Reframing Urban Nature-Based Solutions Through Perspectives of Environmental Justice and Privilege

被引:15
作者
Bauer, Willi [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Erlangen Nurnberg, Dept Geog, Erlangen, Germany
关键词
environmental justice; environmental privilege; Global North; green gentrification; just cities; nature-based solutions; ECOSYSTEM SERVICES; GREEN SPACE; GENTRIFICATION; DIRECTIONS; ADAPTATION; COMMUNITY; INEQUITY; HEALTH; CITY;
D O I
10.17645/up.v8i1.6018
中图分类号
TU98 [区域规划、城乡规划];
学科分类号
0814 ; 082803 ; 0833 ;
摘要
Since its introduction, the concept of "nature-based solutions" has gained much attention, drawing public funds and private investments. Nature-based solutions conceptualise the use of nature in planning as a cost-efficient and sustainable means to address societal, economic, and ecological challenges. However, this "triple win" premise tends to conceal potentially resulting injustices, such as displacement through green gentrification. While these injustices have attracted the atten-tion of environmental justice scholars, as exemplified by the "just green enough" approach, links to the "nature-based solutions" concept are mostly implicit. Further, the concept of environmental privilege, questioning who benefits from created natural amenities, has rarely been taken up. This article, therefore, argues that environmental justice should be linked closely to nature-based solutions. Supported by a theoretical perspective, the article aims at exploring who benefits from, and who loses out on, urban nature-based solutions processes. It builds on a qualitative literature review of the schol-arly landscape on environmental justice and urban greening while linking to nature-based solutions, adding perspectives of environmental privilege. In this, it attempts to offer three important contributions to the current academic discussion. First, the article provides an overview of the debate on urban greening, (in)justice, and environmental privilege. Second, it relates the concept of nature-based solutions to the debate on environmental justice, opening nature-based solutions up for critique and conceptual refinements. Third, it outlines a way forward for reframing nature-based solutions through the lens of environmental justice and privilege. Thus, this article provides a starting point for further discussions on the implementation of just nature-based solutions in cities.
引用
收藏
页码:334 / 345
页数:12
相关论文
共 50 条
[21]   Planning the multifunctionality of nature-based solutions in urban spaces [J].
Alves, Alida ;
van Opstal, Carlo ;
Keijzer, Nout ;
Sutton, Nora ;
Chen, Wei-Shan .
CITIES, 2024, 146
[22]   How deep does justice go? Addressing ecological, indigenous, and infrastructural justice through nature-based solutions in New York City [J].
Grabowski, Zbigniew Jakub ;
Wijsman, Katinka ;
Tomateo, Claudia ;
McPhearson, Timon .
ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE & POLICY, 2022, 138 :171-181
[23]   Environmental inequalities and heterogeneity in preferences for nature-based solutions [J].
Herivaux, Cecile ;
Le Coent, Philippe .
DEVELOPPEMENT DURABLE & TERRITOIRES, 2023, 14 (02)
[24]   Dataset of urban nature games to aid integrating nature-based solutions in urban planning [J].
Istrate, Aura-Luciana ;
Hamel, Perrine .
DATA IN BRIEF, 2023, 51
[25]   Integral recovery of an urban watershed through the implementation of nature-based solutions [J].
Bonilla Brenes, Ricardo ;
Hack, Jochen ;
Morales, Martin ;
Oreamuno, Rafael .
FRONTIERS IN SUSTAINABILITY, 2024, 5
[26]   Realizing multispecies justice through a capability approach to promote nature-based solutions [J].
Pineda-Pinto, Melissa ;
Lennon, Mick ;
Kennedy, Christopher ;
O'Donnell, Mairead ;
Andersson, Erik ;
Wijsman, Katinka ;
Collier, Marcus J. .
NPJ URBAN SUSTAINABILITY, 2025, 5 (01)
[27]   Nature-based solutions as discursive tools and contested practices in urban nature's neoliberalisation processes [J].
Kotsila, Panagiota ;
Anguelovski, Isabelle ;
Baro, Francesc ;
Langemeyer, Johannes ;
Sekulova, Filka ;
Connolly, James J. T. .
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING E-NATURE AND SPACE, 2021, 4 (02) :252-274
[28]   Identification of Agricultural Areas to Restore Through Nature-Based Solutions (NbS) [J].
Petti, Beatrice ;
Ottaviano, Marco .
LAND, 2024, 13 (11)
[29]   Distribution of Nature-based Solutions in cities across Europe [J].
Cooper, Clair ;
Cunningham, Niall ;
Bracken, Louise J. ;
Collier, Marcus .
LAND USE POLICY, 2024, 141
[30]   Applying multispecies justice in nature-based solutions and urban sustainability planning: Tensions and prospects [J].
Raymond, Christopher M. ;
Rautio, Pauliina ;
Fagerholm, Nora ;
Aaltonen, Valtteri A. ;
Andersson, Erik ;
Celermajer, Danielle ;
Christie, Mike ;
Haellfors, Maria ;
Saari, Maria Helena ;
Mishra, Himansu Sekhar ;
Lechner, Alex M. ;
Pineda-Pinto, Melissa ;
Schlosberg, David .
NPJ URBAN SUSTAINABILITY, 2025, 5 (01)