The Stonehenge bluestones did not come from Waun Mawn in West Wales

被引:0
作者
John, Brian [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Durham, Dept Geog, Durham, England
[2] Univ Durham, Dept Geog, Newport SA42 0QN, Pembroke, England
关键词
archaeology; bluestones; glacial geomorphology; glacial sediments; Holocene; neolithic; quaternary; standing stones; stone circle; Stonehenge; Wales; Waun Mawn; GEOCHEMISTRY;
D O I
10.1177/09596836241236318
中图分类号
P9 [自然地理学];
学科分类号
0705 ; 070501 ;
摘要
This paper examines the hypothesis that Waun Mawn in West Wales provided the bluestone monoliths that were used at Stonehenge. Some archaeologists believe that the site supports the last remains of a giant stone circle or 'Proto Stonehenge' which was dismantled and transported to Salisbury Plain around 5000 years ago. It was claimed, after three excavation seasons at Waun Mawn in 2017, 2018 and 2021, that there is firm evidence of some standing stones which were later removed or broken up, but it has still not been demonstrated that there ever was a small stone circle here, let alone a 'giant' one. Furthermore, there have been no control studies in the neighbourhood which might demonstrate that the speculative feature has any unique characteristics. There is nothing at Waun Mawn to link this site in any way to Stonehenge, and this is confirmed by recent cited research. No evidence has been brought forward in support of the claim that 'this was one of the great religious and political centres of Neolithic Britain'. It is concluded that at Waun Mawn and elsewhere in West Wales there has been substantial 'interpretative inflation' driven by the desire to demonstrate a Stonehenge connection.
引用
收藏
页码:895 / 907
页数:13
相关论文
共 13 条
  • [1] Identification of the source of dolerites used at the Waun Mawn stone circle in the Mynydd Preseli, west Wales and implications for the proposed link with Stonehenge
    Bevins, Richard E.
    Pearce, Nick J. G.
    Pearson, Mike Parker
    Ixer, Rob A.
    JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCE-REPORTS, 2022, 45
  • [2] How Waun Mawn stone circle was designed and built, and when the Bluestones arrived at Stonehenge: a response to Darvill
    Parker Pearson, Mike
    Pollard, Josh
    Richards, Colin
    Welham, Kate
    Kinnaird, Timothy
    Srivastava, Aayush
    Casswell, Chris
    Shaw, Dave
    Simmons, Ellen
    Stanford, Adam
    Bevins, Richard
    Ixer, Rob
    Ruggles, Clive
    Rylatt, Jim
    Edinborough, Kevan
    ANTIQUITY, 2022, 96 (390) : 1530 - 1537
  • [3] Mythical rings? Waun Mawn and Stonehenge Stage 1
    Darvill, Timothy
    ANTIQUITY, 2022, 96 (390) : 1515 - 1529
  • [4] The original Stonehenge? A dismantled stone circle in the Preseli Hills of west Wales
    Pearson, Mike Parker
    Pollard, Josh
    Richards, Colin
    Welham, Kate
    Kinnaird, Timothy
    Shaw, Dave
    Simmons, Ellen
    Stanford, Adam
    Bevins, Richard
    Ixer, Rob
    Ruggles, Clive
    Rylatt, Jim
    Edinborough, Kevan
    ANTIQUITY, 2021, 95 (379) : 85 - 103
  • [5] Lithological description and provenancing of a collection of bluestones from excavations at Stonehenge by William Hawley in 1924 with implications for the human versus ice transport debate of the monument's bluestone megaliths
    Bevins, Richard
    Ixer, Rob
    Pearce, Nick
    Scourse, James
    Daw, Tim
    GEOARCHAEOLOGY-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL, 2023, 38 (06): : 771 - 785
  • [6] Reconstructing extraction techniques at Stonehenge's bluestone megalith quarries in the Preseli hills of west Wales
    Pearson, Mike Parker
    Bevins, Richard
    Pearce, Nick
    Ixer, Rob
    Pollard, Josh
    Richards, Colin
    Welham, Kate
    JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCE-REPORTS, 2022, 46
  • [7] Portable XRF investigation of Stonehenge Stone 62 and potential source dolerite outcrops in the Mynydd Preseli, west Wales
    Pearce, Nick J. G.
    Bevins, Richard E.
    Ixer, Rob A.
    JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL SCIENCE-REPORTS, 2022, 44
  • [8] Beyond Stonehenge: Carn Menyn Quarry and the origin and date of bluestone extraction in the Preseli Hills of south-west Wales
    Darvill, Timothy
    Wainwright, Geoff
    ANTIQUITY, 2014, 88 (342) : 1099 - 1114
  • [9] The "Coastal Cajamarca" style did not come from the coast
    Tsai, Howard
    NAWPA PACHA, 2019, 39 (01): : 121 - 144
  • [10] Early Ordovician brachiopods from south-west Wales
    Cocks, L. Robin M.
    Popov, Leonid E.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE GEOLOGISTS ASSOCIATION, 2019, 130 (06) : 677 - 690