) : 54 - 64
  • [10] Belardinelli P, 2021, Scientific reports, V11, P1