Obtaining SF-6D utilities from FACT-H&N in thyroid carcinoma patients: development and results from a mapping study

Objective: There is limited evidence for mapping clinical tools to preference-based generic tools in the Chinese thyroid cancer patient population. The current study aims to map the FACT-H&N (Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Head and Neck Cancer) to the SF-6D (Short Form Six-Dimension), which will inform future cost-utility analyses related to thyroid cancer treatment. Methods: A total of 1050 participants who completed the FACT-H&N and SF-6D questionnaires were included in the analysis. Four methods of direct and indirect mapping were estimated: OLS regression, Tobit regression, ordered probit regression, and beta mixture regression. We evaluated the predictive performance in terms of root mean square error (RMSE), mean absolute error (MAE), concordance correlation coefficient (CCC), Akaike information criterion (AIC) and Bayesian information criterion (BIC) and the correlation between the observed and predicted SF-6D scores. Results: The mean value of SF-6D was 0.690 (SD = 0.128). The RMSE values for the fivefold cross-validation as well as the 30% random sample validation for multiple models in this study were 0.0833-0.0909, MAE values were 0.0676-0.0782, and CCC values were 0.6940-0.7161. SF-6D utility scores were best predicted by a regression model consisting of the total score of each dimension of the FACT-H&N, the square of the total score of each dimension, and covariates including age and gender. We proposed to use direct mapping (OLS regression) and indirect mapping (ordered probit regression) to establish a mapping model of FACT-H&N to SF-6D. The mean SF-6D and cumulative distribution functions simulated from the recommended mapping algorithm generally matched the observed ones. Conclusions: In the absence of preference-based quality of life tools, obtaining the health status utility of thyroid cancer patients from directly mapped OLS regression and indirectly mapped ordered probit regression is an effective alternative.