The role of the depth of resection of the distal tibia on biomechanical performance of the tibial component for TAR: A finite element analysis with three implant designs

The depth of resection of the tibia bone in total ankle replacement (TAR) may influence implant-bone micro-motion and stress shielding. High implant-bone micromotion and stress-shielding lead to aseptic loosening of the tibial component for TAR. The aim was to improve the outcomes of the different designs of TAR (STAR, Mobility, and Salto) with the variation of the depth of resection of the distal tibia bone. Finite element (FE) models of the implanted tibia with the depth of resection varying from 6 mm to 16 mm and of the intact tibia was prepared. The value of micromotion increased as the depth of resection increased. The micromotion increased in the proximal anterior-posterior portion of the pegs for STAR, the posterior part of the stem for Mobility, and the proximal lateral portion of the keel for Salto with the increase in the depth of resection. Whereas, the stresses (von Mises) decreased in some regions and increased in some regions depending upon the implant design. But overall stresses decreased in the tibia bone. Furthermore, the mean stress shielding increased in all the designs as the depth of resection increased. This in silico study indicated that the depth of resection should be given more importance during TAR surgery. The ideal depth of resection should be minimum i.e., 6 mm based on this FE study.