Is percutaneous drainage better than endoscopic drainage in the management of patients with malignant obstructive jaundice? A meta-analysis of RCTs

被引:2
|
作者
Bian, Cnogwen [1 ,2 ]
Fang, Yuan [1 ]
Xia, Jun [3 ]
Shi, Lan [4 ]
Huang, Hanfei [1 ]
Xiong, Qiru [5 ]
Wu, Ruolin [6 ]
Zeng, Zhong [1 ]
机构
[1] Kunming Med Univ, Dept Gen Surg, Affiliated Hosp 1, Kunming, Peoples R China
[2] Univ Hong Kong, Li Ka Shing Fac Med, Dept Surg, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[3] Anhui Med Univ, Dept Gen Surg, Affiliated Hosp 1, Hefei, Peoples R China
[4] Zhejiang Chinese Med Univ, Dept Clin Med Coll 4, Hangzhou, Zhejiang, Peoples R China
[5] Anhui Med Univ, Dept Gen Surg, Affiliated Hosp 2, Hefei, Peoples R China
[6] Anhui Med Univ, Organ Transplantat Ctr, Dept Hepatopancreatobiliary Surg, Dept Gen Surg,Affiliated Hosp 1, Hefei, Peoples R China
来源
FRONTIERS IN ONCOLOGY | 2023年 / 13卷
基金
中国国家自然科学基金;
关键词
ERCP; PTCD; Malignant obstructive jaundice; Procedure-related complication; Meta-analysis; PREOPERATIVE BILIARY DRAINAGE; RANDOMIZED-TRIAL; RISK-FACTORS;
D O I
10.3389/fonc.2023.1105728
中图分类号
R73 [肿瘤学];
学科分类号
100214 ;
摘要
To compare the safety and efficacy of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography (ERCP) and percutaneous transhepatic cholangial drainage (PTCD) in the treatment of malignant obstructive jaundice, a systematic review and meta-analysis of published studies was undertaken to assess the differences between the two procedures in terms of efficacy and safety. From November 2000 to November 2022, the Embase, PubMed, MEDLINE, and Cochrane databases were searched for randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on the treatment of malignant obstructive jaundice with ERCP or PTCD. Two investigators independently assessed the quality of the included studies and extracted the data. Six RCTs, including 407 patients, were included. The results of the meta-analysis showed that the overall technical success rate in the ERCP group was significantly lower than that in the PTCD group (Z=3.19, P=0.001, OR=0.31 (95% CI: 0.15-0.64)), but with a higher overall procedure-related complication incidence rate (Z=2.57, P=0.01, OR=0.55 (95% CI: 0.34-0.87)). The incidence of procedure-related pancreatitis in the ERCP group was higher than that in the PTCD group (Z=2.80, P=0.005, OR=5.29 (95% CI: 1.65-16.97)), and the differences were statistically significant. No significant difference was observed between the two groups when the clinical efficacy, postoperative cholangitis, and bleeding rate were compared.Both treatments for malignant obstructive jaundice were efficacious and safe. However, the PTCD group had a greater technique success rate and a lower incidence of postoperative pancreatitis.The present meta-analysis has been registered in PROSPERO
引用
收藏
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Percutaneous biliary stent combined with brachytherapy using 125I seeds for treatment of unresectable malignant obstructive jaundice: A meta-analysis
    Chen, Wei-Yue
    Kong, Chun-Li
    Meng, Miao-Miao
    Chen, Wei-Qian
    Zheng, Li-Yun
    Mao, Jian-Ting
    Fang, Shi-Ji
    Chen, Li
    Shu, Gao-Feng
    Yang, Yang
    Weng, Qiao-You
    Chen, Min-Jiang
    Xu, Min
    Ji, Jian-Song
    WORLD JOURNAL OF CLINICAL CASES, 2021, 9 (35) : 10979 - 10993
  • [42] Endoscopic ultrasound-guided vs endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography biliary drainage for obstructed distal malignant biliary strictures: A systematic review and meta-analysis
    Logiudice, Fernanda P.
    Bernardo, Wanderlei M.
    Galetti, Facundo
    Sagae, Vitor M.
    Matsubayashi, Carolina O.
    Madruga Neto, Antonio C.
    Brunaldi, Vitor O.
    de Moura, Diogo T. H.
    Franzini, Tomazo
    Cheng, Spencer
    Matuguma, Sergio E.
    de Moura, Eduardo G. H.
    WORLD JOURNAL OF GASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY, 2019, 11 (04): : 281 - 291
  • [43] Biliary Drainage in Patients With Unresectable, Malignant Obstruction Where ERCP Fails Endoscopic Ultrasonography-Guided Choledochoduodenostomy Versus Percutaneous Drainage
    Artifon, Everson L. A.
    Aparicio, Dayse
    Paione, Jose B.
    Lo, Simon K.
    Bordini, Andre
    Rabello, Carolina
    Otoch, Jose P.
    Gupta, Kapil
    JOURNAL OF CLINICAL GASTROENTEROLOGY, 2012, 46 (09) : 768 - 774
  • [44] Effects of different preoperative biliary drainage methods for resected malignant obstruction jaundice on the incidence rate of implantation metastasis: A meta-analysis
    Yang, Gang
    Xiong, Yongfu
    Sun, Ji
    Tang, Tao
    Li, Weinan
    Wang, Guan
    Li, Jingdong
    ONCOLOGY LETTERS, 2020, 20 (03) : 2217 - 2224
  • [45] Percutaneous transthoracic catheter drainage for lung abscess: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Lee, Jong Hyuk
    Hong, Hyunsook
    Tamburrini, Mario
    Park, Chang Min
    EUROPEAN RADIOLOGY, 2022, 32 (02) : 1184 - 1194
  • [46] Percutaneous transthoracic catheter drainage for lung abscess: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Jong Hyuk Lee
    Hyunsook Hong
    Mario Tamburrini
    Chang Min Park
    European Radiology, 2022, 32 : 1184 - 1194
  • [47] Effect of the drainage of cerebrospinal fluid in patients with aneurismal subarachnoid hemorrhage: A meta-analysis
    Qian, Cong
    Yu, Xiaobo
    Chen, Jingyin
    Gu, Chi
    Wang, Lin
    Chen, Gao
    Dai, Yuying
    MEDICINE, 2016, 95 (41)
  • [48] Primary drainage of distal malignant biliary obstruction: A comparative network meta-analysis
    Lauri, Gaetano
    Archibugi, Livia
    Arcidiacono, Paolo Giorgio
    Repici, Alessandro
    Hassan, Cesare
    Capurso, Gabriele
    Facciorusso, Antonio
    DIGESTIVE AND LIVER DISEASE, 2024, 56 (12) : 2004 - 2010
  • [49] Choledochoduodenostomy Versus Hepaticogastrostomy in Endoscopic Ultrasound-guided Drainage for Malignant Biliary Obstruction: A Meta-analysis and Systematic Review
    Mao, Kejie
    Hu, Binbin
    Sun, Feng
    Wan, Kaiming
    SURGICAL LAPAROSCOPY ENDOSCOPY & PERCUTANEOUS TECHNIQUES, 2022, 32 (01): : 124 - 132
  • [50] A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Intraluminal Brachytherapy Versus Stent Alone in the Treatment of Malignant Obstructive Jaundice
    Xu, Xinjian
    Li, Jingjing
    Wu, Juan
    Zhu, Rui
    Ji, Wenbin
    CARDIOVASCULAR AND INTERVENTIONAL RADIOLOGY, 2018, 41 (02) : 206 - 217